Mexican comunidades hold their forests and the payments made for them, New Mexico acequias run a centuries-old irrigation commons, and Catskills farmers supply New York City under the city’s agreement.
Right of reply
This page describes communities, organizations and programs only through their published records and statements. None has yet been invited to comment. Responses and corrections will be recorded on the case pages with their date. [MS] marks a claim that rests on the account of the party the claim is about.
The cases
Hydrological payments (PSAH, Mexico). The program started in 2003 with MXN 200 million (US$18.2 million) earmarked from federal water fees. Rates were 300 pesos per hectare per year for forest and 400 for cloud forest. In early years, 64% of enrolled land was at low or very low deforestation risk (Muñoz-Piña et al. 2008). Alix-Garcia and colleagues found small to moderate avoided deforestation (3ie Impact Evaluation 20) [IC]. Payments go to the ejido or comunidad assembly, which decides use.
Sierra Norte, Oaxaca. Zapotec and Chinantec communities such as Ixtlán de Juárez and Capulálpam de Méndez run community forest enterprises on communal land. In the Sierra de Juárez, forest cover fell until 2001 and then recovered, so that in 2014 it covered about 84% of the area and slightly exceeded its 1979 extent; the authors attribute the trend to community organization, forest enterprises and payment programs (Navarro Cerrillo et al. 2019) [IC]. Von Thaden et al. (2025) found that parcels at least ten years past the end of PSAH payments had significantly higher deforestation than controls, and that nearly 70% of enrolled parcels were in areas of low to medium deforestation risk [IC]. The payment effect faded while the community forestry institutions persisted.
Acequias of northern New Mexico. Field studies found that about 60% of water diverted into a main acequia returns to the river as surface flow, 33% as shallow groundwater and 7% is lost to evapotranspiration, with seepage recharging the aquifer at about 1,169 mm a year and extending the runoff season downstream (Rango et al. 2013) [IC]. In Taos valley the acequias produce less and have mostly lost their common pastures; Cox (2014) attributes much of this to demographic change, markets and public policy, and finds that members rated pressure to sell water rights lower than drought, newcomers and falling participation [IC]. Cox and Ross (2011) link weaker performance to the subdivision of land among new residents [IC].
The Catskills and New York City. Under the Whole Farm Program from 1992, the city pays cost-share through the farmer-led Watershed Agricultural Council. The Revised 2017 Filtration Avoidance Determination, issued in December 2022, requires a US$11 million contract with the council, and the city’s 2022 report states that no new whole farm plans were approved West of Hudson that year [IC]. The council’s board composition and the watershed towns’ objections were not read.
San Luis Valley Subdistrict 1 (Colorado). Irrigators on about 160,000 irrigated acres have paid a fee on their net groundwater pumping since 2011, rising from US$45 to US$150 an acre-foot by 2017, and part of the income pays for fallowing. Farmers in the fee district pumped about 32% less a year than comparable farmers outside it (Smith et al. 2017) [IC]. Most of the aquifer storage gained was lost in the 2018 drought (Allen and Smith 2023), storage in 2023 was 1.21 million acre-feet below 2000 (Smith and Andersson 2025), and the aquifer reached a record low in August 2026; a plan to raise the fee from US$150 to US$500 an acre-foot went to water court that year, with groundwater-only producers arguing that it puts the burden on them (Inside Climate News 2026) [IC].
California’s 1991 Drought Water Bank. The state bought over 820,000 acre-feet, mainly from Delta farmers, and sold almost 390,000 to 12 agencies, about half of the allocated water going to the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California; the state estimated that about 150,000 acres would be taken out of production (Legislative Analyst’s Office 1991; Lund et al. 1992) [IC]. It is in the register as a tradeable-right counterpoint.
In the register
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Tenure | Beyond-market markers | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | United States | Sangre de Cristo, Rio Grande | commons | communal | B1, B2 | [IC] |
| California Drought Water Bank of 1991 | United States | Sierra Nevada and southern Cascades (Sacramento-San Joaquin system) | state-program | mixed | [IC] | |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Mexico | Sierra Juárez | community-forestry | communal | B1, B2, B4, B6, B8 | [IC] |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Mexico | Sierra Madre and others | state-program | communal | B4, B8 | [IC] |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | United States | Catskills | negotiated-payments | private | B7, B8 | [IC] |
| San Luis Valley Groundwater Subdistrict 1 | United States | Southern Rocky Mountains (San Juan and Sangre de Cristo ranges) | commons | mixed | B2, B4 | [IC] |
| Case | Coordination | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | T+I | communal | Members' labor and fees | B1, B2 | Centuries |
| California Drought Water Bank of 1991 | I+M | mixed | The Department of Water Resources bought water from 348 sellers, mostly Delta farmers, and sold it to 12 agencies; eligible buyers were urban areas receiving under 75% of normal supply and farm areas facing permanent production losses | One-year emergency program in 1991; later drought banks not checked | |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | T+I; M subordinate | communal | Timber, PSAH, ecotourism into assembly | B1, B2, B4, B6, B8 | Community forestry 40+ yrs; PES effect faded |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | I; T subordinate | communal | Federal water fees: MXN 300-400/ha/yr to assemblies | B4, B8 | Program continues |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | I+M; E subordinate | private | New York City pays cost-share for farm best management practices through the farmer-led Watershed Agricultural Council | B7, B8 | Whole Farm Program from 1992; Memorandum of Agreement 1997; Revised 2017 Filtration Avoidance Determination issued December 2022 |
| San Luis Valley Groundwater Subdistrict 1 | I+M; T subordinate | mixed | Irrigators on about 160,000 irrigated acres pay a fee per net acre-foot pumped, with credit for surface water put toward aquifer recharge (USD 45 in 2011, USD 75 in 2012, USD 90 in 2015, USD 150 since 2017); part of the income funds local fallowing, alongside federal CREP funds from 2016 | B2, B4 | Fee in force since 2011 and raised four times; five more subdistricts formed in the valley from 2016 to 2019; USD 500 fee before water court in 2026, with an appeal likely |
| Case | Water outcome | Water evidence | Community outcome | Community evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | About 60% of diverted water returns to the river as surface flow, 33% as shallow groundwater and 7% is lost to evapotranspiration; seepage recharges the aquifer at about 1,169 mm a year; return flow delays runoff | E3 | Crop production and common livestock pasturing have declined (Cox 2014) | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| California Drought Water Bank of 1991 | Over 820,000 acre-feet bought and almost 390,000 sold; the rest went to Delta instream flows and carryover storage for 1992 (Lund et al. 1992) | E5 | About 150,000 acres of farmland taken out of production in selling areas (Department of Water Resources estimate reported by the Legislative Analyst's Office, 1991); third-party effects not assessed in the sources read | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Not measured (forest cover) | E2 | Not measured here | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Mexico's Payments for Hydrological Services | Not measured (forest only) | E2 | Small poverty effects | E2 | [IC] | yes |
| New York City Watershed Agreement and the Catskills | Filtration avoidance maintained [TBV] | E2 | The 2017 FAD requires a USD 11 million contract with the Watershed Agricultural Council; no new West-of-Hudson whole farm plans were approved in 2022 | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| San Luis Valley Groundwater Subdistrict 1 | Pumping about 30% below a counterfactual from comparable farms (32% in Smith et al. 2017; 30.4% by difference-in-differences; nominal reduction closer to 10%); aquifer storage fell to a low in 2013, most gains were lost in the 2018 drought, and storage stood 1.21 million acre-feet below 2000 in 2023, against an estimated 2.38 million without the subdistrict's measures (Allen and Smith 2023; Smith and Andersson 2025); record low in August 2026 | E2 | Farm values fell after the subdistrict formed in 2006, recovered 86% of that loss after the fee began, and remain about 6% below pre-2006 values (Smith and Andersson 2025); groundwater-only producers, about 14% of parcels, argue the USD 500 fee puts the burden on them | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Case | Capture or harm | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acequias of Northern New Mexico | Individual quantification of water rights in the Abeyta adjudication; land subdivision by newcomers; urban growth; loss of common pastures; water markets rated a moderate pressure | Centuries | [IC] |
| Community Forestry in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca | Parcels 10+ yrs post-payment more deforested | Community forestry 40+ yrs; PES effect faded | [IC] |
The tabs show the region’s cases with their lineage and tenure, their value flows and governance, their outcomes and evidence levels, the failures and captures, and the cases awaiting enrichment. Each case page gives the full coding. The codes are explained on the case register page.
Related
- Community Catchment Case Register
- Mountain Water Commons: Community-Held Catchments Beyond Asset-Based Development
Provenance
Created on 9 November 2026 by moving the “Mexico and North America” subsection of the brief’s “Cases by mountain system” section to this page without change to its wording. Links to case pages were added to the case names, and the opening sentence and the embedded base mexico-and-north-america.base were added. The base lists every case page whose mountain_region is “Mexico and North America”. Revised the same day: a comparison of community and protected forests attributed to a 2018 land-cover study was replaced with that study’s own findings (Navarro Cerrillo et al. 2019), because its abstract does not make the comparison. Enriched on 9 November 2026: the paragraph on cases first coded [TBV] was rewritten from the enrichment pass, with each case linked to its page and graded as its page now is. Updated the same day with the grade changes from the second enrichment run. Updated on 10 November 2026 with cases added from the resource-backed currencies research run, which has no brief on the wiki. Revised on 10 November 2026: the acequias paragraph was corrected against Cox and Ross (2011) and Cox (2014).