Makutano Water Points is a record in the case register, coded from the evidence reviewed in Mountain Water Commons. Its claim grade is [MS].
Right of reply
This page describes the communities, organizations and programs in this case only through their published records and statements. None has yet been invited to comment. Responses and corrections will be recorded here with their date. [MS] marks a claim that rests on the account of the party the claim is about.
Coding
The codes are explained on the case register page. Coordinates are an approximate centroid for map views.
| Field | Entry |
|---|---|
| Country and region | Kenya, Machakos (Yatta) |
| Mountain system | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) |
| Climate | BSh; ~600 mm |
| Period | 1998 to present |
| Lineage | ABCD-framed by Coady |
| Assets mobilized | A1 A2 A4 A5 A7 |
| Retention methods | 9 dams, 17 sub-surface wells |
| Coordination (TIME) | T+E |
| Tenure | Communal/private |
| Value flow | Users pay 250 KES/yr to committee accounts |
| Beyond-market markers | B2 B4 B8 |
| Water outcome | Not measured |
| Community outcome | Walk to water was 15 km [MS] |
| Persistence | 20+ yrs |
| Capture or harm | None found |
| Evidence, water | E5 |
| Evidence, community | E5 |
| Claim grade | [MS] |
| Independent of implementing partner | Partial |
Note on sources
This case and Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia both rest on evaluations compiled by Brianne Peters at the Coady International Institute, which ran or framed both programs. The second enrichment run of 9 November 2026 searched for independent evaluations of each; it found none for Ethiopia, and for Makutano one 2014 radio report (May, The World) whose counts of roads and water points differ from Coady’s. The two cases are kept separate, and their shared evaluator should be weighed when they are read together.
In the briefs
- Mountain Water Commons: Community-Held Catchments Beyond Asset-Based Development (9 November 2026). The regional narrative is on Africa.
Sources
- May, M. (2014). Kenyan communities succeed in managing scarce water, where aid projects once foundered. The World, PRI, 3 July 2014. Media.
Mahomed and Peters 2011. Full citations are in the Sources section of Mountain Water Commons.
Provenance
Created on 9 November 2026 from row KE-ABCD-MAKUTANO of the Mountain Water Commons case table, when that table moved into the case register. Entries are copied from the table without change; the lineage_type, tenure_type, climate_group and coordinates keys were added for filtering. Page status follows the claim grade: [IC] gives academic-inference, [MS] gives working-hypothesis, [TBV] gives stub.