New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills is a record in the case register, checked against its sources in two enrichment passes on 9 November 2026. Its claim grade is [IC].
Right of reply
This page describes the communities, organizations and programs in this case only through their published records and statements. None has yet been invited to comment. Responses and corrections will be recorded here with their date. [MS] marks a claim that rests on the account of the party the claim is about.
Coding
The codes are explained on the case register page. Coordinates are an approximate centroid for map views.
| Field | Entry |
|---|---|
| Country and region | United States, New York |
| Mountain system | Catskills |
| Climate | Dfb; ~1,100-1,300 mm |
| Period | 1993 WAC; 1997 MOA |
| Lineage | Negotiated payments |
| Assets mobilized | A2 A3 A5 A7 |
| Retention methods | Farm plans, easements |
| Coordination (TIME) | I+M; E subordinate |
| Tenure | Private farms, city land |
| Value flow | New York City pays cost-share for farm best management practices through the farmer-led Watershed Agricultural Council |
| Beyond-market markers | B7 B8 |
| Water outcome | Filtration avoidance maintained [TBV] |
| Community outcome | The 2017 FAD requires a US$11 million contract with the Watershed Agricultural Council; no new West-of-Hudson whole farm plans were approved in 2022 |
| Persistence | Whole Farm Program from 1992; Memorandum of Agreement 1997; Revised 2017 Filtration Avoidance Determination issued December 2022 |
| Capture or harm | Unresolved issues over long-term stewardship and the city’s water supply permit, raised by the Coalition of Watershed Towns; no new conservation easements conveyed in 2022 |
| Evidence, water | E2 |
| Evidence, community | E5 |
| Claim grade | [IC] |
| Independent of implementing partner | yes |
What the sources show
An Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy account from the 1990s describes the Whole Farm Program, begun in 1992, in which New York City pays cost-share for best management practices on watershed farms through the farmer-led Watershed Agricultural Council. Farmers chose whether to join, and the target of 85% participation within five years was reported met ahead of schedule. The program was expected to spare the city a filtration plant estimated at about US$6 billion to build and US$300 million a year to run. These figures date from the 1990s; current records from the city’s filtration avoidance determinations were not read in this pass.
Second enrichment run. The second enrichment run read the current regulatory record. The New York State Department of Health issued the Revised 2017 Filtration Avoidance Determination in December 2022, after a comment period the Coalition of Watershed Towns asked to extend. The determination requires the city to register a contract or amendment giving the Watershed Agricultural Council US$11 million. The city’s 2022 annual report states that “the WAP did not approve any new WFPs on WOH farms” that year and that no new conservation easements were conveyed to the state [IC]. The council’s board composition and the substance of the towns’ objections were not read.
In the briefs
- Mountain Water Commons: Community-Held Catchments Beyond Asset-Based Development (9 November 2026). The regional narrative is on Mexico and North America.
Sources
- Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy (n.d., 1990s). The New York City Watershed Whole Farm Program. Gray literature. https://www.iatp.org/sites/default/files/New_York_City_Watershed_Whole_Farm_Program.htm
- New York State Department of Health (2022). Revised 2017 New York City Filtration Avoidance Determination. December 2022. Official record. https://www.health.ny.gov/environmental/water/drinking/nycfad/docs/nyc_fad.pdf
- NYC Department of Environmental Protection (2023). 2022 FAD Annual Report. Official record. https://www.nyc.gov/assets/dep/downloads/pdf/about/filtration-avoidance-determination/fad_11_fad_annual_2022.pdf
- NYC Department of Environmental Protection (2022). Response to comments on deliverables, 30 March 2022. https://www.nyc.gov/assets/dep/downloads/pdf/about/filtration-avoidance-determination/dep_response_to_comments_on_nov_dec_2021_jan_2022_deliverables.pdf
Provenance
Created on 9 November 2026 from row US-NYC-CATSKILLS of the Mountain Water Commons case table, when that table moved into the case register. Entries are copied from the table without change; the lineage_type, tenure_type, climate_group and coordinates keys were added for filtering. Page status follows the claim grade: [IC] gives academic-inference, [MS] gives working-hypothesis, [TBV] gives stub. Enriched on 9 November 2026: the entries were checked against the sources listed, the grade was set to [TBV] on that basis ([IC] for a peer-reviewed study, an official record or two independent sources; [MS] where the only source is the party or its partner), and the Sources section now gives full citations. A second, multilingual enrichment run the same day added the sources marked in the second paragraph of What the sources show and set the grade to [IC].