Alpine commons such as Törbel and the Regole d’Ampezzo have held forests, pastures and water under their own statutes for centuries, with membership rules that also exclude newcomers.
Right of reply
This page describes communities, organizations and programs only through their published records and statements. None has yet been invited to comment. Responses and corrections will be recorded on the case pages with their date. [MS] marks a claim that rests on the account of the party the claim is about.
The cases
Törbel (Switzerland). Village statutes from 1483 limit cows on the common alp to the number each household can winter, and the commune governs forest and irrigation (Netting 1981; Ostrom 1990) [IC]. No water measurement.
The Valais bisses. Reynard (2002) reports a network that shrank from more than 1,400 km to about 600 km, with about 52.5% of working channels run by farmer corporations and 42.5% by municipalities, and weaker corporations handing their channels to public bodies [IC].
The Regole d’Ampezzo. The Regole hold more than 16,000 hectares as inalienable collective property for about 1,000 families and have run the regional natural park since 1990; membership passes through male descendants of old families, and newcomers have none, by the Regole’s own account [MS]. After the Marmolada collapse of 2022, the Regole returned to the state the management of the peaks, crags, trails and streams they had leased, and kept their forest and pasture (regional press) [MS].
Tyrol’s Agrargemeinschaften. Austria’s Constitutional Court ruled in 2008 that the value of former municipal land beyond the members’ use rights belongs to the municipality, which set agrarian commons against municipalities [IC]. A 2010 law amendment and rulings of 2010 and 2011 confirmed the municipalities’ claim, and a 2014 amendment placed a municipal administrator inside these communities, which they challenged in court [IC].
Eigg and Slovakia’s 2010 to 2012 program. Eigg’s community trust, which bought the island in 1997, runs a grid that draws 95% of energy use from hydro, wind and solar, and the population has risen from 65 to 109; a peer-reviewed study and the European Commission confirm the system’s design and funding, including the residents’ own cap of 5 kW per household [IC]. Slovakia’s program ended with its funding, its auditor found duplicate invoices, and one of its dams breached fatally in 2021 [IC].
In the register
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Tenure | Beyond-market markers | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Austria | Eastern Alps | commons | contested | B1 | [IC] |
| Bisses of the Valais | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | commons | communal | B1, B2 | [IC] |
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | United Kingdom | Island uplands | community-land-trust | trust | B1, B2, B6 | [IC] |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Italy | Dolomites | commons | communal | B1, B2, B4, B8 | [MS] |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Slovakia | Carpathians | state-program | state | [IC] | |
| Törbel Commons | Switzerland | Pennine Alps | commons | communal | B1, B2 | [IC] |
| Case | Coordination | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | T+I | contested | Rents disputed | B1 | Ongoing |
| Bisses of the Valais | T+I; M (tourism) | communal | Members, commune, tourism | B1, B2 | Irrigation since at least the 13th century; about 52.5% of channels in use run by consortages, 42.5% by municipalities |
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | E+M | trust | Residents pay for power from a GBP 1.6 million community grid funded by the trust, residents' fees, lottery, regional and EU grants; the trust owns the island, bought for GBP 1.5 million in 1997 | B1, B2, B6 | Community ownership since 1997; 24-hour renewable power from 1 February 2008 |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | T+I | communal | Timber, rents and an annual regional contribution fund the Regole and the park (budget about €2 million a year); no revenue distributed to members beyond household rights to timber, pasture and firewood | B1, B2, B4, B8 | Medieval origins; natural park entrusted to the Regole in 1990; after the 2022 Marmolada collapse the assembly returned management of leased peaks, crags, trails and streams to the State Demanio, keeping its 16,000 ha of forest and pasture |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | I | state | State pays municipalities for labor | Ended with funding | |
| Törbel Commons | T+I | communal | Members | B1, B2 | 500+ yrs |
| Case | Water outcome | Water evidence | Community outcome | Community evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | Not measured | E5 | Not measured | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Bisses of the Valais | Not measured | E5 | Network shrank from over 1,400 km in the late 19th century to about 600 km; more than half the channels abandoned in the 20th century | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Isle of Eigg Buyout and Hydro | Not measured | E5 | Population rose from 65 at the buyout to 109; renewables (184 kW of hydro, wind and solar) supply 95% of energy use | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Regole d'Ampezzo | Not measured | E5 | More than 16,000 ha and about 1,000 families; Regolieri are about 40% of Cortina's residents | E5 | [MS] | no |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | No published hydrological evaluation; one gully monitoring study (VTEI 2022) | E5 | Temporary jobs; auditor found duplicate invoices (€32,181) in 46 municipalities | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Törbel Commons | Not measured | E5 | Population stable for centuries | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Case | Capture or harm | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agrargemeinschaften of Tyrol | The 2008 ruling assigned the substance value of former municipal land to municipalities; a 2010 law amendment and later rulings confirmed it, and a 2014 amendment placed a municipal administrator inside these agrarian communities, which challenged it in court | Ongoing | [IC] |
| Slovakia's Landscape Revitalization Program | Ended with funding; structures damaged or destroyed; a 6 m dam at Rudno nad Hronom breached in 2021 with one death | Ended with funding | [IC] |
The tabs show the region’s cases with their lineage and tenure, their value flows and governance, their outcomes and evidence levels, the failures and captures, and the cases awaiting enrichment. Each case page gives the full coding. The codes are explained on the case register page.
Related
- Community Catchment Case Register
- Mountain Water Commons: Community-Held Catchments Beyond Asset-Based Development
Provenance
Created on 9 November 2026 by moving the “The Alps and Europe elsewhere” subsection of the brief’s “Cases by mountain system” section to this page without change to its wording. Links to case pages were added to the case names, and the opening sentence and the embedded base alps-and-europe.base were added. The base lists every case page whose mountain_region is “Alps and Europe”. Enriched on 9 November 2026: the paragraph on cases first coded [TBV] was rewritten from the enrichment pass, with each case linked to its page and graded as its page now is. Updated the same day with the grade changes from the second enrichment run.