Asset-Based Community Development (ABCD) as practiced has almost never treated a mountain’s capacity to hold and release water as a community asset; the communities that do so govern their catchments through commons, customary, Indigenous and reciprocity traditions, and the evidence they offer is strongest for persistence and decision rights and weakest for measured downstream water.
Overview
This brief codes 46 cases on six continents in which a community mobilized a living system in a mountain or upland catchment. For each case it records who began the work, who holds the land and the rules, who pays whom and on what trigger, what was measured, and what failed. It builds on three earlier runs: Retention Works on the Slope, Unproven at the River, Community-Led Landscape Restoration in Sub-Saharan Africa and Exclusion from Water Finance. It uses their hydrology grades and does not re-argue them.
The case base splits cleanly. Only three ABCD cases involve natural assets at all, and all three treat land, trees or water points as inputs to livelihoods. The cases in which a community names and governs the mountain’s water function belong to other traditions: the acequias de careo of Sierra Nevada in Spain, the amunas (mamanteo) of the Peruvian Andes, the Alpine commons of Törbel and Cortina d’Ampezzo, the acequias of northern New Mexico, Bali’s subak, Sikkim’s dhara (springs) and the Tigray exclosures. Several of these peoples hold the mountain as kin or deity, and the brief reports that relationship in their terms.
A practitioner can safely take the following from the evidence. Water benefits are measurable at springs, wells and aquifers. Catchment-scale benefits are modeled or claimed. Governance outcomes, meaning who decides and for how long, are documented for centuries in some commons and for under a decade in most payment schemes. Arrangements funded by a utility or donor under rules set elsewhere have repeatedly been redirected, suspended or ended.
The Water Retention Landscapes concept supplies the physical reading of a mountain as a sponge (see also water retention landscape). This brief asks the question the physical reading leaves open: who holds the sponge.
This page describes communities, practitioners, NGOs, utilities, state programs and research organizations only through their published records and statements. None has yet been invited to comment. Corrections and responses will be recorded on this page. On this site, [MS] marks a claim that rests on the account of the party the claim is about or on the wiki’s own project documents. Money is given in the currency and year reported.
ABCD and its limits
Kretzmann and McKnight’s 1993 asset map has six categories: individual gifts, associations, local institutions, physical space, economic exchange and culture. Natural systems appear only inside “physical space”. The Community Capitals Framework (Emery and Flora 2006) adds natural capital as a separate capital, but its cases are mostly rural United States towns.
MacLeod and Emejulu (2014) argue from Scottish practice that ABCD is “neoliberalism with a community face”, fitting austerity because it asks communities to supply what the state withdrew. DeFilippis, Fisher and Shragge (2010) argue more generally that community-building approaches avoid conflict over ownership and power.
The cases here support a narrower version of that critique. ABCD rarely touches tenure, so it rarely reaches the question of who owns a mountain. Mathie, Cameron and Gibson (2017) defend asset-based practice as a way of building citizen-led power.
What the syntheses conclude
Coady Institute ABCD evaluations. In Ethiopia, the ABCD program run with Oxfam Canada, Hundee, KMG Ethiopia and Agri-Service Ethiopia grew from five groups in 2003 to 24 in 2011. The groups mapped natural resources on their asset maps. Comparing the 2008 and 2011 maps “did not reveal many changes in the natural resource base or physical infrastructure” (Peters 2013, p. 19). The reported changes were one group terracing land, one group securing extra land, and Ilu Aga reviving a traditional irrigation practice, planting one hectare of trees and digging three wells and three boreholes, mostly with its own resources [MS]. No water measurement was made.
The Kenyan Makutano case shows the strongest ABCD-framed water governance found. It has 26 water points (nine dams and 17 sub-surface wells), each run by an elected committee registered as its own community-based organization with its own bank account, and members pay 250 Kenya shillings a year (Mahomed and Peters 2011) [MS]. Makutano is in semi-arid lowland Yatta, outside any mountain catchment. From Clients to Citizens (Mathie and Cunningham 2008) contains no case that governs a catchment.
Commons scholarship. Ostrom (1990) drew her design principles partly from Alpine commons (Törbel) and irrigation systems (Spanish huertas, Philippine zanjeras). Cox, Arnold and Villamayor-Tomás (2010) reviewed 91 studies and found the principles broadly supported. They reformulated them by splitting the boundary and congruence principles, and they noted acequias in New Mexico as an example. The reviewers flag that the principles describe structure and say less about trust and legitimacy, and that they are prone to being generalized beyond their cases.
Mountain water towers. Immerzeel et al. (2020) ranked 78 global water towers by importance and vulnerability. Viviroli et al. (2020) project that about 1.5 billion people, 24% of the world’s lowland population, will depend critically on runoff from mountains by the mid-twenty-first century, up from about 0.2 billion (7%) in the 1960s. South Africa’s equivalent category is the strategic water source area. This literature establishes the asset physically and is silent on community tenure.
Payments and reciprocity. The water finance exclusion run found that water funds mostly keep rural stewards off boards, and that Mexico’s hydrological payments reached poor ejidos because ejidos hold the forest. The cases here add one randomized test of a reciprocal water agreement, a form of payment for ecosystem services (Watershared, Bolivia) and one long-term persistence test (Oaxaca, Mexico), both summarized below.
Territories of life and biocultural heritage. The ICCA Consortium and the UNEP-WCMC registry document community-conserved areas, which the Consortium calls territories of life. IIED and ANDES document biocultural heritage territories such as the Potato Park in Cusco. These sources record governance, and none of them was designed to measure water.
The distinctions
- ABCD by name versus kindred practice. Three rows are ABCD-labeled or ABCD-framed. The other 43 follow commons, customary, Indigenous, reciprocity, state-program or water-fund lineages.
- Mapping versus governing. The Ethiopian ABCD groups mapped resources (weak form). Törbel, the Regole d’Ampezzo, New Mexico acequias and the subak hold rules, rights and sanctions (strong form).
- Naming versus measuring. Huamantanga’s comuneros located amuna outflow springs accurately before tracers confirmed them (Ochoa-Tocachi interview, National Geographic 2019). Sikkim’s Devithans are sacred springs protected from disturbance, recorded by Tambe et al. (2012) without discharge figures. Both are forms of Indigenous knowledge about the retention function.
- Local versus catchment gain, timing versus volume. Amunas and careo shift timing: water infiltrated in the wet season resurfaces weeks to months later. Neither adds rain.
- Commons versus market with a community owner. Bolivia’s reciprocal agreements pay individual landholders in kind through municipal water funds, a market-like contract inside community norms. Sierra Nevada careo is a commons run by irrigators’ communities.
- Kin versus infrastructure. For Tūhoe, Te Urewera is an ancestor; for Ngā Iwi o Taranaki, Taranaki Maunga (Mount Taranaki) is a tupuna. The settlements write that relationship into law. Sedapal describes the same kind of slope as “natural infrastructure”.
- Community-led versus externally led. Dhara Vikas is a state program under India’s rural employment scheme. Watershared was designed by Fundación Natura Bolivia. Abreha we Atsbeha combined community labor with state food-for-work and regional bureau planning.
Coordination is coded with the TIME Framework: T-form (Tribal), I-form (Institutional), M-form (Market) and E-form (Emergent).
Kindred traditions
Commons and irrigation communities
Users hold use rights and set rules on rotation, maintenance labor and sanctions (Ostrom 1990). Main cases: Törbel, Valais bisses, acequias de careo, New Mexico acequias, subak, aflaj. These differ from ABCD in starting from a bounded resource and a rulebook, and they count members by rights, which also excludes people.
Territories of life (ICCAs)
A people or community governs an area with a close relationship to it and achieves conservation outcomes (ICCA Consortium). Main cases: the Ogiek claim to the Mau, Te Urewera, the Potato Park. These start from self-determination and tenure claims.
Biocultural heritage territories
ANDES and IIED’s model combines customary law, landscape and genetic resources. The Potato Park, run by Quechua communities near Pisac, is the reference case. Water is part of the territory and has not been measured.
Reciprocal water agreements
Downstream users pay upstream landholders in kind to protect forest and springs, through a local fund under municipal and cooperative rules (Asquith, Vargas and Wunder 2008). Bétrisey and Mager (2014) describe ayni and minka reciprocity norms shaping the agreements in Florida Province.
Springshed management
Hydrogeological mapping of a spring’s recharge area (its springshed) is followed by recharge works, often with para-hydrogeologists trained from the village (Tambe et al. 2012; ACWADAM; People’s Science Institute). It names the retention function most explicitly of any tradition found, and is usually state-led or NGO-led. The wiki’s watershed mapping entry covers the mapping step.
Rights of nature and legal personhood
Statute makes the mountain or river a legal person with a joint iwi-Crown voice (Te Urewera Act 2014, Te Awa Tupua Act 2017, Taranaki Maunga Collective Redress Act 2025). It changes standing and governance, and so far nothing has been measured about water.
Siembra y cosecha de agua (sowing and harvesting water)
The Andean and Iberian practice of diverting wet-season or snowmelt water onto permeable slopes to recharge aquifers (amunas, careo, qochas). Jódar, Martos-Rosillo and colleagues (2022) link the Iberian and Andean forms explicitly.
Traditions not reached
Indigenous Protected Areas, community land trusts holding catchment land and watershed councils were in the run’s search list. Eigg is the only land trust row, at [TBV], and no watershed council or Indigenous Protected Area case was verified.
Cases by mountain system
The case narratives for each region are on the regional pages of the case register. Each page tells how its cases began, who holds the mountain, how value flows, what the evidence shows and what failed, and embeds a table of the region’s cases.
- Andes (7 cases). Andean comunidades have revived pre-Inca recharge canals and restored high wetlands, and Bolivian municipalities have set up reciprocal agreements with downstream users; in most of these cases a utility, a water fund or an NGO holds the money.
- Mexico and North America (4 cases). Mexican comunidades hold their forests and the payments made for them, New Mexico acequias run a centuries-old irrigation commons, and Catskills farmers supply New York City under the city’s agreement.
- Iberia, the Mediterranean and Arabia (5 cases). Irrigators’ communities in Sierra Nevada maintain snowmelt recharge channels with measured aquifer effects, while customary systems in the Atlas and Oman are weakening under state forestry and private wells.
- Alps and Europe (6 cases). Alpine commons such as Törbel and the Regole d’Ampezzo have held forests, pastures and water under their own statutes for centuries, with membership rules that also exclude newcomers.
- Himalaya (5 cases). Springshed programs in the Indian Himalaya name the mountain’s recharge function most precisely of any tradition found, and most are led by the state or NGOs.
- Southeast and East Asia (4 cases). Terrace and water-temple systems in Bali, the Cordillera and Yunnan have coordinated mountain water for centuries and are now losing land and water to tourism and labor to out-migration.
- Africa (12 cases). African mountain catchments appear in the register mostly as state land, water-fund project sites or contested territories, and the communities in them seldom hold the money.
- Oceania (3 cases). Aotearoa New Zealand’s settlements made a forest, a river and a mountain legal persons with iwi-Crown governance; no change in water has yet been measured.
The case table
The 46 cases are held in the Community Catchment Case Register, one page per case, and the table below is built from those pages. Each case page gives the full coding, its sources and its right-of-reply note. The register page explains the asset codes (A1 to A8), the beyond-market markers (B1 to B8), the evidence levels (E1 to E5) and the filter keys.
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Beyond-market markers | Water evidence | Community evidence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mountain region Africa12 | |||||||
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Northern highlands | state-program | B2 | E3 | E5 | [IC] |
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Nyando uplands | abcd-by-name | B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Highlands | abcd-by-name | B2 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | state-program | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | Maloti | state-program | E4 | E4 | [IC] | |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | ngo-program | B6 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | abcd-framed | B2, B4, B8 | E5 | E5 | [MS] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Drakensberg-Maloti | negotiated-payments | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | Mau escarpment | territory-of-life | B1 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Cherangany Hills | territory-of-life | B1 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | Drakensberg foothills | state-program | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | water-fund | E5 | E5 | [MS] | |
| Mountain region Iberia, Mediterranean and Arabia5 | |||||||
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Sierra Nevada | commons | B1, B2 | E2 | E5 | [IC] |
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | Hajar | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | High Atlas | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Sierra Nevada | commons | B2 | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | Turia from Iberian ranges | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Mexico and North America4 | |||||||
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande | commons | B1, B2 | E3 | E4 | [IC] |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Sierra Juárez | community-forestry | B1, B2, B4, B6, B8 | E2 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | Sierra Madre and others | state-program | B4, B8 | E2 | E2 | [IC] |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | Catskills | negotiated-payments | B7, B8 | E2 | E5 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Himalaya6 | |||||||
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Western/Central Himalaya | ngo-program | B2 | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Trans-Himalaya | practitioner-innovation | B2 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | Central Himalaya | community-forestry | B2, B4, B8 | E4 | E2 | [IC] |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Eastern Himalaya | state-program | E3 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | negotiated-payments | B3, B4, B7 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | negotiated-payments | B3, B4, B7 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Alps and Europe6 | |||||||
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | Eastern Alps | commons | B1 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | Island uplands | community-land-trust | B1, B2, B6 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | Dolomites | commons | B1, B2, B4, B8 | E5 | E5 | [MS] |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | Carpathians | state-program | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Andes7 | |||||||
| Amunas of Huarochirí | Peru | Western Andes, Rímac/Chillón headwaters | customary | B1, B2 | E4 | E5 | [IC] |
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | Northern Andes páramo | water-fund | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Los Negros Reciprocal Water Agreement | Bolivia | Eastern Andes valleys | reciprocity | B3, B4, B6 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | Western Andes, Santa Eulalia | state-program | B7 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Potato Park, Pisac | Peru | Central Andes | biocultural-heritage | B1, B2, B6 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Qochas of San Juan de Tarucani | Peru | Western Andes, Chili headwaters | state-program | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | Eastern Andes | reciprocity | B3, B4 | E1 | E1 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Southeast and East Asia4 | |||||||
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Ailao Mountains | customary | B2 | E5 | E5 | [TBV] |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | Cordillera | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | Central uplands | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E2 | [IC] |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | Batur, Batukaru volcanoes | customary | B1, B2 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Oceania3 | |||||||
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | Tongariro to sea | legal-personhood | B1, B2, B5 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | Taranaki volcanic peaks | legal-personhood | B1, B5, B8 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | Te Urewera ranges | legal-personhood | B1, B2, B5, B8 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Beyond-market markers | Water evidence | Community evidence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Continent Africa13 | |||||||
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Northern highlands | state-program | B2 | E3 | E5 | [IC] |
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | High Atlas | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Nyando uplands | abcd-by-name | B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Highlands | abcd-by-name | B2 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | state-program | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | Maloti | state-program | E4 | E4 | [IC] | |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | ngo-program | B6 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | abcd-framed | B2, B4, B8 | E5 | E5 | [MS] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Drakensberg-Maloti | negotiated-payments | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | Mau escarpment | territory-of-life | B1 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Cherangany Hills | territory-of-life | B1 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | Drakensberg foothills | state-program | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | water-fund | E5 | E5 | [MS] | |
| Continent Europe9 | |||||||
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Sierra Nevada | commons | B1, B2 | E2 | E5 | [IC] |
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | Eastern Alps | commons | B1 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | Island uplands | community-land-trust | B1, B2, B6 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | Dolomites | commons | B1, B2, B4, B8 | E5 | E5 | [MS] |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Sierra Nevada | commons | B2 | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | Carpathians | state-program | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | Turia from Iberian ranges | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Continent North America4 | |||||||
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande | commons | B1, B2 | E3 | E4 | [IC] |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Sierra Juárez | community-forestry | B1, B2, B4, B6, B8 | E2 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | Sierra Madre and others | state-program | B4, B8 | E2 | E2 | [IC] |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | Catskills | negotiated-payments | B7, B8 | E2 | E5 | [IC] |
| Continent Asia11 | |||||||
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Western/Central Himalaya | ngo-program | B2 | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | Hajar | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Trans-Himalaya | practitioner-innovation | B2 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | Central Himalaya | community-forestry | B2, B4, B8 | E4 | E2 | [IC] |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Eastern Himalaya | state-program | E3 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Ailao Mountains | customary | B2 | E5 | E5 | [TBV] |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | Cordillera | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | Central uplands | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E2 | [IC] |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | negotiated-payments | B3, B4, B7 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | Batur, Batukaru volcanoes | customary | B1, B2 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | negotiated-payments | B3, B4, B7 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Continent South America7 | |||||||
| Amunas of Huarochirí | Peru | Western Andes, Rímac/Chillón headwaters | customary | B1, B2 | E4 | E5 | [IC] |
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | Northern Andes páramo | water-fund | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Los Negros Reciprocal Water Agreement | Bolivia | Eastern Andes valleys | reciprocity | B3, B4, B6 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | Western Andes, Santa Eulalia | state-program | B7 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Potato Park, Pisac | Peru | Central Andes | biocultural-heritage | B1, B2, B6 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Qochas of San Juan de Tarucani | Peru | Western Andes, Chili headwaters | state-program | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | Eastern Andes | reciprocity | B3, B4 | E1 | E1 | [IC] |
| Continent Oceania3 | |||||||
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | Tongariro to sea | legal-personhood | B1, B2, B5 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | Taranaki volcanic peaks | legal-personhood | B1, B5, B8 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | Te Urewera ranges | legal-personhood | B1, B2, B5, B8 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Beyond-market markers | Water evidence | Community evidence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mountain region Africa12 | |||||||
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Northern highlands | state-program | B2 | E3 | E5 | [IC] |
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Nyando uplands | abcd-by-name | B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Highlands | abcd-by-name | B2 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | state-program | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | Maloti | state-program | E4 | E4 | [IC] | |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | ngo-program | B6 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | abcd-framed | B2, B4, B8 | E5 | E5 | [MS] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Drakensberg-Maloti | negotiated-payments | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | Mau escarpment | territory-of-life | B1 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Cherangany Hills | territory-of-life | B1 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | Drakensberg foothills | state-program | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | water-fund | E5 | E5 | [MS] | |
| Mountain region Iberia, Mediterranean and Arabia5 | |||||||
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Sierra Nevada | commons | B1, B2 | E2 | E5 | [IC] |
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | Hajar | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | High Atlas | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Sierra Nevada | commons | B2 | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | Turia from Iberian ranges | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Mexico and North America4 | |||||||
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande | commons | B1, B2 | E3 | E4 | [IC] |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Sierra Juárez | community-forestry | B1, B2, B4, B6, B8 | E2 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | Sierra Madre and others | state-program | B4, B8 | E2 | E2 | [IC] |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | Catskills | negotiated-payments | B7, B8 | E2 | E5 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Himalaya6 | |||||||
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Western/Central Himalaya | ngo-program | B2 | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Trans-Himalaya | practitioner-innovation | B2 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | Central Himalaya | community-forestry | B2, B4, B8 | E4 | E2 | [IC] |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Eastern Himalaya | state-program | E3 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | negotiated-payments | B3, B4, B7 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | negotiated-payments | B3, B4, B7 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Alps and Europe6 | |||||||
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | Eastern Alps | commons | B1 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | Island uplands | community-land-trust | B1, B2, B6 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | Dolomites | commons | B1, B2, B4, B8 | E5 | E5 | [MS] |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | Carpathians | state-program | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Andes7 | |||||||
| Amunas of Huarochirí | Peru | Western Andes, Rímac/Chillón headwaters | customary | B1, B2 | E4 | E5 | [IC] |
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | Northern Andes páramo | water-fund | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Los Negros Reciprocal Water Agreement | Bolivia | Eastern Andes valleys | reciprocity | B3, B4, B6 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | Western Andes, Santa Eulalia | state-program | B7 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Potato Park, Pisac | Peru | Central Andes | biocultural-heritage | B1, B2, B6 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Qochas of San Juan de Tarucani | Peru | Western Andes, Chili headwaters | state-program | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | Eastern Andes | reciprocity | B3, B4 | E1 | E1 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Southeast and East Asia4 | |||||||
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Ailao Mountains | customary | B2 | E5 | E5 | [TBV] |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | Cordillera | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | Central uplands | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E2 | [IC] |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | Batur, Batukaru volcanoes | customary | B1, B2 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Oceania3 | |||||||
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | Tongariro to sea | legal-personhood | B1, B2, B5 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | Taranaki volcanic peaks | legal-personhood | B1, B5, B8 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | Te Urewera ranges | legal-personhood | B1, B2, B5, B8 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Region | Mountain system | Köppen | Rainfall | Lineage | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Country Ethiopia2 | |||||||
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Tigray | Northern highlands | BSh, Cwb | ~550 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Oromia, SNNPR | Highlands | Cwb | ~800-1,200 mm | abcd-by-name | [MS] |
| Country Spain3 | |||||||
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Granada (Alpujarra) | Sierra Nevada | Csb | ~600-800 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Granada | Sierra Nevada | Csb | ~700 mm | commons | [MS] |
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | Valencia | Turia from Iberian ranges | BSk, Csa | ~450 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Country United States2 | |||||||
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | NM and S Colorado | Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande | BSk, Dfb | ~300-500 mm | commons | [IC] |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | New York | Catskills | Dfb | ~1,100-1,300 mm | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Country India3 | |||||||
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Uttarakhand, Himachal | Western/Central Himalaya | Cwa, Cwb | ~1,200-2,000 mm | ngo-program | [MS] |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Ladakh | Trans-Himalaya | BWk | ~100 mm | practitioner-innovation | [IC] |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Sikkim | Eastern Himalaya | Cwb | ~1,500-3,000 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Country Oman1 | |||||||
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | — | Hajar | BWh | ~100-300 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Country Morocco1 | |||||||
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | High Atlas | High Atlas | Csb, BSk | ~500 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Country Austria1 | |||||||
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | Tyrol | Eastern Alps | Dfb | ~900-1,500 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Country Peru4 | |||||||
| Amunas of Huarochirí | Peru | Lima (Huarochirí, Canta) | Western Andes, Rímac/Chillón headwaters | Cwb, ET | ~400-700 mm | customary | [IC] |
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | Lima (Carampoma) | Western Andes, Santa Eulalia | ET | ~700 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Potato Park, Pisac | Peru | Cusco (Pisac) | Central Andes | Cwb | ~700 mm | biocultural-heritage | [IC] |
| Qochas of San Juan de Tarucani | Peru | Arequipa (Tarucani) | Western Andes, Chili headwaters | ET, BSk | ~350 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Country Kenya5 | |||||||
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Kisumu/Homa Bay | Nyando uplands | Aw, Cfb | ~1,200-1,500 mm | abcd-by-name | [IC] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Machakos (Yatta) | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | BSh | ~600 mm | abcd-framed | [MS] |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | Rift Valley | Mau escarpment | Cfb | ~1,200-2,000 mm | territory-of-life | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Elgeyo-Marakwet | Cherangany Hills | Cfb | ~1,200 mm | territory-of-life | [IC] |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Central | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | Cfb, Cwb | ~1,000-2,500 mm | water-fund | [MS] |
| Country Switzerland2 | |||||||
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | Valais | Pennine Alps | Dfb | ~550 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | Valais | Pennine Alps | Dfb | ~600 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Country Nepal1 | |||||||
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | mid-hills | Central Himalaya | Cwa, Cwb | ~1,500-2,500 mm | community-forestry | [IC] |
| Country Mexico2 | |||||||
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Oaxaca | Sierra Juárez | Cwb | ~1,000-1,500 mm | community-forestry | [IC] |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | national | Sierra Madre and others | — | — | state-program | [IC] |
| Country Ecuador1 | |||||||
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | Pichincha | Northern Andes páramo | ET, Cfb | ~1,000-1,500 mm | water-fund | [IC] |
| Country China1 | |||||||
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Yunnan | Ailao Mountains | Cwa, Cwb | ~1,400 mm | customary | [TBV] |
| Country Philippines1 | |||||||
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | Ifugao | Cordillera | Cfb, Am | ~3,000 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Country South Africa4 | |||||||
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Western Cape | Cape Fold Belt | Csb | ~600-3,000 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Eastern Cape | Cape Fold Belt | BSk, Cfb | ~250-700 mm | ngo-program | [MS] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Lesotho | Drakensberg-Maloti | Cwb | ~1,000-1,500 mm | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | KwaZulu-Natal | Drakensberg foothills | Cfb, Cwb | ~800-1,200 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Country Japan1 | |||||||
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | — | Central uplands | Cfa, Dfa | ~1,500-2,500 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Country United Kingdom1 | |||||||
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | Inner Hebrides | Island uplands | Cfb | ~1,500-2,000 mm | community-land-trust | [IC] |
| Country Lesotho1 | |||||||
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | — | Maloti | Cwb | ~700-1,200 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Country Bolivia2 | |||||||
| Los Negros Reciprocal Water Agreement | Bolivia | Santa Cruz (Pampagrande) | Eastern Andes valleys | Cwb | ~700 mm | reciprocity | [MS] |
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | Río Grande Valles Cruceños | Eastern Andes | Cwa, BSh | ~600-1,000 mm | reciprocity | [IC] |
| Country Bhutan2 | |||||||
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Paro (Namey Nichu, Tsento gewog) | Eastern Himalaya | Cwb | ~800 mm | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Mongar (Yakpugang) | Eastern Himalaya | Cwa | — | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Country Italy1 | |||||||
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | Belluno | Dolomites | Dfb | ~1,100 mm | commons | [MS] |
| Country Slovakia1 | |||||||
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | national | Carpathians | Dfb, Cfb | ~600-900 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Country Indonesia1 | |||||||
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | Bali | Batur, Batukaru volcanoes | Am | ~1,500-3,000 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Country New Zealand3 | |||||||
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | Manawatū-Whanganui | Tongariro to sea | Cfb | ~1,200-2,000 mm | legal-personhood | [IC] |
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | Taranaki | Taranaki volcanic peaks | Cfb | ~3,000 mm+ | legal-personhood | [IC] |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | Bay of Plenty | Te Urewera ranges | Cfb | ~2,000 mm+ | legal-personhood | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Region | Mountain system | Köppen | Rainfall | Lineage | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mountain system Northern highlands1 | |||||||
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Tigray | Northern highlands | BSh, Cwb | ~550 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Mountain system Sierra Nevada2 | |||||||
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Granada (Alpujarra) | Sierra Nevada | Csb | ~600-800 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Granada | Sierra Nevada | Csb | ~700 mm | commons | [MS] |
| Mountain system Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande1 | |||||||
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | NM and S Colorado | Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande | BSk, Dfb | ~300-500 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Mountain system Western/Central Himalaya1 | |||||||
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Uttarakhand, Himachal | Western/Central Himalaya | Cwa, Cwb | ~1,200-2,000 mm | ngo-program | [MS] |
| Mountain system Hajar1 | |||||||
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | — | Hajar | BWh | ~100-300 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Mountain system High Atlas1 | |||||||
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | High Atlas | High Atlas | Csb, BSk | ~500 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Mountain system Eastern Alps1 | |||||||
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | Tyrol | Eastern Alps | Dfb | ~900-1,500 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Mountain system Western Andes, Rímac/Chillón headwaters1 | |||||||
| Amunas of Huarochirí | Peru | Lima (Huarochirí, Canta) | Western Andes, Rímac/Chillón headwaters | Cwb, ET | ~400-700 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Mountain system Trans-Himalaya1 | |||||||
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Ladakh | Trans-Himalaya | BWk | ~100 mm | practitioner-innovation | [IC] |
| Mountain system Nyando uplands1 | |||||||
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Kisumu/Homa Bay | Nyando uplands | Aw, Cfb | ~1,200-1,500 mm | abcd-by-name | [IC] |
| Mountain system Pennine Alps2 | |||||||
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | Valais | Pennine Alps | Dfb | ~550 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | Valais | Pennine Alps | Dfb | ~600 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Mountain system Highlands1 | |||||||
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Oromia, SNNPR | Highlands | Cwb | ~800-1,200 mm | abcd-by-name | [MS] |
| Mountain system Central Himalaya1 | |||||||
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | mid-hills | Central Himalaya | Cwa, Cwb | ~1,500-2,500 mm | community-forestry | [IC] |
| Mountain system Sierra Juárez1 | |||||||
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Oaxaca | Sierra Juárez | Cwb | ~1,000-1,500 mm | community-forestry | [IC] |
| Mountain system Eastern Himalaya3 | |||||||
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Sikkim | Eastern Himalaya | Cwb | ~1,500-3,000 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Paro (Namey Nichu, Tsento gewog) | Eastern Himalaya | Cwb | ~800 mm | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Mongar (Yakpugang) | Eastern Himalaya | Cwa | — | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Mountain system Northern Andes páramo1 | |||||||
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | Pichincha | Northern Andes páramo | ET, Cfb | ~1,000-1,500 mm | water-fund | [IC] |
| Mountain system Ailao Mountains1 | |||||||
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Yunnan | Ailao Mountains | Cwa, Cwb | ~1,400 mm | customary | [TBV] |
| Mountain system Cordillera1 | |||||||
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | Ifugao | Cordillera | Cfb, Am | ~3,000 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Mountain system Cape Fold Belt2 | |||||||
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Western Cape | Cape Fold Belt | Csb | ~600-3,000 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Eastern Cape | Cape Fold Belt | BSk, Cfb | ~250-700 mm | ngo-program | [MS] |
| Mountain system Central uplands1 | |||||||
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | — | Central uplands | Cfa, Dfa | ~1,500-2,500 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Mountain system Island uplands1 | |||||||
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | Inner Hebrides | Island uplands | Cfb | ~1,500-2,000 mm | community-land-trust | [IC] |
| Mountain system Maloti1 | |||||||
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | — | Maloti | Cwb | ~700-1,200 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Mountain system Eastern Andes valleys1 | |||||||
| Los Negros Reciprocal Water Agreement | Bolivia | Santa Cruz (Pampagrande) | Eastern Andes valleys | Cwb | ~700 mm | reciprocity | [MS] |
| Mountain system Not mountain (semi-arid plain)1 | |||||||
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Machakos (Yatta) | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | BSh | ~600 mm | abcd-framed | [MS] |
| Mountain system Drakensberg-Maloti1 | |||||||
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Lesotho | Drakensberg-Maloti | Cwb | ~1,000-1,500 mm | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Mountain system Western Andes, Santa Eulalia1 | |||||||
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | Lima (Carampoma) | Western Andes, Santa Eulalia | ET | ~700 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Mountain system Sierra Madre and others1 | |||||||
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | national | Sierra Madre and others | — | — | state-program | [IC] |
| Mountain system Catskills1 | |||||||
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | New York | Catskills | Dfb | ~1,100-1,300 mm | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Mountain system Mau escarpment1 | |||||||
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | Rift Valley | Mau escarpment | Cfb | ~1,200-2,000 mm | territory-of-life | [IC] |
| Mountain system Central Andes1 | |||||||
| Potato Park, Pisac | Peru | Cusco (Pisac) | Central Andes | Cwb | ~700 mm | biocultural-heritage | [IC] |
| Mountain system Western Andes, Chili headwaters1 | |||||||
| Qochas of San Juan de Tarucani | Peru | Arequipa (Tarucani) | Western Andes, Chili headwaters | ET, BSk | ~350 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Mountain system Dolomites1 | |||||||
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | Belluno | Dolomites | Dfb | ~1,100 mm | commons | [MS] |
| Mountain system Cherangany Hills1 | |||||||
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Elgeyo-Marakwet | Cherangany Hills | Cfb | ~1,200 mm | territory-of-life | [IC] |
| Mountain system Carpathians1 | |||||||
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | national | Carpathians | Dfb, Cfb | ~600-900 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Mountain system Batur, Batukaru volcanoes1 | |||||||
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | Bali | Batur, Batukaru volcanoes | Am | ~1,500-3,000 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Mountain system Tongariro to sea1 | |||||||
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | Manawatū-Whanganui | Tongariro to sea | Cfb | ~1,200-2,000 mm | legal-personhood | [IC] |
| Mountain system Taranaki volcanic peaks1 | |||||||
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | Taranaki | Taranaki volcanic peaks | Cfb | ~3,000 mm+ | legal-personhood | [IC] |
| Mountain system Te Urewera ranges1 | |||||||
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | Bay of Plenty | Te Urewera ranges | Cfb | ~2,000 mm+ | legal-personhood | [IC] |
| Mountain system Turia from Iberian ranges1 | |||||||
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | Valencia | Turia from Iberian ranges | BSk, Csa | ~450 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Mountain system Drakensberg foothills1 | |||||||
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | KwaZulu-Natal | Drakensberg foothills | Cfb, Cwb | ~800-1,200 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Mountain system Aberdares, Mount Kenya1 | |||||||
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Central | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | Cfb, Cwb | ~1,000-2,500 mm | water-fund | [MS] |
| Mountain system Eastern Andes1 | |||||||
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | Río Grande Valles Cruceños | Eastern Andes | Cwa, BSh | ~600-1,000 mm | reciprocity | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Region | Mountain system | Köppen | Rainfall | Lineage | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Climate group arid7 | |||||||
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Tigray | Northern highlands | BSh, Cwb | ~550 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | NM and S Colorado | Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande | BSk, Dfb | ~300-500 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | — | Hajar | BWh | ~100-300 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Ladakh | Trans-Himalaya | BWk | ~100 mm | practitioner-innovation | [IC] |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Eastern Cape | Cape Fold Belt | BSk, Cfb | ~250-700 mm | ngo-program | [MS] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Machakos (Yatta) | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | BSh | ~600 mm | abcd-framed | [MS] |
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | Valencia | Turia from Iberian ranges | BSk, Csa | ~450 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Climate group mediterranean4 | |||||||
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Granada (Alpujarra) | Sierra Nevada | Csb | ~600-800 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | High Atlas | High Atlas | Csb, BSk | ~500 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Western Cape | Cape Fold Belt | Csb | ~600-3,000 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Granada | Sierra Nevada | Csb | ~700 mm | commons | [MS] |
| Climate group temperate24 | |||||||
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Uttarakhand, Himachal | Western/Central Himalaya | Cwa, Cwb | ~1,200-2,000 mm | ngo-program | [MS] |
| Amunas of Huarochirí | Peru | Lima (Huarochirí, Canta) | Western Andes, Rímac/Chillón headwaters | Cwb, ET | ~400-700 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Oromia, SNNPR | Highlands | Cwb | ~800-1,200 mm | abcd-by-name | [MS] |
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | mid-hills | Central Himalaya | Cwa, Cwb | ~1,500-2,500 mm | community-forestry | [IC] |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Oaxaca | Sierra Juárez | Cwb | ~1,000-1,500 mm | community-forestry | [IC] |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Sikkim | Eastern Himalaya | Cwb | ~1,500-3,000 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Yunnan | Ailao Mountains | Cwa, Cwb | ~1,400 mm | customary | [TBV] |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | Ifugao | Cordillera | Cfb, Am | ~3,000 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | — | Central uplands | Cfa, Dfa | ~1,500-2,500 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | Inner Hebrides | Island uplands | Cfb | ~1,500-2,000 mm | community-land-trust | [IC] |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | — | Maloti | Cwb | ~700-1,200 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Los Negros Reciprocal Water Agreement | Bolivia | Santa Cruz (Pampagrande) | Eastern Andes valleys | Cwb | ~700 mm | reciprocity | [MS] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Lesotho | Drakensberg-Maloti | Cwb | ~1,000-1,500 mm | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | Rift Valley | Mau escarpment | Cfb | ~1,200-2,000 mm | territory-of-life | [IC] |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Paro (Namey Nichu, Tsento gewog) | Eastern Himalaya | Cwb | ~800 mm | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Potato Park, Pisac | Peru | Cusco (Pisac) | Central Andes | Cwb | ~700 mm | biocultural-heritage | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Elgeyo-Marakwet | Cherangany Hills | Cfb | ~1,200 mm | territory-of-life | [IC] |
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | Manawatū-Whanganui | Tongariro to sea | Cfb | ~1,200-2,000 mm | legal-personhood | [IC] |
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | Taranaki | Taranaki volcanic peaks | Cfb | ~3,000 mm+ | legal-personhood | [IC] |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | Bay of Plenty | Te Urewera ranges | Cfb | ~2,000 mm+ | legal-personhood | [IC] |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | KwaZulu-Natal | Drakensberg foothills | Cfb, Cwb | ~800-1,200 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Central | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | Cfb, Cwb | ~1,000-2,500 mm | water-fund | [MS] |
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | Río Grande Valles Cruceños | Eastern Andes | Cwa, BSh | ~600-1,000 mm | reciprocity | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Mongar (Yakpugang) | Eastern Himalaya | Cwa | — | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Climate group continental6 | |||||||
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | Tyrol | Eastern Alps | Dfb | ~900-1,500 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | Valais | Pennine Alps | Dfb | ~550 mm | commons | [IC] |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | New York | Catskills | Dfb | ~1,100-1,300 mm | negotiated-payments | [IC] |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | Belluno | Dolomites | Dfb | ~1,100 mm | commons | [MS] |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | national | Carpathians | Dfb, Cfb | ~600-900 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | Valais | Pennine Alps | Dfb | ~600 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Climate group tropical2 | |||||||
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Kisumu/Homa Bay | Nyando uplands | Aw, Cfb | ~1,200-1,500 mm | abcd-by-name | [IC] |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | Bali | Batur, Batukaru volcanoes | Am | ~1,500-3,000 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Climate group polar-alpine3 | |||||||
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | Pichincha | Northern Andes páramo | ET, Cfb | ~1,000-1,500 mm | water-fund | [IC] |
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | Lima (Carampoma) | Western Andes, Santa Eulalia | ET | ~700 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Qochas of San Juan de Tarucani | Peru | Arequipa (Tarucani) | Western Andes, Chili headwaters | ET, BSk | ~350 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Climate group Uncategorized1 | |||||||
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | national | Sierra Madre and others | — | — | state-program | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Region | Mountain system | Köppen | Rainfall | Lineage | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Granada (Alpujarra) | Sierra Nevada | Csb | ~600-800 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | High Atlas | High Atlas | Csb, BSk | ~500 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Western Cape | Cape Fold Belt | Csb | ~600-3,000 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Granada | Sierra Nevada | Csb | ~700 mm | commons | [MS] |
| Case | Country | Region | Mountain system | Köppen | Rainfall | Lineage | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Tigray | Northern highlands | BSh, Cwb | ~550 mm | state-program | [IC] |
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | NM and S Colorado | Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande | BSk, Dfb | ~300-500 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | — | Hajar | BWh | ~100-300 mm | customary | [IC] |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Ladakh | Trans-Himalaya | BWk | ~100 mm | practitioner-innovation | [IC] |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Eastern Cape | Cape Fold Belt | BSk, Cfb | ~250-700 mm | ngo-program | [MS] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Machakos (Yatta) | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | BSh | ~600 mm | abcd-framed | [MS] |
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | Valencia | Turia from Iberian ranges | BSk, Csa | ~450 mm | commons | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Beyond-market markers | Water evidence | Community evidence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mountain region Africa6 | |||||||
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Northern highlands | state-program | B2 | E3 | E5 | [IC] |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | state-program | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | ngo-program | B6 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Drakensberg-Maloti | negotiated-payments | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | Drakensberg foothills | state-program | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | water-fund | E5 | E5 | [MS] | |
| Mountain region Iberia, Mediterranean and Arabia2 | |||||||
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Sierra Nevada | commons | B1, B2 | E2 | E5 | [IC] |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Sierra Nevada | commons | B2 | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Mountain region Himalaya3 | |||||||
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Western/Central Himalaya | ngo-program | B2 | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Trans-Himalaya | practitioner-innovation | B2 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Eastern Himalaya | state-program | E3 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Mountain region Andes4 | |||||||
| Amunas of Huarochirí | Peru | Western Andes, Rímac/Chillón headwaters | customary | B1, B2 | E4 | E5 | [IC] |
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | Northern Andes páramo | water-fund | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | Western Andes, Santa Eulalia | state-program | B7 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Qochas of San Juan de Tarucani | Peru | Western Andes, Chili headwaters | state-program | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Case | Country | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | state | Timber and fees to group fund | B2, B4, B8 | 30 yrs | [IC] |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | communal | Timber, PSAH, ecotourism into assembly | B1, B2, B4, B6, B8 | Community forestry 40+ yrs; PES effect faded | [IC] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | mixed | Users pay 250 KES/yr to committee accounts | B2, B4, B8 | 20+ yrs | [MS] |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | communal | Timber, rents and an annual regional contribution fund the Regole and the park (budget about €2 million a year); no revenue distributed to members beyond household rights to timber, pasture and firewood | B1, B2, B4, B8 | Medieval origins; natural park entrusted to the Regole in 1990; after the 2022 Marmolada collapse the assembly returned management of leased peaks, crags, trails and streams to the State Demanio, keeping its 16,000 ha of forest and pasture | [MS] |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | legal-personhood | Crown redress | B1, B2, B5, B8 | 12 yrs | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Los Negros Reciprocal Water Agreement | Bolivia | mixed | Irrigators, municipality, donors pay in kind into municipal fund | B3, B4, B6 | Over 20 years; spread to 5 countries [MS] | [MS] |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | mixed | Five hotels and the Satsham Water Association pay the Namey Nichu Watershed Management Group (29 households) Nu 142,000, only after the PES Verification Team confirms the agreed activities; the community forest group manages the money | B3, B4, B7 | First agreement ran 2016 to 2020; second phase under consultation from December 2018 | [IC] |
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | mixed | Water users, municipalities, donors: USD 1-10/ha/yr in kind + USD 100 joining | B3, B4 | Agreements continue | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | mixed | Mongar municipality pays the Yakpugang Community Forest Management Group (113 members) Nu 52,000 a year in the first three-year contract; Norten (2021) gives Nu 178,200 a year from town users and Nu 50,000 from Mongar Regional Referral Hospital | B3, B4, B7 | Contract renewed after the first three-year period | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | communal | Lima users pay 1% of bill; Sedapal contracts works; community paid labor and O&M | B7 | Fund continues; projects slow | [IC] |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | private | New York City pays cost-share for farm best management practices through the farmer-led Watershed Agricultural Council | B7, B8 | Whole Farm Program from 1992; Memorandum of Agreement 1997; Revised 2017 Filtration Avoidance Determination issued December 2022 | [IC] |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | mixed | Five hotels and the Satsham Water Association pay the Namey Nichu Watershed Management Group (29 households) Nu 142,000, only after the PES Verification Team confirms the agreed activities; the community forest group manages the money | B3, B4, B7 | First agreement ran 2016 to 2020; second phase under consultation from December 2018 | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | mixed | Mongar municipality pays the Yakpugang Community Forest Management Group (113 members) Nu 52,000 a year in the first three-year contract; Norten (2021) gives Nu 178,200 a year from town users and Nu 50,000 from Mongar Regional Referral Hospital | B3, B4, B7 | Contract renewed after the first three-year period | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | legal-personhood | NZD 80m redress + NZD 1m | B1, B2, B5 | 9 yrs | [IC] |
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | legal-personhood | Crown redress | B1, B5, B8 | 1 yr | [IC] |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | legal-personhood | Crown redress | B1, B2, B5, B8 | 12 yrs | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tenure state5 | ||||||
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | state | State food-for-work, PSNP, donors | B2 | 20+ yrs | [IC] |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | state | Community own resources; Bale Salka: govt 53%, community 36%, NGO 11% | B2 | Groups grew 5 to 24 | [MS] |
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | state | Timber and fees to group fund | B2, B4, B8 | 30 yrs | [IC] |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | state | South Africa pays royalties to the Lesotho state; with customs dues they made up 27.8% of government revenue (late 1990s); compensation to resettled households | 40 yrs | [IC] | |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | state | State pays municipalities for labor | Ended with funding | [IC] | |
| Tenure communal16 | ||||||
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | communal | Members' labor | B1, B2 | Centuries, many abandoned | [IC] |
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | communal | Members' labor and fees | B1, B2 | Centuries | [IC] |
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | communal | Donors, state | B2 | Ongoing | [MS] |
| Amunas of Huarochirí | Peru | communal | Donors, brewer, MERESE pay works; community labor; no outcome payment | B1, B2 | Festival maintenance in 3 known communities | [IC] |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | communal | Government agencies, the Watershed Development Programme, NGOs, Indian Army goodwill schemes and crowdfunding; INR 300,000 to 1,000,000 per structure | B2 | Built over about 30 years; performance varies by site and year | [IC] |
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | communal | Members, commune, tourism | B1, B2 | Irrigation since at least the 13th century; about 52.5% of channels in use run by consortages, 42.5% by municipalities | [IC] |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | communal | Timber, PSAH, ecotourism into assembly | B1, B2, B4, B6, B8 | Community forestry 40+ yrs; PES effect faded | [IC] |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | communal | None | B1, B2 | Reorganization peaked in FY1974 and has stayed low; surviving iriai groups still decide by unanimity | [IC] |
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | communal | Lima users pay 1% of bill; Sedapal contracts works; community paid labor and O&M | B7 | Fund continues; projects slow | [IC] |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | communal | Federal water fees: MXN 300-400/ha/yr to assemblies | B4, B8 | Program continues | [IC] |
| Potato Park, Pisac | Peru | communal | Community micro-enterprises (ecotourism, crafts, herbal products), mostly led by women; NGO and grant support | B1, B2, B6 | Set up after ANDES registered in 1995; still running | [IC] |
| Qochas of San Juan de Tarucani | Peru | communal | Arequipa water users pay through the MERESE tariff approved by Sunass; Sunass disbursed S/135,000 after the first year; Sedapar, Sernanp and Descosur carry out the works | Recent | [IC] | |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | communal | Timber, rents and an annual regional contribution fund the Regole and the park (budget about €2 million a year); no revenue distributed to members beyond household rights to timber, pasture and firewood | B1, B2, B4, B8 | Medieval origins; natural park entrusted to the Regole in 1990; after the 2022 Marmolada collapse the assembly returned management of leased peaks, crags, trails and streams to the State Demanio, keeping its 16,000 ha of forest and pasture | [MS] |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | communal | Volunteer labor organized by the University of Granada's MEMOLab with the irrigators' community | B2 | Restored in 2014 under the EU MEMOLA project with 180 volunteers and the irrigators' community, after more than 30 years of disuse; cleaned each year (2023, 2025, 23 May 2026) | [MS] |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | communal | Members | B1, B2 | 500+ yrs | [IC] |
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | communal | Members' fees | B1, B2 | Medieval to present; meets every Thursday at noon; UNESCO intangible heritage listing 2009 | [IC] |
| Tenure customary2 | ||||||
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | customary | Water shares held as timed turns (athar) and bought, sold and rented within the community (about USD 3,000 for 30 minutes a week in one village); a common right of one day's flow is rented at weekly auctions (Daris, al-Malki) or on annual contracts (al-Khatmeen) to fund maintenance | B1, B2 | Over 4,000 aflaj in the 1990s inventory, 3,000 in use; UNESCO listing 2006 | [IC] |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | customary | None | B1, B2 | On the List of World Heritage in Danger until 2012, when the Committee removed them and noted that sustained funding remains needed | [IC] |
| Tenure contested4 | ||||||
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | contested | None | B1, B2 | Long-standing; governance still functional and decided by representatives of the tribal fractions (Domínguez 2026); agdal forests in a neighboring valley gained cover where village agdals apply | [IC] |
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | contested | Rents disputed | B1 | Ongoing | [IC] |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | contested | KES ~157.8m reparations ordered, unpaid | B1 | Rulings stand; compliance judgment of 4 Dec 2025 found the 2017 judgment partly implemented and the 2022 reparations unpaid | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | contested | EU Kenya Water Towers programme (reported as USD 35 million) to Kenya's forest agencies; suspended January 2018, later ended | B1 | Evictions since 2009 under a 2013 resettlement decision; EU suspended its programme on 17 January 2018 | [IC] |
| Tenure private2 | ||||||
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | private | Donor-funded | B2 | Not verified | [IC] |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | private | New York City pays cost-share for farm best management practices through the farmer-led Watershed Agricultural Council | B7, B8 | Whole Farm Program from 1992; Memorandum of Agreement 1997; Revised 2017 Filtration Avoidance Determination issued December 2022 | [IC] |
| Tenure mixed14 | ||||||
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | mixed | MGNREGA wages | 15+ yrs | [IC] | |
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | mixed | Constituents' contributions build trust capital (about USD 12 million, 2016), whose returns fund about USD 2 million a year; communities receive in-kind project support and guardapáramo wages | Running since 2000 | [IC] | |
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | mixed | Main scenic area: Yunnan Shibo pays 10% of pre-tax ticket revenue to the county for villagers, who report receiving nothing (2014). Azheke: village company splits revenue 30% operations, 70% villagers; 12 dividend rounds totaling CNY 3.4525 million (CNY 53,116 per household) by October 2025 | B2 | Centuries | [TBV] |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | mixed | State and fund pay teams | Funding-dependent | [IC] | |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | mixed | Donors and partners fund restoration; the farmer-owned Baviaanskloof Development Company reports over €2.5 million raised | B6 | Partnership formed 2014 with a 20-year commitment | [MS] |
| Los Negros Reciprocal Water Agreement | Bolivia | mixed | Irrigators, municipality, donors pay in kind into municipal fund | B3, B4, B6 | Over 20 years; spread to 5 countries [MS] | [MS] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | mixed | Users pay 250 KES/yr to committee accounts | B2, B4, B8 | 20+ yrs | [MS] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | mixed | Not implemented at scale | Not launched | [IC] | |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | mixed | Five hotels and the Satsham Water Association pay the Namey Nichu Watershed Management Group (29 households) Nu 142,000, only after the PES Verification Team confirms the agreed activities; the community forest group manages the money | B3, B4, B7 | First agreement ran 2016 to 2020; second phase under consultation from December 2018 | [IC] |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | mixed | Members; tourism revenue rarely to farmers | B1, B2 | Centuries, under strain | [IC] |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | mixed | Municipal and utility budgets fund pilot projects led by uMgungundlovu, Msunduzi and eThekwini; no payment to upstream residents found | Memorandum of understanding signed by 21 parties in 2013; strategy adopted July 2016; SANBI lists 17 member organizations | [IC] | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | mixed | City utility, KenGen, firms, donors to trust; farmers get inputs | 10 yrs | [MS] | |
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | mixed | Water users, municipalities, donors: USD 1-10/ha/yr in kind + USD 100 joining | B3, B4 | Agreements continue | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | mixed | Mongar municipality pays the Yakpugang Community Forest Management Group (113 members) Nu 52,000 a year in the first three-year contract; Norten (2021) gives Nu 178,200 a year from town users and Nu 50,000 from Mongar Regional Referral Hospital | B3, B4, B7 | Contract renewed after the first three-year period | [IC] |
| Tenure trust1 | ||||||
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | trust | Residents pay for power from a GBP 1.6 million community grid funded by the trust, residents' fees, lottery, regional and EU grants; the trust owns the island, bought for GBP 1.5 million in 1997 | B1, B2, B6 | Community ownership since 1997; 24-hour renewable power from 1 February 2008 | [IC] |
| Tenure legal-personhood3 | ||||||
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | legal-personhood | NZD 80m redress + NZD 1m | B1, B2, B5 | 9 yrs | [IC] |
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | legal-personhood | Crown redress | B1, B5, B8 | 1 yr | [IC] |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | legal-personhood | Crown redress | B1, B2, B5, B8 | 12 yrs | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Beyond-market markers | Water evidence | Community evidence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lineage state-program9 | |||||||
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Northern highlands | state-program | B2 | E3 | E5 | [IC] |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Eastern Himalaya | state-program | E3 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | state-program | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | Maloti | state-program | E4 | E4 | [IC] | |
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | Western Andes, Santa Eulalia | state-program | B7 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | Sierra Madre and others | state-program | B4, B8 | E2 | E2 | [IC] |
| Qochas of San Juan de Tarucani | Peru | Western Andes, Chili headwaters | state-program | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | Carpathians | state-program | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | Drakensberg foothills | state-program | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Lineage commons9 | |||||||
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Sierra Nevada | commons | B1, B2 | E2 | E5 | [IC] |
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande | commons | B1, B2 | E3 | E4 | [IC] |
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | Eastern Alps | commons | B1 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | Central uplands | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E2 | [IC] |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | Dolomites | commons | B1, B2, B4, B8 | E5 | E5 | [MS] |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Sierra Nevada | commons | B2 | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | Turia from Iberian ranges | commons | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Lineage ngo-program2 | |||||||
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Western/Central Himalaya | ngo-program | B2 | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | ngo-program | B6 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Lineage customary6 | |||||||
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | Hajar | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | High Atlas | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Amunas of Huarochirí | Peru | Western Andes, Rímac/Chillón headwaters | customary | B1, B2 | E4 | E5 | [IC] |
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Ailao Mountains | customary | B2 | E5 | E5 | [TBV] |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | Cordillera | customary | B1, B2 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | Batur, Batukaru volcanoes | customary | B1, B2 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Lineage practitioner-innovation1 | |||||||
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Trans-Himalaya | practitioner-innovation | B2 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Lineage abcd-by-name2 | |||||||
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Nyando uplands | abcd-by-name | B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Highlands | abcd-by-name | B2 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Lineage community-forestry2 | |||||||
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | Central Himalaya | community-forestry | B2, B4, B8 | E4 | E2 | [IC] |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Sierra Juárez | community-forestry | B1, B2, B4, B6, B8 | E2 | E4 | [IC] |
| Lineage water-fund2 | |||||||
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | Northern Andes páramo | water-fund | E5 | E5 | [IC] | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | water-fund | E5 | E5 | [MS] | |
| Lineage community-land-trust1 | |||||||
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | Island uplands | community-land-trust | B1, B2, B6 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Lineage reciprocity2 | |||||||
| Los Negros Reciprocal Water Agreement | Bolivia | Eastern Andes valleys | reciprocity | B3, B4, B6 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | Eastern Andes | reciprocity | B3, B4 | E1 | E1 | [IC] |
| Lineage abcd-framed1 | |||||||
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | abcd-framed | B2, B4, B8 | E5 | E5 | [MS] |
| Lineage negotiated-payments4 | |||||||
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Drakensberg-Maloti | negotiated-payments | E4 | E5 | [IC] | |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | Catskills | negotiated-payments | B7, B8 | E2 | E5 | [IC] |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | negotiated-payments | B3, B4, B7 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | negotiated-payments | B3, B4, B7 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Lineage territory-of-life2 | |||||||
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | Mau escarpment | territory-of-life | B1 | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Cherangany Hills | territory-of-life | B1 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Lineage biocultural-heritage1 | |||||||
| Potato Park, Pisac | Peru | Central Andes | biocultural-heritage | B1, B2, B6 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Lineage legal-personhood3 | |||||||
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | Tongariro to sea | legal-personhood | B1, B2, B5 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | Taranaki volcanic peaks | legal-personhood | B1, B5, B8 | E5 | E5 | [IC] |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | Te Urewera ranges | legal-personhood | B1, B2, B5, B8 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Beyond-market markers | Water evidence | Community evidence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Nyando uplands | abcd-by-name | B2 | E5 | E4 | [IC] |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Highlands | abcd-by-name | B2 | E5 | E4 | [MS] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | abcd-framed | B2, B4, B8 | E5 | E5 | [MS] |
| Case | Country | Water outcome | Water evidence | Community outcome | Community evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | No landscape effect on E. coli; local effect where cattle excluded | E1 | Some effects, complex; no deforestation effect at 5 yrs | E1 | [IC] | partial |
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Careo 48% of recharge 2014-15; +40% total resources | E2 | Not measured | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Not measured (forest cover) | E2 | Not measured here | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | Not measured (forest only) | E2 | Small poverty effects | E2 | [IC] | yes |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | Filtration avoidance maintained [TBV] | E2 | The 2017 FAD requires a USD 11 million contract with the Watershed Agricultural Council; no new West-of-Hudson whole farm plans were approved in 2022 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Water table from about 50 m to about 5 m below surface (as cited), or 15 to 3 m; tenfold groundwater availability since 1993; runoff -21% | E3 | 650 wells; irrigation [MS] | E5 | [IC] | partial |
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Implementers report lean-season discharge gains at named springs (for example 40 to 60% at Alohsa, Nagaland, 2021; 1.76 to 2.6 L/min at one Uttarakhand spring); before-after designs without controls, and one atlas attributes a 16% rise to higher rainfall | E3 | More than 45 women trained as para-workers for discharge and water-quality measurement (PSI 2021-22) | E5 | [MS] | no |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Lean discharge 4.4 to 14.4 L/min (5 springs); 12 to 35 and 6 to 40 L/min 2020-24 | E3 | Not measured | E5 | [IC] | partial |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Not measured for Barjas; at basin scale, spring chemistry in Bérchules shows careo influence on most groundwater (Molina Rojas et al. 2022) | E3 | Not verified | E5 | [MS] | no |
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | About 60% of diverted water returns to the river as surface flow, 33% as shallow groundwater and 7% is lost to evapotranspiration; seepage recharges the aquifer at about 1,169 mm a year; return flow delays runoff | E3 | Crop production and common livestock pasturing have declined (Cox 2014) | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Case | Country | Lineage | Tenure | Capture or harm | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mountain region Mexico and North America2 | ||||||
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | commons | communal | Individual quantification of water rights in the Abeyta adjudication; land subdivision by newcomers; urban growth; loss of common pastures; water markets rated a moderate pressure | Centuries | [IC] |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | community-forestry | communal | Parcels 10+ yrs post-payment more deforested | Community forestry 40+ yrs; PES effect faded | [IC] |
| Mountain region Iberia, Mediterranean and Arabia1 | ||||||
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | customary | customary | Private boreholes lower water tables below the tunnels | Over 4,000 aflaj in the 1990s inventory, 3,000 in use; UNESCO listing 2006 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Alps and Europe2 | ||||||
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | commons | contested | The 2008 ruling assigned the substance value of former municipal land to municipalities; a 2010 law amendment and later rulings confirmed it, and a 2014 amendment placed a municipal administrator inside these agrarian communities, which challenged it in court | Ongoing | [IC] |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | state-program | state | Ended with funding; structures damaged or destroyed; a 6 m dam at Rudno nad Hronom breached in 2021 with one death | Ended with funding | [IC] |
| Mountain region Himalaya1 | ||||||
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | community-forestry | state | Elite capture reported | 30 yrs | [IC] |
| Mountain region Southeast and East Asia4 | ||||||
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | customary | mixed | Main-area ticket revenue sharing contested; terrace abandonment; a few Azheke households rejected the dividend rule | Centuries | [TBV] |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | customary | customary | Out-migration | On the List of World Heritage in Danger until 2012, when the Committee removed them and noted that sustained funding remains needed | [IC] |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | commons | communal | Iriai rights replaced by individual or association ownership under the 1966 modernization law; many receiving forest associations now dissolving | Reorganization peaked in FY1974 and has stayed low; surviving iriai groups still decide by unanimity | [IC] |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | customary | mixed | Tourism water priority, land conversion | Centuries, under strain | [IC] |
| Mountain region Africa4 | ||||||
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | state-program | state | Resettlement harms; the royalty fund meant for the poorest was restructured by the World Bank after political misuse | 40 yrs | [IC] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | negotiated-payments | mixed | No implemented community payment scheme found | Not launched | [IC] |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | territory-of-life | contested | State eviction | Rulings stand; compliance judgment of 4 Dec 2025 found the 2017 judgment partly implemented and the 2022 reparations unpaid | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | territory-of-life | contested | State eviction; Amnesty found the Sengwer were never genuinely consulted | Evictions since 2009 under a 2013 resettlement decision; EU suspended its programme on 17 January 2018 | [IC] |
| Mountain region Andes2 | ||||||
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | state-program | communal | 2020 decree let Sedapal use MERESE for operations | Fund continues; projects slow | [IC] |
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | reciprocity | mixed | Low uptake; intakes unenrolled | Agreements continue | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Water outcome | Water evidence | Community outcome | Community evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Careo 48% of recharge 2014-15; +40% total resources | E2 | Not measured | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | About 60% of diverted water returns to the river as surface flow, 33% as shallow groundwater and 7% is lost to evapotranspiration; seepage recharges the aquifer at about 1,169 mm a year; return flow delays runoff | E3 | Crop production and common livestock pasturing have declined (Cox 2014) | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | About a quarter of aflaj stopped flowing and a third declined sharply since the 1990s inventory (ministers, 2014) | E5 | Not verified | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | Not measured | E5 | Not verified | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | Not measured | E5 | Not measured | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | 14 ice reservoirs inventoried; Nang stored about 1,010 to 3,220 m³ of ice in 2014/15; only five catchments could irrigate all fields in optimal years | E4 | Smallholders report better spring yields and more frequent irrigation; maintenance limited by labor shortages | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | Not measured | E5 | Network shrank from over 1,400 km in the late 19th century to about 600 km; more than half the channels abandoned in the 20th century | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | Not measured | E4 | More than 18,000 user groups; community forest management linked to a 37% relative reduction in deforestation and a 4.3% relative reduction in poverty | E2 | [IC] | yes |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Not measured (forest cover) | E2 | Not measured here | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | Not measured; monitoring stations installed | E5 | Páramo communities take part through conservation agreements and as paid guardapáramos; FONAG reports 55,000 ha protected (TNC, 2025) [MS] | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Not measured | E5 | Cultivated land in Yuanyang County fell by 84.16 km² between 2010 and 2017; some terraces abandoned for lack of labor | E5 | [TBV] | yes |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | Not measured | E5 | Terraces abandoned as the irrigation system was neglected and people left | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Modeled drought streamflow gains | E4 | Jobs | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | Not measured | E5 | About 1.85 million ha of iriai forest at the 1966 law; 0.89 million ha since reorganized; 0.45 million ha confirmed as remaining iriai in an owners' survey | E2 | [IC] | yes |
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | Not measured | E5 | Population rose from 65 at the buyout to 109; renewables (184 kW of hydro, wind and solar) supply 95% of energy use | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | Transfer to Gauteng | E4 | More than 30,000 rural farmers affected by the first phases; no compensation before displacement; living standards of most affected people reported declining | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Modeled: improved grassland management raises baseflow; benefits exceed costs in low to medium degraded areas, not in heavily degraded ones | E4 | Not applicable | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | Not measured | E5 | ~12,000 person-days [MS] | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | Not measured (forest only) | E2 | Small poverty effects | E2 | [IC] | yes |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | Filtration avoidance maintained [TBV] | E2 | The 2017 FAD requires a USD 11 million contract with the Watershed Agricultural Council; no new West-of-Hudson whole farm plans were approved in 2022 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | 19% tree cover loss 2001-22 (complex) | E4 | ~700 households evicted Nov 2023 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Not measured; obligations are activity-based | E5 | Payment conditional on four verified activities; spent on community investments | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Potato Park, Pisac | Peru | Not measured | E5 | Recognized in 2020 as an agrobiodiversity zone of 7,238.33 ha across four comunidades campesinas; more than 1,330 potato varieties kept | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Not measured | E5 | Up to 1,500 homes burned in January 2014; more than 300 since December 2017; one Sengwer man shot dead on 16 January 2018 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | No published hydrological evaluation; one gully monitoring study (VTEI 2022) | E5 | Temporary jobs; auditor found duplicate invoices (€32,181) in 46 municipalities | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | Not measured | E4 | ~25% of farmland lost in 25 yrs | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | Not measured; no water rights | E5 | Little evaluation | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | Not measured | E5 | Too recent | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | Not measured | E5 | Governance shifted to Board | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | Not measured | E5 | Population stable for centuries | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | Not measured | E5 | Not measured | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Not measured; land users report year-round water and better maize harvests | E5 | Yakpugang residents more aware of the payment than town dwellers, about 20% of whom knew of it; renewal and payment were late in the first contract period | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Period | Lineage | Assets | Coordination | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Water outcome | Community outcome | Persistence | Capture or harm | Water evidence | Community evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Northern highlands | 1990s to 2020 | state-program | A1, A2, A3, A4, A7, A8 | I+T | state | State food-for-work, PSNP, donors | B2 | Water table from about 50 m to about 5 m below surface (as cited), or 15 to 3 m; tenfold groundwater availability since 1993; runoff -21% | 650 wells; irrigation [MS] | 20+ yrs | War 2020-22 effect not documented | E3 | E5 | [IC] | partial |
| Acequias de Careo of Bérchules | Spain | Sierra Nevada | ~1,200 yrs; data 2014-2019 | commons | A1, A2, A4, A6, A7, A8 | T+I | communal | Members' labor | B1, B2 | Careo 48% of recharge 2014-15; +40% total resources | Not measured | Centuries, many abandoned | Depopulation, park restrictions | E2 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande | 1600s to present | commons | A1, A2, A4, A6, A7 | T+I | communal | Members' labor and fees | B1, B2 | About 60% of diverted water returns to the river as surface flow, 33% as shallow groundwater and 7% is lost to evapotranspiration; seepage recharges the aquifer at about 1,169 mm a year; return flow delays runoff | Crop production and common livestock pasturing have declined (Cox 2014) | Centuries | Individual quantification of water rights in the Abeyta adjudication; land subdivision by newcomers; urban growth; loss of common pastures; water markets rated a moderate pressure | E3 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Western/Central Himalaya | 2010s | ngo-program | A1, A2, A7, A8 | E+I | communal | Donors, state | B2 | Implementers report lean-season discharge gains at named springs (for example 40 to 60% at Alohsa, Nagaland, 2021; 1.76 to 2.6 L/min at one Uttarakhand spring); before-after designs without controls, and one atlas attributes a 16% rise to higher rainfall | More than 45 women trained as para-workers for discharge and water-quality measurement (PSI 2021-22) | Ongoing | Not verified | E3 | E5 | [MS] | no |
| Aflaj of Oman | Oman | Hajar | Ancient; UNESCO 2006 | customary | A1, A2, A4, A6, A7 | T+M | customary | Water shares held as timed turns (athar) and bought, sold and rented within the community (about USD 3,000 for 30 minutes a week in one village); a common right of one day's flow is rented at weekly auctions (Daris, al-Malki) or on annual contracts (al-Khatmeen) to fund maintenance | B1, B2 | About a quarter of aflaj stopped flowing and a third declined sharply since the 1990s inventory (ministers, 2014) | Not verified | Over 4,000 aflaj in the 1990s inventory, 3,000 in use; UNESCO listing 2006 | Private boreholes lower water tables below the tunnels | E5 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Agdal of Yagour | Morocco | High Atlas | Customary; studies 2000s | customary | A2, A3, A6, A7 | T; I subordinate | contested | None | B1, B2 | Not measured | Not verified | Long-standing; governance still functional and decided by representatives of the tribal fractions (Domínguez 2026); agdal forests in a neighboring valley gained cover where village agdals apply | No Yagour-specific erosion documented; regionally, community institutions have weakened since the forest service arrived (1985), reforestation has expanded at the agdals' expense (2023), and high pastures face pressure from land speculation | E5 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | Eastern Alps | 2008 rulings to present | commons | A2, A3, A7 | T+I | contested | Rents disputed | B1 | Not measured | Not measured | Ongoing | The 2008 ruling assigned the substance value of former municipal land to municipalities; a 2010 law amendment and later rulings confirmed it, and a 2014 amendment placed a municipal administrator inside these agrarian communities, which challenged it in court | E5 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Amunas of Huarochirí | Peru | Western Andes, Rímac/Chillón headwaters | Pre-Inca; revival 2010s; evidence 2014-2021 | customary | A1, A2, A4, A6, A7, A8 | T+I; M, E subordinate | communal | Donors, brewer, MERESE pay works; community labor; no outcome payment | B1, B2 | Tracer mean 45 d retention; modeled +7.5% mean dry-season flow, up to +33% early dry season, 99 Mm3/yr delayed | Not measured; 1,562 trained [MS] | Festival maintenance in 3 known communities | Timing shift to Lima; no downstream-loss study | E4 | E5 | [IC] | partial |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Trans-Himalaya | 1987 onward | practitioner-innovation | A1, A4, A7, A8 | E+T | communal | Government agencies, the Watershed Development Programme, NGOs, Indian Army goodwill schemes and crowdfunding; INR 300,000 to 1,000,000 per structure | B2 | 14 ice reservoirs inventoried; Nang stored about 1,010 to 3,220 m³ of ice in 2014/15; only five catchments could irrigate all fields in optimal years | Smallholders report better spring yields and more frequent irrigation; maintenance limited by labor shortages | Built over about 30 years; performance varies by site and year | Floods and landslides disabled some structures; disputes over water sharing at the ice stupa | E4 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Nyando uplands | 2016 onward | abcd-by-name | A1, A2, A7 | E+T | private | Donor-funded | B2 | Not measured | Livelihood comparisons | Not verified | None found | E5 | E4 | [IC] | partial |
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | Medieval to present | commons | A1, A2, A4, A7 | T+I; M (tourism) | communal | Members, commune, tourism | B1, B2 | Not measured | Network shrank from over 1,400 km in the late 19th century to about 600 km; more than half the channels abandoned in the 20th century | Irrigation since at least the 13th century; about 52.5% of channels in use run by consortages, 42.5% by municipalities | Weaker consortages dissolving and handing channels to municipalities; piping and sprinklers; tourism uses | E5 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Highlands | 2003-2011 | abcd-by-name | A1, A2, A3, A4, A5, A7 | T+E | state | Community own resources; Bale Salka: govt 53%, community 36%, NGO 11% | B2 | Not measured | Few natural-resource changes on maps | Groups grew 5 to 24 | None found | E5 | E4 | [MS] | no |
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | Central Himalaya | 1993 Act to present | community-forestry | A2, A3, A5, A7 | T+I | state | Timber and fees to group fund | B2, B4, B8 | Not measured | More than 18,000 user groups; community forest management linked to a 37% relative reduction in deforestation and a 4.3% relative reduction in poverty | 30 yrs | Elite capture reported | E4 | E2 | [IC] | yes |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Sierra Juárez | 1980s enterprises; PSAH 2003 | community-forestry | A1, A2, A3, A5, A6, A7 | T+I; M subordinate | communal | Timber, PSAH, ecotourism into assembly | B1, B2, B4, B6, B8 | Not measured (forest cover) | Not measured here | Community forestry 40+ yrs; PES effect faded | Parcels 10+ yrs post-payment more deforested | E2 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Eastern Himalaya | 2008 to present | state-program | A1, A3, A4, A6, A7, A8 | I; T subordinate | mixed | MGNREGA wages | Lean discharge 4.4 to 14.4 L/min (5 springs); 12 to 35 and 6 to 40 L/min 2020-24 | Not measured | 15+ yrs | Some declines in Manipur study | E3 | E5 | [IC] | partial | |
| FONAG Water Fund, Quito | Ecuador | Northern Andes páramo | 2000 to present | water-fund | A3, A7, A8 | I+M | mixed | Constituents' contributions build trust capital (about USD 12 million, 2016), whose returns fund about USD 2 million a year; communities receive in-kind project support and guardapáramo wages | Not measured; monitoring stations installed | Páramo communities take part through conservation agreements and as paid guardapáramos; FONAG reports 55,000 ha protected (TNC, 2025) [MS] | Running since 2000 | Communities hold no board seat: the trust board is formed by six institutional constituents with votes proportional to their contributions; the fund depends heavily on the city's water and electricity utilities | E5 | E5 | [IC] | yes | |
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Ailao Mountains | Centuries; UNESCO 2013 | customary | A1, A4, A6, A7 | T+I | mixed | Main scenic area: Yunnan Shibo pays 10% of pre-tax ticket revenue to the county for villagers, who report receiving nothing (2014). Azheke: village company splits revenue 30% operations, 70% villagers; 12 dividend rounds totaling CNY 3.4525 million (CNY 53,116 per household) by October 2025 | B2 | Not measured | Cultivated land in Yuanyang County fell by 84.16 km² between 2010 and 2017; some terraces abandoned for lack of labor | Centuries | Main-area ticket revenue sharing contested; terrace abandonment; a few Azheke households rejected the dividend rule | E5 | E5 | [TBV] | yes |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | Cordillera | Centuries; danger list 2001-12 | customary | A1, A4, A6, A7 | T | customary | None | B1, B2 | Not measured | Terraces abandoned as the irrigation system was neglected and people left | On the List of World Heritage in Danger until 2012, when the Committee removed them and noted that sustained funding remains needed | Out-migration | E5 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | 1995 onward | state-program | A3, A7, A8 | I+M | mixed | State and fund pay teams | Modeled drought streamflow gains | Jobs | Funding-dependent | Communities as labor only | E4 | E5 | [IC] | yes | |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | Central uplands | Edo period to 1950s | commons | A2, A6, A7 | T | communal | None | B1, B2 | Not measured | About 1.85 million ha of iriai forest at the 1966 law; 0.89 million ha since reorganized; 0.45 million ha confirmed as remaining iriai in an owners' survey | Reorganization peaked in FY1974 and has stayed low; surviving iriai groups still decide by unanimity | Iriai rights replaced by individual or association ownership under the 1966 modernization law; many receiving forest associations now dissolving | E5 | E2 | [IC] | yes |
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | Island uplands | 1997 buyout | community-land-trust | A2, A3, A4, A5, A7 | E+M | trust | Residents pay for power from a GBP 1.6 million community grid funded by the trust, residents' fees, lottery, regional and EU grants; the trust owns the island, bought for GBP 1.5 million in 1997 | B1, B2, B6 | Not measured | Population rose from 65 at the buyout to 109; renewables (184 kW of hydro, wind and solar) supply 95% of energy use | Community ownership since 1997; 24-hour renewable power from 1 February 2008 | Tourism growth reported to strain water supply and waste disposal | E5 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | Maloti | 1986 treaty to present | state-program | A7 | I+M | state | South Africa pays royalties to the Lesotho state; with customs dues they made up 27.8% of government revenue (late 1990s); compensation to resettled households | Transfer to Gauteng | More than 30,000 rural farmers affected by the first phases; no compensation before displacement; living standards of most affected people reported declining | 40 yrs | Resettlement harms; the royalty fund meant for the poorest was restructured by the World Bank after political misuse | E4 | E4 | [IC] | yes | |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | 2010s | ngo-program | A2, A7, A8 | E+M | mixed | Donors and partners fund restoration; the farmer-owned Baviaanskloof Development Company reports over €2.5 million raised | B6 | Not measured; the catchment is reported to supply about 70% of Port Elizabeth's water | Only four farmers in the development company's loan scheme within a 41,000 ha area (Commonland 2020) [MS]; farmers reported willing to keep working with Living Lands (de Villiers et al. 2026, co-produced) | Partnership formed 2014 with a 20-year commitment | None found; spekboom planting across the wider regional program averaged 28% survival | E5 | E4 | [MS] | no |
| Los Negros Reciprocal Water Agreement | Bolivia | Eastern Andes valleys | 2003 to present | reciprocity | A2, A3, A5, A6, A7 | E+T; M subordinate | mixed | Irrigators, municipality, donors pay in kind into municipal fund | B3, B4, B6 | Not measured independently | Not measured | Over 20 years; spread to 5 countries [MS] | Donor co-funding throughout | E5 | E4 | [MS] | partial |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | 1998 to present | abcd-framed | A1, A2, A4, A5, A7 | T+E | mixed | Users pay 250 KES/yr to committee accounts | B2, B4, B8 | Not measured | Walk to water was 15 km [MS] | 20+ yrs | None found | E5 | E5 | [MS] | partial |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Drakensberg-Maloti | 2000s | negotiated-payments | A7, A8 | I+M | mixed | Not implemented at scale | Modeled: improved grassland management raises baseflow; benefits exceed costs in low to medium degraded areas, not in heavily degraded ones | Not applicable | Not launched | No implemented community payment scheme found | E4 | E5 | [IC] | yes | |
| MERESE and the Milloc Bofedales | Peru | Western Andes, Santa Eulalia | Law 2014; tariff 2015; Milloc 2021 | state-program | A3, A4, A7, A8 | I; T subordinate | communal | Lima users pay 1% of bill; Sedapal contracts works; community paid labor and O&M | B7 | Not measured | ~12,000 person-days [MS] | Fund continues; projects slow | 2020 decree let Sedapal use MERESE for operations | E5 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | Sierra Madre and others | 2003 to present | state-program | A3, A7 | I; T subordinate | communal | Federal water fees: MXN 300-400/ha/yr to assemblies | B4, B8 | Not measured (forest only) | Small poverty effects | Program continues | 64% of early enrollment low-risk | E2 | E2 | [IC] | yes |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | Catskills | 1993 WAC; 1997 MOA | negotiated-payments | A2, A3, A5, A7 | I+M; E subordinate | private | New York City pays cost-share for farm best management practices through the farmer-led Watershed Agricultural Council | B7, B8 | Filtration avoidance maintained [TBV] | The 2017 FAD requires a USD 11 million contract with the Watershed Agricultural Council; no new West-of-Hudson whole farm plans were approved in 2022 | Whole Farm Program from 1992; Memorandum of Agreement 1997; Revised 2017 Filtration Avoidance Determination issued December 2022 | Unresolved issues over long-term stewardship and the city's water supply permit, raised by the Coalition of Watershed Towns; no new conservation easements conveyed in 2022 | E2 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | Mau escarpment | Claims since colonial era; rulings 2017, 2022, 2025 | territory-of-life | A1, A6, A7 | T vs I | contested | KES ~157.8m reparations ordered, unpaid | B1 | 19% tree cover loss 2001-22 (complex) | ~700 households evicted Nov 2023 | Rulings stand; compliance judgment of 4 Dec 2025 found the 2017 judgment partly implemented and the 2022 reparations unpaid | State eviction | E4 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | Agreement signed 29 October 2015 for 1 January 2016 to 31 December 2020; second-phase consultations from December 2018 | negotiated-payments | A2, A3, A7 | I+M; T subordinate | mixed | Five hotels and the Satsham Water Association pay the Namey Nichu Watershed Management Group (29 households) Nu 142,000, only after the PES Verification Team confirms the agreed activities; the community forest group manages the money | B3, B4, B7 | Not measured; obligations are activity-based | Payment conditional on four verified activities; spent on community investments | First agreement ran 2016 to 2020; second phase under consultation from December 2018 | Second-phase consultations raised concerns about water allocation to hotels and equitable distribution; hotel development near Taktsang | E5 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Potato Park, Pisac | Peru | Central Andes | 2000s to present | biocultural-heritage | A1, A2, A6, A7 | T+E | communal | Community micro-enterprises (ecotourism, crafts, herbal products), mostly led by women; NGO and grant support | B1, B2, B6 | Not measured | Recognized in 2020 as an agrobiodiversity zone of 7,238.33 ha across four comunidades campesinas; more than 1,330 potato varieties kept | Set up after ANDES registered in 1995; still running | None found | E5 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Qochas of San Juan de Tarucani | Peru | Western Andes, Chili headwaters | 2020s | state-program | A4, A7, A8 | I; T subordinate | communal | Arequipa water users pay through the MERESE tariff approved by Sunass; Sunass disbursed S/135,000 after the first year; Sedapar, Sernanp and Descosur carry out the works | Storage reported: 25 qochas holding more than 600,000 m³ (2024); one qocha of 133,500 m³; no hydrological monitoring result found | Communities may use the water for alpaca pasture and troughs; residents report water lasting to October [MS] | Recent | Money held by state fund and NGO | E5 | E5 | [IC] | partial | |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | Dolomites | Medieval; park 1990 | commons | A2, A3, A6, A7 | T+I | communal | Timber, rents and an annual regional contribution fund the Regole and the park (budget about €2 million a year); no revenue distributed to members beyond household rights to timber, pasture and firewood | B1, B2, B4, B8 | Not measured | More than 16,000 ha and about 1,000 families; Regolieri are about 40% of Cortina's residents | Medieval origins; natural park entrusted to the Regole in 1990; after the 2022 Marmolada collapse the assembly returned management of leased peaks, crags, trails and streams to the State Demanio, keeping its 16,000 ha of forest and pasture | Membership passes through male descendants of old families; newcomers excluded and women's rights limited | E5 | E5 | [MS] | no |
| Restored Acequias de Careo of Cáñar | Spain | Sierra Nevada | 2014 onward | commons | A1, A2, A4, A7, A8 | T+E | communal | Volunteer labor organized by the University of Granada's MEMOLab with the irrigators' community | B2 | Not measured for Barjas; at basin scale, spring chemistry in Bérchules shows careo influence on most groundwater (Molina Rojas et al. 2022) | Not verified | Restored in 2014 under the EU MEMOLA project with 180 volunteers and the irrigators' community, after more than 30 years of disuse; cleaned each year (2023, 2025, 23 May 2026) | None found | E3 | E5 | [MS] | no |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Cherangany Hills | 2014-2018 evictions | territory-of-life | A6, A7 | T vs I | contested | EU Kenya Water Towers programme (reported as USD 35 million) to Kenya's forest agencies; suspended January 2018, later ended | B1 | Not measured | Up to 1,500 homes burned in January 2014; more than 300 since December 2017; one Sengwer man shot dead on 16 January 2018 | Evictions since 2009 under a 2013 resettlement decision; EU suspended its programme on 17 January 2018 | State eviction; Amnesty found the Sengwer were never genuinely consulted | E5 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | Carpathians | 2010-2012 | state-program | A3, A4, A7 | I | state | State pays municipalities for labor | No published hydrological evaluation; one gully monitoring study (VTEI 2022) | Temporary jobs; auditor found duplicate invoices (€32,181) in 46 municipalities | Ended with funding | Ended with funding; structures damaged or destroyed; a 6 m dam at Rudno nad Hronom breached in 2021 with one death | E5 | E5 | [IC] | yes | |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | Batur, Batukaru volcanoes | 11th century; UNESCO 2012 | customary | A1, A2, A3, A4, A6, A7 | T; I and M rising | mixed | Members; tourism revenue rarely to farmers | B1, B2 | Not measured | ~25% of farmland lost in 25 yrs | Centuries, under strain | Tourism water priority, land conversion | E4 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River) | New Zealand | Tongariro to sea | 2017 Act | legal-personhood | A3, A6, A7 | T+I | legal-personhood | NZD 80m redress + NZD 1m | B1, B2, B5 | Not measured; no water rights | Little evaluation | 9 yrs | Consents proceed without its consent | E5 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Te Kāhui Tupua (Taranaki Maunga) | New Zealand | Taranaki volcanic peaks | 2025 Act | legal-personhood | A3, A6, A7 | T+I | legal-personhood | Crown redress | B1, B5, B8 | Not measured | Too recent | 1 yr | None yet | E5 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Te Urewera | New Zealand | Te Urewera ranges | 2014 Act | legal-personhood | A3, A6, A7 | T+I | legal-personhood | Crown redress | B1, B2, B5, B8 | Not measured | Governance shifted to Board | 12 yrs | None found | E5 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | 1483 statutes to present | commons | A2, A3, A4, A6, A7 | T+I | communal | Members | B1, B2 | Not measured | Population stable for centuries | 500+ yrs | Exclusion of non-citizens | E5 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Tribunal de las Aguas of Valencia | Spain | Turia from Iberian ranges | Medieval to present | commons | A2, A3, A4, A6, A7 | T+I | communal | Members' fees | B1, B2 | Not measured | Not measured | Medieval to present; meets every Thursday at noon; UNESCO intangible heritage listing 2009 | Urbanization of huerta | E5 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | Drakensberg foothills | 2013 onward | state-program | A3, A7, A8 | I+E | mixed | Municipal and utility budgets fund pilot projects led by uMgungundlovu, Msunduzi and eThekwini; no payment to upstream residents found | Modeled gains in dry-season baseflow and lower sediment yield from rehabilitating degraded land and clearing invasive plants; no measured outcome found | No figure found for jobs or income going to catchment residents; no rural community, traditional council or land-rights holder named as a member | Memorandum of understanding signed by 21 parties in 2013; strategy adopted July 2016; SANBI lists 17 member organizations | None documented | E4 | E5 | [IC] | partial | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | 2015 to present | water-fund | A2, A3, A7, A8 | I+M | mixed | City utility, KenGen, firms, donors to trust; farmers get inputs | Reported: turbidity 11% lower (UTNWF) or suspended sediment 21.3% below average with 8% less filtration chemical use (Toolbox, December 2023); projected: 50% lower sediment and up to 15% more water yield (TNC 2015); no independent measurement | 44,725 farmers [MS] | 10 yrs | Farmers under-represented on board | E5 | E5 | [MS] | no | |
| Watershared Randomized Trial | Bolivia | Eastern Andes | 2010 baseline; 2015 endline | reciprocity | A2, A3, A5, A7 | E+M; I subordinate | mixed | Water users, municipalities, donors: USD 1-10/ha/yr in kind + USD 100 joining | B3, B4 | No landscape effect on E. coli; local effect where cattle excluded | Some effects, complex; no deforestation effect at 5 yrs | Agreements continue | Low uptake; intakes unenrolled | E1 | E1 | [IC] | partial |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | Contract signed December 2010, implemented 2011, renewed | negotiated-payments | A2, A3, A7 | I+M; T subordinate | mixed | Mongar municipality pays the Yakpugang Community Forest Management Group (113 members) Nu 52,000 a year in the first three-year contract; Norten (2021) gives Nu 178,200 a year from town users and Nu 50,000 from Mongar Regional Referral Hospital | B3, B4, B7 | Not measured; land users report year-round water and better maize harvests | Yakpugang residents more aware of the payment than town dwellers, about 20% of whom knew of it; renewal and payment were late in the first contract period | Contract renewed after the first three-year period | Late renewal and late payment in the first period | E5 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
The tabs group the cases by mountain region, continent, country, mountain system and climate; filter them to Mediterranean and arid climates, cases that name the retention function, cases where the community holds both the rules and the money, reciprocal agreements, contracted providers, legal personhood, tenure, lineage, measured water evidence, failures and captures, and independent evidence; and show the full coding in one table. Click a column heading to sort by it.
Counts: 46 rows. ABCD by name or ABCD-framed: 3. Rows naming the retention function (A8): 15. Rows with E1 or E2 water evidence: 4 (Watershared; the PSAH and Oaxaca forest-cover proxies; careo); with E3, also the New Mexico acequias, Dhara Vikas and Abreha we Atsbeha. Rows where the arrangement failed, faded, was taken over or did harm: 16 (MERESE, Watershared, Oaxaca PES effect, New Mexico acequia water sales, aflaj, Tyrol, Slovakia, Nepal user groups, subak, Ifugao, Hani, iriai, Ogiek, Sengwer, Lesotho, Maloti). Regional coverage: 12 African, 7 Andean, 5 Mediterranean-climate, 10 Asian. After two enrichment passes on 9 November 2026, the register’s grades are 38 [IC], 8 [MS] and 1 [TBV] (the Hani terraces); the table above reads each case page’s current grade. The register now holds 47 cases: a second enrichment run added Yakpugang (Bhutan) as its own case, and the counts above refer to the 46 this brief coded.
The nine predictions
P1. ABCD practice rarely counts living systems as assets.
For: 3 of 46 rows are ABCD by name or framing, and none names A8 or governs a mountain catchment. The Coady Ethiopia maps showed few natural-resource changes. Against: Coady’s groups did put natural resources on asset maps, and the Kenyan ICRAF work is about trees. Grade: [IC] for the Coady record; the count is this brief’s coding. Status: academic-inference. The wiki can say: “In the cases found, ABCD-labeled work mapped land, trees and water points, and none governed a mountain catchment.”
P2. Secure community tenure over a mountain catchment goes with maintained retention function over decades.
For: Törbel, the Regole, careo, New Mexico acequias and Oaxaca’s community forests persisted under secure collective rights. In the Sierra de Juárez, forest cover under community management fell until 2001 and then recovered, and by 2014 slightly exceeded its 1979 extent (Navarro Cerrillo et al. 2019). The Ogiek case shows the reverse: insecure tenure, evictions and a 19% tree cover loss. Against: no study measures the retention function itself against tenure. Remoteness, low population and abandonment confound the Alpine and Iberian cases, and Tigray shows retention restored on state land. Grade: [TBV] as a causal claim. Status: working-hypothesis. The wiki can say: “Long-lived mountain water commons share secure collective rights; the link to measured retention has not been tested.”
P3. Communities that hold the rules and the money keep arrangements going longer.
For: Oaxaca’s assemblies, which hold both, outlasted the PSAH effect. MERESE money held by the state was redirected in 2020, and Slovakia’s program ended with its funding. Makutano’s committees hold accounts and persisted [MS]. Against: few cases separate rule-holding from money-holding, and survivors dominate the old commons. Grade: [TBV]. Status: working-hypothesis. The wiki can say: “In the cases found, arrangements with money and rules held elsewhere were redirected or ended more often.”
P4. Reciprocal arrangements with downstream users produce measured water outcomes.
For: local E. coli fell where cattle were excluded (Watershared), and careo and amunas show recharge with timing shifts. Against: the one randomized test found no detectable effect at the scale of the communities’ water supplies. Amunas catchment gains are modeled, and UTNWF flow claims are self-reported. Grade: [IC] against. Status: documented-fact for the null result. The wiki can say: “The only randomized test of a reciprocal water agreement found local gains and no landscape-scale water-quality effect.”
P5. Communities with a named mountain water asset move from needy to needed.
For: Carampoma’s guardianship and maintenance role at Milloc, and the Catskills farmers under the city agreement. Against: in both, the payer set the terms; the amunas maintenance contract was proposed and not found executed. Grade: [MS]. Status: working-hypothesis. The wiki can say: “A few utilities now pay mountain communities to maintain water works, on terms the utility sets.”
P6. Legal personhood or rights of nature changes water outcomes.
For: governance shifted in Te Urewera to a Tūhoe-majority board. Against: no water measurement exists for any of the three settlements. Te Awa Tupua holds no water rights, and consents to take water proceed without its consent. Grade: [IC] that governance changed and water is unmeasured. Status: documented-fact (governance); speculative-projection (water). The wiki can say: “Legal personhood changed who speaks for the mountain or river; no change in water has been measured.”
P7. Beyond-market arrangements get pulled back into market or state forms.
For: the MERESE redirection, Ogiek evictions despite rulings, subak land and water lost to tourism, aflaj undercut by wells, and Tyrol disputes over value. Against: Törbel, the Regole and the Oaxaca assemblies resisted, protected by legal recognition of collective title and membership rules. Grade: [IC]. Status: structural-inference. The wiki can say: “State and market pressure has eroded several mountain water commons; legally recognized collective title protected others.” The wiki’s green grabbing entry covers one form of this pull.
P8. Cultural and sacred relationships with the mountain sustain stewardship where money does not.
For: Lansing’s water temples coordinated irrigation for centuries, Sikkim’s Devithans springs are protected, and the Māori settlements rest on ancestral relationship. Against: Balinese farmers cite ritual costs as a burden, and sacred status did not stop subak land conversion. The evidence is ethnographic. Grade: [TBV]. Status: working-hypothesis. The wiki can say: “Ethnographies record sacred relationships alongside long stewardship; causation is untested.”
P9. Practitioner and program claims match independent measurement.
Watershared: NGO accounts of conservation benefits set against a null randomized result on water quality. Amunas: “33%” in the press against a 7.5% mean in the paper. Abreha we Atsbeha: the water table is given as rising from about 50 m to about 5 m below the surface, from 15 m to 3 m, or by about 5 m, depending on the source. UTNWF: 27 million liters a day [MS] with no independent gauge found. Dhara Vikas: E3 gains, plus a Manipur brief showing declines. Grade: [IC] that gaps exist. Status: documented-fact. The wiki can say: “Flagship claims overstate or outrun independent measurement in most cases checked.”
Evidence the claims must face
- Survivorship. Törbel, the Regole and the subak are famous because they survived. Iriai, many aflaj and most abandoned careo are the failed or faded counterparts.
- Romanticism and exclusion. The Regole are hereditary. Törbel excluded non-citizens. Acequia and falaj rights follow land or shares. Water committee and temple membership in Bali follows land ownership. Women’s access is rarely reported.
- Remoteness. Alpine and Andean commons persisted where outsiders had little interest; the Mau, which Kenya values as a water tower, saw evictions.
- Outside money. Watershared, Aquafondo, UTNWF, Dhara Vikas and Abreha we Atsbeha all relied on NGO, utility, donor or state funding. The communities supplied labor and land.
- Downstream loss. Careo and amunas move water in time, and careo also moves it between basins. No case measured what downstream users lost.
- Rainfall confounding. Sikkim’s spring gains and Tigray’s groundwater rise come from before-after designs without rainfall controls.
- Self-reported totals. Farmer counts, liters per day and hectares from UTNWF, Natura and Aquafondo are [MS].
Patterns across the cases
| Beyond-market pattern | Cases | Persisted 50+ years | Measured water effect | Capture or harm recorded |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B1+B2 commons, no outside payment | Törbel, careo, NM acequias, Valencia, subak, agdal, aflaj, iriai, Ifugao | 9 of 9 at some point; 3 now weakening | Careo (E2), NM acequias (E3) | Subak, aflaj, iriai |
| B4/B8 community holds payments | PSAH ejidos, Oaxaca, Makutano, Regole | Oaxaca 40+ yrs | None on water | Oaxaca PES effect faded |
| B3 reciprocal, NGO-brokered | Los Negros, Watershared, Paro (Namey Nichu), Yakpugang | No | Null at landscape scale (E1) | Low uptake |
| B7 contracted provider | Milloc, Catskills, Paro, Yakpugang | Catskills 30 yrs | None verified | Terms set by payer; payment conditional on verified work in Paro |
| B5 legal personhood | Te Urewera, Te Awa Tupua, Taranaki | No (recent) | None | Water rights excluded |
| No B marker, state or fund | Arequipa qochas, UTNWF, Dhara Vikas, Cape clearing, Slovakia, Lesotho | Lesotho as state project | Sikkim springs (E3), Cape modeled | MERESE redirected, Slovakia ended, Lesotho resettlement |
Governance: the long-lived cases combine bounded membership and user-made rules with recognized collective title. Value: where money arrives from outside, the community holding the account (Oaxaca, Makutano) is associated with persistence, and the state or fund holding it (MERESE, Slovakia) with redirection or ending. Persistence: payments alone did not persist in effect after they stopped (Oaxaca).
Applying the findings (the wiki’s reading)
This section is the wiki’s own reading of the cases.
- Secure the boundary and the title first. Törbel, the Regole and the Oaxaca comunidades held recognized collective rights before any payment. The Ogiek won in court and still lost the forest on the ground. A community preparing to hold a catchment should treat title and membership rules as the first asset.
- Keep the account inside the community’s rules. Oaxaca’s assemblies and Makutano’s committees held money. MERESE showed what happens when the payer holds it. A commitment pool in which downstream users’ commitments are held under upstream rules matches the B4 and B8 pattern; the evidence supports that structure and does not test the pool itself.
- Measure at the spring and the well, with a control. Sikkim and Tigray show what before-after records can show; Watershared shows that randomization by community fails when catchments cross community lines. Pair a treated and an untreated spring or sub-catchment, and log rainfall.
- Name timing honestly. Careo and amunas shift water in time. Claims of new water invite the downstream objection the earlier run documented.
- Avoid single-funder dependence. Slovakia’s program and the PSAH effect ended or faded with funding. A BioHub that coordinates several downstream payers under one community rulebook would address the failure pattern seen here; no case tests that design.
Summary of claims
| Claim | Grade | Recommended status | Safe for the wiki |
|---|---|---|---|
| ABCD-labeled cases rarely include mountain catchments (3 of 46, none governing one) | [IC] | academic-inference | With caveat (search scope) |
| Careo channels supplied 48% of Bérchules aquifer recharge in 2014-15 | [IC] | documented-fact | Yes |
| Amunas scale-up could add 7.5% mean dry-season flow for Lima | [IC] | academic-inference | Yes (as model) |
| Watershared had no detectable effect on water quality at the scale of community water supplies | [IC] | documented-fact | Yes |
| PSAH effects faded 10+ years after payments ended in Sierra Juárez | [IC] | academic-inference | Yes |
| MERESE funds were authorized for Sedapal operations in 2020 | [IC] | documented-fact | Yes |
| Kenya has only partly implemented the 2017 Ogiek judgment and has paid none of the 2022 reparations (compliance judgment, 4 December 2025) | [IC] | documented-fact | Yes |
| Legal personhood has not been shown to change water outcomes | [IC] | documented-fact | Yes |
| Secure tenure maintains retention function | [TBV] | working-hypothesis | No |
| Sacred relationships sustain stewardship without money | [TBV] | working-hypothesis | With caveat |
| UTNWF added 27 million liters a day to Nairobi | [MS] | speculative-projection | No |
| Abreha we Atsbeha’s water table rose; the size of the rise is unresolved (50 m to 5 m, 15 m to 3 m, or about 5 m) | [IC] on direction, [TBV] on size | documented-framework | With caveat |
Related
- Water Retention Landscapes
- Retention Works on the Slope, Unproven at the River
- Community-Led Landscape Restoration in Sub-Saharan Africa
- Exclusion from Water Finance
- Outcome Payments for Community Restoration
- Commitment Pooling
- TIME Framework
- Commons
- Needed versus needy
- Payment for ecosystem services (PES)
- Community Catchment Case Register
Sources
Sources with a page in the wiki’s sources/ folder are linked. Entries marked “not re-read” are cited from the research brief’s leads or standard literature and were not opened in this run. Items not peer-reviewed are labeled by type.
ABCD, community development and its critics
- Emery, M., and Flora, C. (2006). Spiraling-up: mapping community transformation with community capitals framework. Community Development 37(1): 19-35. https://doi.org/10.1080/15575330609490152
- DeFilippis, J., Fisher, R., and Shragge, E. (2010). Contesting Community: The Limits and Potential of Local Organizing. Rutgers University Press. https://doi.org/10.36019/9780813549743
- Fuchs, L. E., Peters, B., and Neufeldt, H. (2019). Identities, interests, and preferences matter: fostering sustainable community development by building assets and agency in western Kenya. Sustainable Development 27(4): 704-712. https://doi.org/10.1002/sd.1934
- Kretzmann, J. P., and McKnight, J. L. (1993). Building Communities from the Inside Out: A Path Toward Finding and Mobilizing a Community’s Assets. Center for Urban Affairs and Policy Research, Northwestern University. Not re-read.
- MacLeod, M. A., and Emejulu, A. (2014). Neoliberalism with a community face? A critical analysis of asset-based community development in Scotland. Journal of Community Practice 22(4): 430-450. https://doi.org/10.1080/10705422.2014.959147
- Mahomed, H., and Peters, B. (2011). The Story Behind the Well: A Case Study of Successful Community Development in Makutano, Kenya. Global Fund for Community Foundations and Coady International Institute. Gray literature. https://coady.stfx.ca/wp-content/uploads/pdfs/StoryBehindTheWell.pdf
- Mathie, A., Cameron, J., and Gibson, K. (2017). Asset-based and citizen-led development: using a diffracted power lens to analyze the possibilities and challenges. Progress in Development Studies 17(1): 54-66. https://doi.org/10.1177/1464993416674302
- Mathie, A., and Cunningham, G. (eds.) (2008). From Clients to Citizens: Communities Changing the Course of Their Own Development. Practical Action Publishing. https://doi.org/10.3362/9781780440187
- Peters, B. (comp.) (2013). Applying an Asset-Based Community-Driven Development Approach in Ethiopia, 2003-2011: Final Internal Evaluation Report. Coady International Institute. Internal evaluation. https://coady.stfx.ca/wp-content/uploads/pdfs/ABCDEthiopiaFinalEvaluation.pdf
Commons scholarship
- Cox, M. (2014). Applying a social-ecological system framework to the study of the Taos valley irrigation system. Human Ecology 42: 311-324. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10745-014-9651-y
- Cox, M., Arnold, G., and Villamayor Tomás, S. (2010). A review of design principles for community-based natural resource management. Ecology and Society 15(4): 38. http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol15/iss4/art38/
- McKean, M. A. (1986). Management of traditional common lands (iriaichi) in Japan. In Proceedings of the Conference on Common Property Resource Management, National Research Council, pp. 533-589. Not re-read.
- Netting, R. McC. (1981). Balancing on an Alp: Ecological Change and Continuity in a Swiss Mountain Community. Cambridge University Press. Not re-read.
- Ostrom, E. (1990). Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511807763
Mountain water towers and hydrology
- Feng, X., Fu, B., Piao, S., et al. (2016). Revegetation in China’s Loess Plateau is approaching sustainable water resource limits. Nature Climate Change 6: 1019-1022. https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate3092
- Glendenning, C. J., and Vervoort, R. W. (2011). Hydrological impacts of rainwater harvesting (RWH) in a case study catchment: the Arvari River, Rajasthan, India. Part 2: catchment-scale impacts. Agricultural Water Management 98(4): 715-730. https://ideas.repec.org/a/eee/agiwat/v98y2011i4p715-730.html
- Holden, P. B., Rebelo, A. J., Wolski, P., Odoulami, R. C., Lawal, K. A., Kimutai, J., Nkemelang, T., and New, M. G. (2022). Nature-based solutions in mountain catchments reduce impact of anthropogenic climate change on drought streamflow. Communications Earth & Environment 3: 51. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43247-022-00379-9
- Immerzeel, W. W., Lutz, A. F., Andrade, M., et al. (2020). Importance and vulnerability of the world’s water towers. Nature 577: 364-369. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-019-1822-y
- Tanner, J., Smith, C., Ellery, F., and Hughes, D. (2017). Determining the hydrological functioning of the endemic Palmiet wetlands in the Eastern Cape of South Africa. IAHS Scientific Assembly 2017, abstract IAHS2017-322. https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/IAHS2017/IAHS2017-322.pdf
- Viviroli, D., Kummu, M., Meybeck, M., Kallio, M., and Wada, Y. (2020). Increasing dependence of lowland populations on mountain water resources. Nature Sustainability 3(11): 917-928. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41893-020-0559-9
Andes
- Aquafondo (n.d.). Amunas en San Pedro de Casta. Practitioner document. https://www.ideassonline.org/public/pdf/AquafondoPeru-ESP.pdf
- Asquith, N. M., Vargas, M. T., and Wunder, S. (2008). Selling two environmental services: in-kind payments for bird habitat and watershed protection in Los Negros, Bolivia. Ecological Economics 65(4): 675-684. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2007.12.014
- Bétrisey, F., and Mager, C. (2014). Small farmers in Florida Province, Bolivia: reciprocity in practice. Mountain Research and Development 34(4): 369-374. https://doi.org/10.1659/MRD-JOURNAL-D-14-00013.1
- Ecosystem Marketplace (n.d.). Bees, trees and mountain streams: Bolivia redefines watershed payments. Media. https://www.ecosystemmarketplace.com/articles/bees-trees-and-mountain-streams-br-bolivia-redefines-watershed-payments/
- El Comercio (n.d.). Merese: ¿de qué manera contribuyen con el suministro de agua de calidad? Media. https://elcomercio.pe/economia/merese-de-que-manera-contribuyen-con-el-suministro-de-agua-de-calidad-merese-agua-aquafondo-sedapal-noticia/
- El Comercio (n.d.). Arequipa: destinan más de S/ 8 millones para la conservación de fuentes de agua. Media. https://elcomercio.pe/lima/sucesos/arequipa-destinan-mas-de-s-8-millones-para-la-conservacion-fuentes-de-agua-noticia/
- Forest Trends, Infraestructura Natural para la Seguridad Hídrica (2021). Primer proyecto ecosistémico de Sedapal recuperará infraestructura natural que abastece de agua a Lima y Callao. Gray literature. https://forest-trends.org/infraestructura-natural-en-peru/inversion/primer-proyecto-ecosistemico-de-sedapal-recuperara-infraestructura-natural-que-abastece-de-agua-a-lima-y-callao/
- Grillos, T. (2017). Economic vs non-material incentives for participation in an in-kind payments for ecosystem services program in Bolivia. Ecological Economics 131: 178-190. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2016.08.010
- La Razón (n.d.). Sedapal recupera bofedales de Milloc con emblemático proyecto ecosistémico. Media. https://larazon.pe/sedapal-recupera-bofedales-de-milloc-con-emblematico-proyecto-ecosistemico/
- La República (n.d.). Bofedales en emergencia. Media. https://especiales.larepublica.pe/bofedales-en-emergencia/
- Ministerio del Ambiente, Perú (n.d.). Se impulsa uso de amunas de Huarochirí, sistema ancestral de siembra y cosecha de agua. Official release. https://www.gob.pe/institucion/minam/noticias/483201-se-impulsa-uso-de-amunas-de-huarochiri-sistema-ancestral-de-siembra-y-cosecha-de-agua
- Carrere, M. (2023). Reciprocal Water Agreements protect millions of hectares of Bolivian forest. Mongabay, 19 January 2023. Media. https://news.mongabay.com/2023/01/reciprocal-water-agreements-protect-millions-of-hectares-of-bolivian-forest
- National Geographic (2019). Seeking relief from drought, Peru’s capital looks to its ancient past. Media. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/seeking-relief-from-drought-peru-capital-lima-looks-to-ancient-past
- Ochoa-Tocachi, B. F., Bardales, J. D., Antiporta, J., et al. (2019). Potential contributions of pre-Inca infiltration infrastructure to Andean water security. Nature Sustainability 2: 584-593. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41893-019-0307-1
- Pressenza (2023). Watershed agreement: farmers, water suppliers and communities work together to protect forests and water sources. Media. https://www.pressenza.com/2023/02/watershed-agreement-farmers-water-suppliers-and-communities-work-together-to-protect-forests-and-water-sources/
- Pynegar, E. L., Jones, J. P. G., Gibbons, J. M., and Asquith, N. M. (2018). The effectiveness of payments for ecosystem services at delivering improvements in water quality: lessons for experiments at the landscape scale. PeerJ 6: e5753. https://peerj.com/articles/5753/
- ReVista, Harvard Review of Latin America (n.d.). Reciprocal agreements for water: an environmental management revolution in the Santa Cruz valleys. Practitioner essay. https://revista.drclas.harvard.edu/reciprocal-agreements-for-water-an-environmental-management-revolution-in-in-the-santa-cruz-valleys-2/
- UK Data Service ReShare. Baseline and endline socio-economic data from a randomised control trial of Watershared, Bolivia. Data deposit. https://reshare.ukdataservice.ac.uk/852623/
- Wiik, E., d’Annunzio, R., Pynegar, E., Crespo, D., Asquith, N., and Jones, J. P. G. (2019). Experimental evaluation of the impact of a payment for environmental services program on deforestation. Conservation Science and Practice 1(2): e8. https://doi.org/10.1111/csp2.8
- World Bank (2022). Leveraging citizen action for water conservation: Reciprocal Watershared Agreements by Fundación Natura Bolivia. Gray literature. https://www.naturabolivia.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/World-Bank-Reciprocal-Watershared-Agreements.pdf
Mexico and North America
- Alix-Garcia, J., Aronson, G., Radeloff, V., Ramirez-Reyes, C., Shapiro, E., Sims, K., and Yañez-Pagans, P. (2014). Environmental and Socioeconomic Impacts of Mexico’s Payments for Ecosystem Services Program. 3ie Impact Evaluation Report 20. https://www.3ieimpact.org/sites/default/files/2017-11/ie20-mexico-pes.pdf
- Alix-Garcia, J. M., Sims, K. R. E., and Yañez-Pagans, P. (2015). Only one tree from each seed? Environmental effectiveness and poverty alleviation in Mexico’s payments for ecosystem services program. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 7(4): 1-40. https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.20130139
- Muñoz-Piña, C., Guevara, A., Torres, J. M., and Braña, J. (2008). Paying for the hydrological services of Mexico’s forests: analysis, negotiations and results. Ecological Economics 65(4): 725-736. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2007.07.031
- Navarro Cerrillo, R. M., Esteves Vieira, D. J., Ochoa-Gaona, S., de Jong, B. H. J., and Delgado Serrano, M. M. (2019). Land cover changes and fragmentation in mountain neotropical ecosystems of Oaxaca, Mexico under community forest management. Journal of Forestry Research 30(1): 143-155. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11676-017-0568-3
- Von Thaden, J. J., Binnqüist-Cervantes, G., Perevochtchikova, M., and Clark-Tapia, R. (2025). Deforestation dynamics post-payment for ecosystem services in Sierra Juárez, Oaxaca. Regional Environmental Change 25: 22. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10113-025-02365-1
Iberia, the Mediterranean and Arabia
- Auclair, L., and Alifriqui, M. (eds.) (2012). Agdal: patrimoine socio-écologique de l’Atlas marocain. IRCAM and IRD. Not re-read.
- Domínguez, P., Bourbouze, A., Demay, S., Genin, D., and Kosoy, N. (2012). Diverse ecological, economic and socio-cultural values of a traditional common natural resource management system in the Moroccan High Atlas: the Aït Ikiss tagdalt. Environmental Values 21(3): 277-296. Not re-read.
- Jódar, J., Martos-Rosillo, S., Custodio, E., Mateos, L., Cabello, J., Casas, J., Salinas-Bonillo, M. J., Martín-Civantos, J. M., González-Ramón, A., Lambán, L. J., et al. (2022). The recharge channels of the Sierra Nevada range (Spain) and the Peruvian Andes as ancient nature-based solutions for the ecological transition. Water 14(19): 3130. Opinion article. https://doi.org/10.3390/w14193130
- Jódar, J., Zakaluk, T., et al. (2022). Artificial recharge by means of careo channels versus natural aquifer recharge in a semi-arid, high-mountain watershed (Sierra Nevada, Spain). SSRN preprint, not peer-reviewed at time of citation. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3983975
- Martos-Rosillo, S., et al. (2017). Las acequias de careo de Sierra Nevada (sur de España): un sistema de recarga ancestral en acuíferos de alta montaña. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/320298208
- Science of the Total Environment (2018). Groundwater dynamics in a hydrologically-modified alpine watershed from an ancient managed recharge system (Sierra Nevada National Park, southern Spain). https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0048969718319570
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre (2006). Aflaj Irrigation Systems of Oman, inscription 1207. Official record. https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1207
Himalaya
- Ecological impacts of springshed management in Himalayan mountain ecosystems (2026). ScienceDirect. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2665972726002904
- Mountain Initiative (2023). Policy Brief 09: Manipur. Gray literature. https://www.mountaininitiative.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/PolicyBriefs-09-Manipur.pdf
- People’s Science Institute (n.d.). Dhara Vikas: creating water security through springshed development. Practitioner document. https://peoplesscienceinstitute.org/PDF’s/EQMG/Dhara_Vikas_Creating_water_security_through_sp.pdf
- Springs of Uttarakhand Mountains: A State of Knowledge Review with Focus on Rejuvenation of Drying Springs (2025). https://www.researchgate.net/publication/406434355
- Tambe, S., Kharel, G., Arrawatia, M. L., Kulkarni, H., Mahamuni, K., and Ganeriwala, A. K. (2012). Reviving dying springs: climate change adaptation experiments from the Sikkim Himalaya. Mountain Research and Development 32(1): 62-72. https://doi.org/10.1659/MRD-JOURNAL-D-11-00079.1
Southeast and East Asia
- Lansing, J. S. (2007). Priests and Programmers: Technologies of Power in the Engineered Landscape of Bali. Revised edition. Princeton University Press. Not re-read.
- Lansing, J. S., and Kremer, J. N. (1993). Emergent properties of Balinese water temple networks: coadaptation on a rugged fitness landscape. American Anthropologist 95(1): 97-114. https://doi.org/10.1525/aa.1993.95.1.02a00050
- SEI (2015). Managing a Living Cultural Landscape: Bali’s Subaks and the UNESCO World Heritage Site. SEI Project Report 2015-05. Gray literature. https://www.sei.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/sei-pr-2015-05-bali-cultural-landscape-lr1.pdf
- Transnational Institute (2018). Tourism and Land Grabbing in Bali. Gray literature. https://www.tni.org/files/publication-downloads/tourism_and_land_grabbing_in_bali.pdf
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. Rice Terraces of the Philippine Cordilleras (inscription 722, 1995); Cultural Landscape of Honghe Hani Rice Terraces (inscription 1111, 2013); Cultural Landscape of Bali Province (inscription 1194, 2012). Official records. https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/722 ; https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1111 ; https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1194
Africa
- African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights (2017). African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights v. Republic of Kenya (Merits), Application No. 006/2012, judgment of 26 May 2017.
- African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights (2022). African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights v. Republic of Kenya (Reparations), Application No. 006/2012, judgment of 23 June 2022. https://www.african-court.org/cpmt/storage/app/uploads/public/62f/e2b/b9a/62fe2bb9a2274387959947.pdf
- African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights (2025). African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights v. Republic of Kenya (Compliance), Application No. 006/2012, judgment of 4 December 2025. Read through the Court’s press release and judgment summary. https://www.african-court.org/afchpr/african-court-on-human-and-peoples-rights-issues-new-orders-to-kenya-over-non-compliance-in-the-ogiek-case/
- ESCR-Net (n.d.). Ogiek case. Case summary. https://www.escr-net.org/resources/ogiek-case/
- Haile, M., and Gebregziabher, D. (2020). Successful landscape restoration in Abreha We Atsbeha watershed, Tigray, Ethiopia. ETFRN News 60: 43-49. Practitioner synthesis. https://communityrights.tropenbos.org/file.php/2396/1-3-haile.pdf
- Gebregziabher, G., Abera, D. A., Gebresamuel, G., Giordano, M., and Langan, S. (2016). An assessment of integrated watershed management in Ethiopia. IWMI Working Paper 170. International Water Management Institute. Cited through Haile and Gebregziabher (2020); not opened. https://doi.org/10.5337/2016.214
- Characterization and impact assessment of water harvesting techniques: a case study of Abreha Weatsbeha watershed, Tigray, Ethiopia. https://www.academia.edu/127449563 (summary at https://restoration.elti.yale.edu/resource/charaterization-and-impact-assessment-water-harvesting-techniques-case-study-abreha-atsbeha)
- IFAD (n.d.). Kenya: Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund project supervision report. Official evaluation. https://www.ifad.org/documents/48415603/49495149/ORMS+Supervision+Template.pdf/a44c9c60-2257-be22-6e72-ca605f8d5421?t=1726609164663
- Minority Rights Group (2025). Violations against Kenya’s indigenous Ogiek condemned yet again by African Court. Advocacy organization. https://minorityrights.org/ogiek-2025/
- Mongabay (2023). Violent evictions are latest ordeal for Kenya’s Ogiek seeking land rights. Media. https://news.mongabay.com/2023/12/violent-evictions-are-latest-ordeal-for-kenyas-ogiek-seeking-land-rights/
- Negusse, T., Yazew, E., and Tadesse, N. (2013). Quantification of the impact of integrated soil and water conservation measures on groundwater availability in Mendae catchment, Abraha We-Atsebaha, eastern Tigray, Ethiopia. Momona Ethiopian Journal of Science 5(2): 117-136. https://www.ajol.info/index.php/mejs/article/view/91495
- The Nature Conservancy (2015). Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund Business Case. Gray literature. https://www.nature.org/content/dam/tnc/nature/en/documents/Nairobi-Water-Fund-Business-Case_FINAL.pdf
- UTNWF (2016). Annual Report 2016. Mission-sourced. https://s3.amazonaws.com/tnc-craft/library/Nairobi-Water-Fund-Annual-Report-2016.pdf
- UTNWF (2021). Strategic Plan 2022-2026. Mission-sourced. https://nairobiwaterfund.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/UTNWF-Strategic-Plan_Final.pdf
Oceania
- Griffith Law Review (2025). Reimagining riverine rights: Te Awa Tupua, the Turag River and Birrarung. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10383441.2025.2526959
- Mongabay (2025). Taranaki Maunga, a New Zealand mountain, declared a legal person. Media. https://news.mongabay.com/short-article/2025/02/taranaki-maunga-new-zealand-mountain-declared-a-legal-person/
- New Zealand Parliament (2014). Te Urewera Act 2014, Public Act 2014 No 51. https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2014/51/en/latest/
- New Zealand Parliament (2017). Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River Claims Settlement) Act 2017, Public Act 2017 No 7. https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2017/7/en/latest/
- New Zealand Parliament (2025). Te Ture Whakatupua mō Te Kāhui Tupua 2025 / Taranaki Maunga Collective Redress Act 2025, Public Act 2025 No 1, s 18. https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2025/1/en/latest/
- Reynecke (2022). The braided river of legal personality. New Zealand Journal of Public and International Law 20(1). https://www.wgtn.ac.nz/public-law/publications/nz-journal-of-public-and-international-law/previous-issues/volume-20-issue-1-2022/05-reynecke-pdf
- University of Canterbury (n.d.). Voice, power and legitimacy: the role of the legal person in river management. Thesis. https://ir.canterbury.ac.nz/server/api/core/bitstreams/cd0131bd-457f-47cb-939e-b6d1713e31a0/content
Earlier wiki runs used as inputs
- Retention Works on the Slope, Unproven at the River (28 October 2026): source of the Slovakia row and the hydrology grades.
- Community-Led Landscape Restoration in Sub-Saharan Africa (14 October 2026).
- Exclusion from Water Finance (25 October 2026): source of the FONAG, Sengwer and Lesotho rows.
Provenance
Written on 9 November 2026 under version 0.1 of abcde-mountain-water-commons-deep-research.md. The research run made 18 web searches and one delegated check of Coady ABCD sources, mostly in English with some Spanish. The multilingual search the instructions call for (French, Italian, German, Nepali, Hindi, Indonesian, Chinese, Japanese, Amharic and te reo Māori) was not done.
The research tools could not open the wiki corpus pages during the run, so the brief was written without reading the current text or epistemic_status of the pages it builds on; section 7 of the instructions was used as given. Rows citing “Instruction lead, not re-verified” rest on the instructions’ leads and standard literature and are graded [TBV]. Climate fields are indicative and were not checked against station records. The run’s own text gave 45 rows; the table holds 46, and the counts here follow the table. Makutano and Valencia are included despite a weak mountain fit. Forest-cover outcomes (PSAH, Oaxaca) are graded as proxies and are not water measurements. The Abreha we Atsbeha groundwater conflict is reported and left unresolved. Citation details added at writing for works the run named without full entries (Kretzmann and McKnight, Immerzeel, Feng, Asquith, Grillos, Lansing, Netting, McKean, Cox 2014, Domínguez, Auclair, Muñoz-Piña, the New Zealand statutes and UNESCO listings) should be checked before source pages are created. No place-specific material from Ward 2 or the surrounding valley was used. Revised the same day: the Markdown case table and its spreadsheet link were replaced by an embedded base, mountain-water-commons.base, built from one page per case in the new case register, so that later enrichment runs update the cases in one place. An enrichment pass the same day checked the 25 cases then graded [TBV] (the hand-back had counted 22) with web search, mostly in English sources, with Austrian court records in German: 13 were raised to [IC], 5 set to [MS] and 7 left at [TBV]. It withdrew the coding of the High Atlas agdal as eroding, found a profile of FONAG that lists community representatives on its board, found no payment scheme at Paro (the documented Bhutanese case is Yakpugang), and added measured return-flow and recharge figures for the New Mexico acequias. A second, multilingual enrichment run the same day found a watershed payment at Paro (the Namey Nichu agreement of 2015), so the Paro case was rewritten as that agreement and Yakpugang was added as a 47th case; it also added Azheke as a named sub-entry of the Hani case and noted that the Coady Ethiopia and Makutano cases share an evaluator. Its grade changes were then applied to the case pages: uMngeni, FONAG, the Catskills, iriai, Eigg, the Potato Park and the Arequipa qochas were raised to [IC], the ACWADAM and People’s Science Institute springsheds set to [MS], and six [MS] cases kept at [MS] with their new sources recorded. FONAG’s own records show only institutional constituents on its board, which supports Exclusion from Water Finance. The regional subsections of “Cases by mountain system” then moved, without change to their wording, to the eight regional pages of the register, and this section now links to them. Checked the same day: the full citations added at writing were confirmed against publisher, DOI or repository records, except Kretzmann and McKnight, Netting, McKean, Lansing (2007), Auclair and Alifriqui, and the Domínguez et al. authors, which remain not re-read. The check corrected four entries. Bottazzi et al. (2014) is Bétrisey and Mager (2014). The 2018 Oaxaca land-cover study is Navarro Cerrillo et al. (2019); its abstract does not compare community and protected forests, so that comparison was removed. The Ogiek compliance judgment found partial compliance with the 2017 judgment and none with the 2022 reparations, where the brief had said no part of either. The New Zealand statute links were corrected. The Abreha we Atsbeha groundwater figures were reconciled with the two earlier briefs: Haile and Gebregziabher (2020), citing Gebregziabher et al. (2016), give a water table rising from about 50 m to about 5 m below the surface, where the research report had 45 m. Glossary entries were added for Asset-Based Community Development, territory of life, reciprocal water agreement, water tower and springshed, and fifteen source pages were created.