| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Tenure | Beyond-market markers | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Ethiopia | Northern highlands | state-program | state | B2 | [IC] |
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Kenya | Nyando uplands | abcd-by-name | private | B2 | [IC] |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Ethiopia | Highlands | abcd-by-name | state | B2 | [MS] |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | state-program | mixed | [IC] | |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Lesotho | Maloti | state-program | state | [IC] | |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | South Africa | Cape Fold Belt | ngo-program | mixed | B6 | [MS] |
| Makutano Water Points | Kenya | Not mountain (semi-arid plain) | abcd-framed | mixed | B2, B4, B8 | [MS] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | South Africa | Drakensberg-Maloti | negotiated-payments | mixed | [IC] | |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | Kenya | Mau escarpment | territory-of-life | contested | B1 | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Kenya | Cherangany Hills | territory-of-life | contested | B1 | [IC] |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | South Africa | Drakensberg foothills | state-program | mixed | [IC] | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Kenya | Aberdares, Mount Kenya | water-fund | mixed | [MS] |
| Case | Coordination | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | I+T | state | State food-for-work, PSNP, donors | B2 | 20+ yrs |
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | E+T | private | Donor-funded | B2 | Not verified |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | T+E | state | Community own resources; Bale Salka: govt 53%, community 36%, NGO 11% | B2 | Groups grew 5 to 24 |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | I+M | mixed | State and fund pay teams | Funding-dependent | |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | I+M | state | South Africa pays royalties to the Lesotho state; with customs dues they made up 27.8% of government revenue (late 1990s); compensation to resettled households | 40 yrs | |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | E+M | mixed | Donors and partners fund restoration; the farmer-owned Baviaanskloof Development Company reports over €2.5 million raised | B6 | Partnership formed 2014 with a 20-year commitment |
| Makutano Water Points | T+E | mixed | Users pay 250 KES/yr to committee accounts | B2, B4, B8 | 20+ yrs |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | I+M | mixed | Not implemented at scale | Not launched | |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | T vs I | contested | KES ~157.8m reparations ordered, unpaid | B1 | Rulings stand; compliance judgment of 4 Dec 2025 found the 2017 judgment partly implemented and the 2022 reparations unpaid |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | T vs I | contested | EU Kenya Water Towers programme (reported as USD 35 million) to Kenya's forest agencies; suspended January 2018, later ended | B1 | Evictions since 2009 under a 2013 resettlement decision; EU suspended its programme on 17 January 2018 |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | I+E | mixed | Municipal and utility budgets fund pilot projects led by uMgungundlovu, Msunduzi and eThekwini; no payment to upstream residents found | Memorandum of understanding signed by 21 parties in 2013; strategy adopted July 2016; SANBI lists 17 member organizations | |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | I+M | mixed | City utility, KenGen, firms, donors to trust; farmers get inputs | 10 yrs |
| Case | Water outcome | Water evidence | Community outcome | Community evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abreha we Atsbeha Watershed | Water table from about 50 m to about 5 m below surface (as cited), or 15 to 3 m; tenfold groundwater availability since 1993; runoff -21% | E3 | 650 wells; irrigation [MS] | E5 | [IC] | partial |
| Asset-Based Regreening in Nyando | Not measured | E5 | Livelihood comparisons | E4 | [IC] | partial |
| Coady ABCD Program in Ethiopia | Not measured | E5 | Few natural-resource changes on maps | E4 | [MS] | no |
| Invasive Clearing in Table Mountain Group Catchments | Modeled drought streamflow gains | E4 | Jobs | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Transfer to Gauteng | E4 | More than 30,000 rural farmers affected by the first phases; no compensation before displacement; living standards of most affected people reported declining | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof | Not measured; the catchment is reported to supply about 70% of Port Elizabeth's water | E5 | Only four farmers in the development company's loan scheme within a 41,000 ha area (Commonland 2020) [MS]; farmers reported willing to keep working with Living Lands (de Villiers et al. 2026, co-produced) | E4 | [MS] | no |
| Makutano Water Points | Not measured | E5 | Walk to water was 15 km [MS] | E5 | [MS] | partial |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | Modeled: improved grassland management raises baseflow; benefits exceed costs in low to medium degraded areas, not in heavily degraded ones | E4 | Not applicable | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | 19% tree cover loss 2001-22 (complex) | E4 | ~700 households evicted Nov 2023 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | Not measured | E5 | Up to 1,500 homes burned in January 2014; more than 300 since December 2017; one Sengwer man shot dead on 16 January 2018 | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| uMngeni Ecological Infrastructure Partnership | Modeled gains in dry-season baseflow and lower sediment yield from rehabilitating degraded land and clearing invasive plants; no measured outcome found | E4 | No figure found for jobs or income going to catchment residents; no rural community, traditional council or land-rights holder named as a member | E5 | [IC] | partial |
| Upper Tana-Nairobi Water Fund | Reported: turbidity 11% lower (UTNWF) or suspended sediment 21.3% below average with 8% less filtration chemical use (Toolbox, December 2023); projected: 50% lower sediment and up to 15% more water yield (TNC 2015); no independent measurement | E5 | 44,725 farmers [MS] | E5 | [MS] | no |
| Case | Capture or harm | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lesotho Highlands Water Project | Resettlement harms; the royalty fund meant for the poorest was restructured by the World Bank after political misuse | 40 yrs | [IC] |
| Maloti-Drakensberg Payment Proposals | No implemented community payment scheme found | Not launched | [IC] |
| Ogiek and the Mau Forest | State eviction | Rulings stand; compliance judgment of 4 Dec 2025 found the 2017 judgment partly implemented and the 2022 reparations unpaid | [IC] |
| Sengwer and the Embobut Forest | State eviction; Amnesty found the Sengwer were never genuinely consulted | Evictions since 2009 under a 2013 resettlement decision; EU suspended its programme on 17 January 2018 | [IC] |