African mountain catchments appear in the register mostly as state land, water-fund project sites or contested territories, and the communities in them seldom hold the money.
Right of reply
This page describes communities, organizations and programs only through their published records and statements. None has yet been invited to comment. Responses and corrections will be recorded on the case pages with their date. [MS] marks a claim that rests on the account of the party the claim is about.
The cases
Abreha we Atsbeha, Tigray (Ethiopia). A 6,766-hectare watershed in which 4,644 hectares (69%) was placed in exclosures and 55 check dams were built. About 650 hand-dug wells now irrigate. The community received the UN Equator Prize in 2012. Reported groundwater figures differ by source. Haile and Gebregziabher (2020), citing Gebregziabher et al. (2016), state that groundwater once lay about 50 m below the surface and now lies about 5 m below it. A characterization study gives 15 m to 3 m and a 21.22% runoff reduction, and Negusse et al. (2013) report a roughly tenfold increase in groundwater availability in the Mendae catchment since 1993. The wiki’s earlier briefs read Gebregziabher et al. (2016) as a rise of about 5 m. The sources agree that the water table rose; none has a control catchment, and the size of the rise is unresolved [IC on direction, TBV on size]. The work combined community labor with the state’s food-for-work and later the Productive Safety Net Programme (PSNP).
Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund (Kenya). A trust created in 2015 with The Nature Conservancy, Nairobi’s utility, KenGen, companies and donors. Its 2016 report claims 27 million more liters a day reaching Nairobi, and its 2022 to 2026 strategy cites 44,725 farmers and an 11% reduction in turbidity [MS]. Targets of 15% more dry-season flow and 18% less sediment are model projections. An IFAD supervision mission recommended better farmer representation at the governance level. Farmers receive inputs and training, and the board is held by contributors.
Ogiek and the Mau (Kenya). The Mau Forest Complex (about 273,300 hectares) is a national water tower. The African Court found in 2017 that evictions violated Ogiek rights, holding that conservation could not justify them and that the Ogiek were not responsible for degradation (African Court 2017). In 2022 it ordered reparations of about KES 157.8 million (about US$1.3 million) and recognition of title (African Court 2022) [IC]. In its first compliance judgment, of 4 December 2025 (Application No. 006/2012), the Court found that Kenya had complied only partly with the 2017 judgment and had paid none of the reparations ordered in 2022, and ordered immediate implementation (African Court 2025) [IC]. In November 2023 a joint force moved to evict about 700 Ogiek households [IC]. Global Forest Watch data reported by Mongabay show the complex lost 19% of tree cover between 2001 and 2022 [IC]. The wiki treats this pattern under conservation violence and fortress conservation.
Table Mountain Group catchments, Western Cape (South Africa). Holden et al. (2022) estimated that clearing invasive trees in the mountain catchments supplying Cape Town would increase streamflow, especially in drought. Tanner et al. (2017) describe the hydrological functioning of palmiet wetlands, which in the Cape Fold Belt are fed by sandstone aquifers. State-funded teams and a water fund do the clearing. Communities hold neither the catchments nor the money and take part as paid labor [IC on hydrology from the prior run].
Sengwer of Embobut (Kenya). Amnesty International (2018) found that the 2013 decision to resettle all residents of the 22,000-hectare Embobut Forest was taken without genuinely consulting the Sengwer, that up to 1,500 homes were burned in January 2014 and more than 300 after December 2017, and that a Sengwer man was shot dead on 16 January 2018; the EU suspended its Kenya Water Towers programme the next day [IC].
Lesotho Highlands Water Project. International Rivers (2001) reported more than 30,000 rural farmers affected, no compensation before displacement and declining living standards for most affected people, while royalties and customs dues made up 27.8% of government revenue [IC].
Maloti-Drakensberg payment proposals (South Africa). Blignaut and colleagues (2010) modeled grassland restoration in a range that covers under 5% of the country and yields about 25% of its runoff, and found benefits above costs in low to medium degraded land [IC]; no implemented community scheme was found.
Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof and the uMngeni partnership (South Africa). The Baviaanskloof work runs through a 2014 partnership and a farmer-owned development company, by its partners’ account [MS]; the uMngeni partnership, begun with a 2013 memorandum signed by 21 parties and coordinated by SANBI and eThekwini, has no rural community or land-rights holder among its members, and its water gains are modeled (Pringle et al. 2023; Hughes et al. 2018) [IC]. In each of these five cases the community appears as evictee, resettled household, worker, landowner-shareholder or project site, and none holds the catchment’s water value.
ABCD cases. The region holds the register’s only three cases that are ABCD by name or ABCD-framed, and none of them governs a mountain catchment. In the Coady ABCD program in Ethiopia, groups grew from five in 2003 to 24 in 2011 and put natural resources on their asset maps; comparing the 2008 and 2011 maps “did not reveal many changes in the natural resource base or physical infrastructure” (Peters 2013) [MS], and no water measurement was made. At Makutano in semi-arid Yatta, Kenya, each of 26 water points is run by an elected committee with its own bank account, and members pay 250 Kenya shillings a year (Mahomed and Peters 2011) [MS]; the site lies outside any mountain catchment. ICRAF’s asset-based regreening in Nyando concerns agroforestry on smallholdings (Fuchs, Peters and Neufeldt 2019), and no water outcome was measured. The Ethiopian and Makutano cases both rest on evaluations compiled by Brianne Peters at the Coady Institute, and a second enrichment run found no independent evaluation of either beyond one 2014 radio report on Makutano.
In the register
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Tenure | Beyond-market markers | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Northern highlands | state-program | state | B2 | [IC] |
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Nyando uplands | abcd-by-name | private | B2 | [IC] |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Highlands | abcd-by-name | state | B2 | [MS] |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | state-program | mixed | [IC] | |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | Maloti | state-program | state | [IC] | |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | ngo-program | mixed | B6 | [MS] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | abcd-framed | mixed | B2, B4, B8 | [MS] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Drakensberg-Maloti | negotiated-payments | mixed | [IC] | |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | Mau escarpment | territory-of-life | contested | B1 | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Cherangany Hills | territory-of-life | contested | B1 | [IC] |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | Drakensberg foothills | state-program | mixed | [IC] | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | water-fund | mixed | [MS] |
| Case | Coordination | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | I+T | state | State food-for-work, PSNP, donors | B2 | 20+ yrs |
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | E+T | private | Donor-funded | B2 | Not verified |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | T+E | state | Community own resources; Bale Salka: govt 53%, community 36%, NGO 11% | B2 | Groups grew 5 to 24 |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | I+M | mixed | State and fund pay teams | Funding-dependent | |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | I+M | state | South Africa pays royalties to the Lesotho state; with customs dues they made up 27.8% of government revenue (late 1990s); compensation to resettled households | 40 yrs | |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | E+M | mixed | Donors and partners fund restoration; the farmer-owned Baviaanskloof Development Company reports over €2.5 million raised | B6 | Partnership formed 2014 with a 20-year commitment |
| Makutano Water Points | T+E | mixed | Users pay 250 KES/yr to committee accounts | B2, B4, B8 | 20+ yrs |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | I+M | mixed | Not implemented at scale | Not launched | |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | T vs I | contested | KES ~157.8m reparations ordered, unpaid | B1 | Rulings stand; compliance judgment of 4 Dec 2025 found the 2017 judgment partly implemented and the 2022 reparations unpaid |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | T vs I | contested | EU Kenya Water Towers programme (reported as USD 35 million) to Kenya's forest agencies; suspended January 2018, later ended | B1 | Evictions since 2009 under a 2013 resettlement decision; EU suspended its programme on 17 January 2018 |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | I+E | mixed | Municipal and utility budgets fund pilot projects led by uMgungundlovu, Msunduzi and eThekwini; no payment to upstream residents found | Memorandum of understanding signed by 21 parties in 2013; strategy adopted July 2016; SANBI lists 17 member organizations | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | I+M | mixed | City utility, KenGen, firms, donors to trust; farmers get inputs | 10 yrs |
| Case | Water outcome | Water evidence | Community outcome | Community evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Water table from about 50 m to about 5 m below surface (as cited), or 15 to 3 m; tenfold groundwater availability since 1993; runoff -21% | E3 | 650 wells; irrigation [MS] | E5 | [IC] | partial |
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Not measured | E5 | Livelihood comparisons | E4 | [IC] | partial |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Not measured | E5 | Few natural-resource changes on maps | E4 | [MS] | no |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | Modeled drought streamflow gains | E4 | Jobs | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Transfer to Gauteng | E4 | More than 30,000 rural farmers affected by the first phases; no compensation before displacement; living standards of most affected people reported declining | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | Not measured; the catchment is reported to supply about 70% of Port Elizabeth's water | E5 | Only four farmers in the development company's loan scheme within a 41,000 ha area (Commonland 2020) [MS]; farmers reported willing to keep working with Living Lands (de Villiers et al. 2026, co-produced) | E4 | [MS] | no |
| Makutano Water Points | Not measured | E5 | Walk to water was 15 km [MS] | E5 | [MS] | partial |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | Modeled: improved grassland management raises baseflow; benefits exceed costs in low to medium degraded areas, not in heavily degraded ones | E4 | Not applicable | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | 19% tree cover loss 2001-22 (complex) | E4 | ~700 households evicted Nov 2023 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Not measured | E5 | Up to 1,500 homes burned in January 2014; more than 300 since December 2017; one Sengwer man shot dead on 16 January 2018 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | Modeled gains in dry-season baseflow and lower sediment yield from rehabilitating degraded land and clearing invasive plants; no measured outcome found | E4 | No figure found for jobs or income going to catchment residents; no rural community, traditional council or land-rights holder named as a member | E5 | [IC] | partial |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Reported: turbidity 11% lower (UTNWF) or suspended sediment 21.3% below average with 8% less filtration chemical use (Toolbox, December 2023); projected: 50% lower sediment and up to 15% more water yield (TNC 2015); no independent measurement | E5 | 44,725 farmers [MS] | E5 | [MS] | no |
| Case | Capture or harm | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Resettlement harms; the royalty fund meant for the poorest was restructured by the World Bank after political misuse | 40 yrs | [IC] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | No implemented community payment scheme found | Not launched | [IC] |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | State eviction | Rulings stand; compliance judgment of 4 Dec 2025 found the 2017 judgment partly implemented and the 2022 reparations unpaid | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | State eviction; Amnesty found the Sengwer were never genuinely consulted | Evictions since 2009 under a 2013 resettlement decision; EU suspended its programme on 17 January 2018 | [IC] |
The tabs show the region’s cases with their lineage and tenure, their value flows and governance, their outcomes and evidence levels, the failures and captures, and the cases awaiting enrichment. Each case page gives the full coding. The codes are explained on the case register page.
Related
- Community Catchment Case Register
- Mountain Water Commons: Community-Held Catchments Beyond Asset-Based Development
Provenance
Created on 9 November 2026 by moving the “Africa” subsection of the brief’s “Cases by mountain system” section to this page without change to its wording. Links to case pages were added to the case names, and the opening sentence and the embedded base africa.base were added. The base lists every case page whose mountain_region is “Africa”. Revised the same day: the Abreha we Atsbeha groundwater figures were reconciled with the wiki’s two earlier briefs, and the account of the Ogiek compliance judgment was corrected against the Court’s own press release and summary. The paragraph on ABCD cases was added the same day from the brief’s “What the syntheses conclude” section, because those three cases are filed in this region and the Africa subsection did not cover them. Enriched on 9 November 2026: the paragraph on cases first coded [TBV] was rewritten from the enrichment pass, with each case linked to its page and graded as its page now is. Updated the same day with the grade changes from the second enrichment run.