Pynegar, E.L., Jones, J.P.G., Gibbons, J.M. and Asquith, N.M. (2018). “The effectiveness of Payments for Ecosystem Services at delivering improvements in water quality: lessons for experiments at the landscape scale.” PeerJ 6: e5753.
The study randomly assigned 129 communities in Bolivia’s Río Grande valleys to Fundación Natura Bolivia’s Watershared reciprocal agreements (65) or to control (64), and measured E. coli in community water supplies at a 2010 baseline and a 2015 endline. It found no significant effect at the landscape scale. Cattle feces in or near water raised contamination locally, and uptake was low, with a median of 2.5% of eligible land enrolled. Natura’s policy director is a co-author, and the paper says so. The wiki takes from it the only randomized test of a reciprocal water agreement found, and its lesson that randomizing by community fails when catchments cross community lines.