Living Lands in the Baviaanskloof is a record in the case register, checked against its sources in two enrichment passes on 9 November 2026. Its claim grade is [MS].
Right of reply
This page describes the communities, organizations and programs in this case only through their published records and statements. None has yet been invited to comment. Responses and corrections will be recorded here with their date. [MS] marks a claim that rests on the account of the party the claim is about.
Coding
The codes are explained on the case register page. Coordinates are an approximate centroid for map views.
| Field | Entry |
|---|---|
| Country and region | South Africa, Eastern Cape |
| Mountain system | Cape Fold Belt |
| Climate | BSk/Cfb; ~250-700 mm |
| Period | 2010s |
| Lineage | NGO restoration |
| Assets mobilized | A2 A7 A8 |
| Retention methods | Thicket and wetland restoration |
| Coordination (TIME) | E+M |
| Tenure | Private farms, protected area |
| Value flow | Donors and partners fund restoration; the farmer-owned Baviaanskloof Development Company reports over €2.5 million raised |
| Beyond-market markers | B6 |
| Water outcome | Not measured; the catchment is reported to supply about 70% of Port Elizabeth’s water |
| Community outcome | Only four farmers in the development company’s loan scheme within a 41,000 ha area (Commonland 2020) [MS]; farmers reported willing to keep working with Living Lands (de Villiers et al. 2026, co-produced) |
| Persistence | Partnership formed 2014 with a 20-year commitment |
| Capture or harm | None found; spekboom planting across the wider regional program averaged 28% survival |
| Evidence, water | E5 |
| Evidence, community | E4 |
| Claim grade | [MS] |
| Independent of implementing partner | no |
What the sources show
Commonland formed a partnership in 2014 with Living Lands and Grounded for the catchments that supply Port Elizabeth, committing to at least 20 years. It describes the Baviaanskloof Development Company as a farmer-owned business that has secured over €2.5 million, and sets targets of 32,000 hectares under restoration or regenerative agriculture and about 500 jobs. It reports no measured water result [MS]. The farmer-owned company is a market form with a local owner; no collective tenure of the catchment was found.
Second enrichment run. The second enrichment run found that most academic work on this case is co-produced with Living Lands. A 2026 article in People and Nature (de Villiers et al.), written as a collaborative reflection with Living Lands from interviews with 12 Baviaanskloof and 6 Langkloof residents, reports that farmers remained willing to keep working with the organization after a disappointment. Commonland’s 2020 case study states that only four farmers were in the development company’s loan scheme within a 41,000-hectare area [MS]. Independently, Mills and Robson (2017) found that about 21.5 million spekboom cuttings planted under the regional thicket restoration program from 2004 to 2016 had an average survival of 28% [IC]; their plots were outside Living Lands’ sites, so the finding bears on the method.
In the briefs
- Mountain Water Commons: Community-Held Catchments Beyond Asset-Based Development (9 November 2026). The regional narrative is on Africa.
Sources
- Commonland (n.d.). Restoring the landscape to secure Port Elizabeth a sustainable future. Partner account. https://common.earth/commonland-port-elizabeth
- de Villiers, A., Esler, K. J., Cockburn, J., and Spierenburg, M. (2026). Remaking place relations for social-ecological restoration: reflections on placemaking in South Africa. People and Nature. Co-produced with Living Lands. https://doi.org/10.1002/pan3.70439
- Mills, A. J., and Robson, A. (2017). Survivorship of spekboom (Portulacaria afra) planted within the Subtropical Thicket Restoration Programme. South African Journal of Science. https://doi.org/10.17159/sajs.2017/a0196
- Commonland (2020). Transformation towards sustainable land use: Forest landscape restoration, South Africa case study. Partner account. https://www.commonland.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/202003_Forest-Landscape-Restoration_SouthAfricaCaseStudy.pdf
Provenance
Created on 9 November 2026 from row ZA-BAVIAANSKLOOF-LIVINGLANDS of the Mountain Water Commons case table, when that table moved into the case register. Entries are copied from the table without change; the lineage_type, tenure_type, climate_group and coordinates keys were added for filtering. Page status follows the claim grade: [IC] gives academic-inference, [MS] gives working-hypothesis, [TBV] gives stub. Enriched on 9 November 2026: the entries were checked against the sources listed, the grade was set to [MS] on that basis ([IC] for a peer-reviewed study, an official record or two independent sources; [MS] where the only source is the party or its partner), and the Sources section now gives full citations. A second, multilingual enrichment run the same day added the sources marked in the second paragraph of What the sources show and set the grade to [MS].