Terrace and water-temple systems in Bali, the Cordillera and Yunnan have coordinated mountain water for centuries and are now losing land and water to tourism and labor to out-migration.
Right of reply
This page describes communities, organizations and programs only through their published records and statements. None has yet been invited to comment. Responses and corrections will be recorded on the case pages with their date. [MS] marks a claim that rests on the account of the party the claim is about.
The cases
Subak, Bali (Indonesia). Farmer associations coordinate irrigation and cropping through a hierarchy of water temples. Lansing modeled how this coordination manages pests and water across a watershed (Lansing and Kremer 1993; Lansing 2007). UNESCO inscribed the Cultural Landscape of Bali Province in 2012, covering 20 subaks over about 2,400 hectares (SEI 2015). A Transnational Institute brief (2018) reports Bali lost nearly 25% of its agricultural land in 25 years and that tourism receives preferential water [IC]. Farmers cite ritual costs, land taxes and water shortage [IC].
The Ifugao terraces. UNESCO removed them from the List of World Heritage in Danger in 2012, after listing abandonment tied to a neglected irrigation system and out-migration among the threats, and noted that sustained funding remains needed [IC].
The Hani terraces. In the main scenic area, the county and the Yunnan Shibo Tourism Holding Group said in 2014 that 10% of pre-tax ticket revenue went to the county for villagers, while villagers and a village committee said they had received nothing; this stays [TBV]. At Azheke, a village company set up in 2019 with a Sun Yat-sen University team pays 70% of revenue to villagers, with shares tied to keeping traditional houses and farming the terraces, and had paid CNY 3.4525 million in 12 dividend rounds (CNY 53,116 per household) by October 2025 [IC]. Cultivated land in Yuanyang County fell by 84.16 km² between 2010 and 2017, by one unreviewed thesis.
Japan’s iriai. About 1.85 million hectares of iriai forest existed when the 1966 modernization law was enacted; 0.89 million hectares have since been reorganized into individual or association ownership, and an owners’ survey confirmed only 0.45 million hectares as remaining iriai (Forestry Agency 2025) [IC]. No source documented a water role for the surviving iriai.
In the register
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Tenure | Beyond-market markers | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Ailao Mountains | customary | mixed | B2 | [TBV] |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Philippines | Cordillera | customary | customary | B1, B2 | [IC] |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Japan | Central uplands | commons | communal | B1, B2 | [IC] |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Indonesia | Batur, Batukaru volcanoes | customary | mixed | B1, B2 | [IC] |
| Case | Coordination | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hani Rice Terraces | T+I | mixed | Main scenic area: Yunnan Shibo pays 10% of pre-tax ticket revenue to the county for villagers, who report receiving nothing (2014). Azheke: village company splits revenue 30% operations, 70% villagers; 12 dividend rounds totaling CNY 3.4525 million (CNY 53,116 per household) by October 2025 | B2 | Centuries |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | T | customary | None | B1, B2 | On the List of World Heritage in Danger until 2012, when the Committee removed them and noted that sustained funding remains needed |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | T | communal | None | B1, B2 | Reorganization peaked in FY1974 and has stayed low; surviving iriai groups still decide by unanimity |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | T; I and M rising | mixed | Members; tourism revenue rarely to farmers | B1, B2 | Centuries, under strain |
| Case | Water outcome | Water evidence | Community outcome | Community evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hani Rice Terraces | Not measured | E5 | Cultivated land in Yuanyang County fell by 84.16 km² between 2010 and 2017; some terraces abandoned for lack of labor | E5 | [TBV] | yes |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Not measured | E5 | Terraces abandoned as the irrigation system was neglected and people left | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Not measured | E5 | About 1.85 million ha of iriai forest at the 1966 law; 0.89 million ha since reorganized; 0.45 million ha confirmed as remaining iriai in an owners' survey | E2 | [IC] | yes |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Not measured | E4 | ~25% of farmland lost in 25 yrs | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Case | Capture or harm | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hani Rice Terraces | Main-area ticket revenue sharing contested; terrace abandonment; a few Azheke households rejected the dividend rule | Centuries | [TBV] |
| Ifugao Rice Terraces | Out-migration | On the List of World Heritage in Danger until 2012, when the Committee removed them and noted that sustained funding remains needed | [IC] |
| Iriai Commons of Japan | Iriai rights replaced by individual or association ownership under the 1966 modernization law; many receiving forest associations now dissolving | Reorganization peaked in FY1974 and has stayed low; surviving iriai groups still decide by unanimity | [IC] |
| Subak and Water Temples of Bali | Tourism water priority, land conversion | Centuries, under strain | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Sources | Last checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hani Rice Terraces | China | Yuan 2023; UNESCO 2013; China Daily 2014; Honghe Prefecture n.d.; People's Forum 2024; Shangguan News 2025 | 2026-11-09 |
The tabs show the region’s cases with their lineage and tenure, their value flows and governance, their outcomes and evidence levels, the failures and captures, and the cases awaiting enrichment. Each case page gives the full coding. The codes are explained on the case register page.
Related
- Community Catchment Case Register
- Mountain Water Commons: Community-Held Catchments Beyond Asset-Based Development
Provenance
Created on 9 November 2026 by moving the “Southeast and East Asia” subsection of the brief’s “Cases by mountain system” section to this page without change to its wording. Links to case pages were added to the case names, and the opening sentence and the embedded base southeast-and-east-asia.base were added. The base lists every case page whose mountain_region is “Southeast and East Asia”. Enriched on 9 November 2026: the paragraph on cases first coded [TBV] was rewritten from the enrichment pass, with each case linked to its page and graded as its page now is. Revised the same day after the second enrichment run: Azheke was added to the Hani case as a named sub-entry. Updated the same day with the grade changes from the second enrichment run.