Springshed programs in the Indian Himalaya name the mountain’s recharge function most precisely of any tradition found, and most are led by the state or NGOs.
Right of reply
This page describes communities, organizations and programs only through their published records and statements. None has yet been invited to comment. Responses and corrections will be recorded on the case pages with their date. [MS] marks a claim that rests on the account of the party the claim is about.
The cases
Dhara Vikas, Sikkim (India). The Rural Management and Development Department launched springshed development under India’s rural employment guarantee scheme (MGNREGA). Tambe et al. (2012), citing their own 2009 survey, recorded that 80% of rural households in Sikkim depend on spring water and that lean-season discharge was perceived to have fallen by about half in drought-prone areas. In five treated springs, lean-season discharge rose from 4.4 to 14.4 liters per minute [IC]. A 2026 study recorded Chipchey Dhara rising from 12 to 35 liters per minute and Gaddi Khola from 6 to 40 between 2020 and 2024 [IC]. A Manipur policy brief on applying the Dhara Vikas model reported discharge declines in the villages it studied. All of these are before-after designs without controls (E3).
Ladakh’s ice reservoirs. Nüsser and colleagues (2019) inventoried 14 structures and measured about 1,010 to 3,220 m³ of ice at Nang in a poor winter; only five catchments could irrigate all fields even in good years, maintenance suffered from labor shortages, and the ice stupa caused disputes over water sharing [IC].
Nepal’s community forest user groups. Oldekop and colleagues (2019) linked community forest management by more than 18,000 groups to a 37% relative fall in deforestation and a 4.3% relative fall in poverty; water was not measured [IC].
ACWADAM and People’s Science Institute springsheds. The implementers’ own assessments report lean-season discharge gains at named springs in Nagaland and Uttarakhand, from before-after comparisons without controls, and one atlas attributes a gain at one spring to higher rainfall [MS]. No independent evaluation was found. A 2025 survey of 10,063 Uttarakhand springs found 76% with falling discharge.
The Paro payment (Bhutan). In the Namey Nichu agreement, signed on 29 October 2015 for 2016 to 2020, hotels (five by SNV’s count, four by IUCN’s) and the Satsham Water Association pay a watershed group of 29 village households for verified care of two streams and their springs, with payment due only after a verification team confirms the work (World Bank 2019; IUCN 2019) [IC]. Consultations on a second phase raised concerns about how water is allocated to the hotels. No water measurement was found.
The Yakpugang payment (Bhutan). Since a contract of December 2010, Mongar municipality has paid the Yakpugang community forest group to protect the springs that supply the town, at Nu 52,000 a year in the first three-year contract; the contract was renewed, though renewal and payment ran late, and a 2021 study reports payments of Nu 228,200 a year from town users and the regional hospital [IC].
In the register
| Case | Country | Mountain system | Lineage | Tenure | Beyond-market markers | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | India | Western/Central Himalaya | ngo-program | communal | B2 | [MS] |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | India | Trans-Himalaya | practitioner-innovation | communal | B2 | [IC] |
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Nepal | Central Himalaya | community-forestry | state | B2, B4, B8 | [IC] |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | India | Eastern Himalaya | state-program | mixed | [IC] | |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | negotiated-payments | mixed | B3, B4, B7 | [IC] |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Bhutan | Eastern Himalaya | negotiated-payments | mixed | B3, B4, B7 | [IC] |
| Case | Coordination | Tenure | Value flow | Beyond-market markers | Persistence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | E+I | communal | Donors, state | B2 | Ongoing |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | E+T | communal | Government agencies, the Watershed Development Programme, NGOs, Indian Army goodwill schemes and crowdfunding; INR 300,000 to 1,000,000 per structure | B2 | Built over about 30 years; performance varies by site and year |
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | T+I | state | Timber and fees to group fund | B2, B4, B8 | 30 yrs |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | I; T subordinate | mixed | MGNREGA wages | 15+ yrs | |
| Paro Watershed Payment | I+M; T subordinate | mixed | Five hotels and the Satsham Water Association pay the Namey Nichu Watershed Management Group (29 households) Nu 142,000, only after the PES Verification Team confirms the agreed activities; the community forest group manages the money | B3, B4, B7 | First agreement ran 2016 to 2020; second phase under consultation from December 2018 |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | I+M; T subordinate | mixed | Mongar municipality pays the Yakpugang Community Forest Management Group (113 members) Nu 52,000 a year in the first three-year contract; Norten (2021) gives Nu 178,200 a year from town users and Nu 50,000 from Mongar Regional Referral Hospital | B3, B4, B7 | Contract renewed after the first three-year period |
| Case | Water outcome | Water evidence | Community outcome | Community evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ACWADAM and People's Science Institute Springsheds | Implementers report lean-season discharge gains at named springs (for example 40 to 60% at Alohsa, Nagaland, 2021; 1.76 to 2.6 L/min at one Uttarakhand spring); before-after designs without controls, and one atlas attributes a 16% rise to higher rainfall | E3 | More than 45 women trained as para-workers for discharge and water-quality measurement (PSI 2021-22) | E5 | [MS] | no |
| Artificial Glaciers and Ice Stupas of Ladakh | 14 ice reservoirs inventoried; Nang stored about 1,010 to 3,220 m³ of ice in 2014/15; only five catchments could irrigate all fields in optimal years | E4 | Smallholders report better spring yields and more frequent irrigation; maintenance limited by labor shortages | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Not measured | E4 | More than 18,000 user groups; community forest management linked to a 37% relative reduction in deforestation and a 4.3% relative reduction in poverty | E2 | [IC] | yes |
| Dhara Vikas Springsheds, Sikkim | Lean discharge 4.4 to 14.4 L/min (5 springs); 12 to 35 and 6 to 40 L/min 2020-24 | E3 | Not measured | E5 | [IC] | partial |
| Paro Watershed Payment | Not measured; obligations are activity-based | E5 | Payment conditional on four verified activities; spent on community investments | E5 | [IC] | yes |
| Yakpugang Watershed Payment | Not measured; land users report year-round water and better maize harvests | E5 | Yakpugang residents more aware of the payment than town dwellers, about 20% of whom knew of it; renewal and payment were late in the first contract period | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Case | Capture or harm | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Community Forest User Groups of Nepal | Elite capture reported | 30 yrs | [IC] |
The tabs show the region’s cases with their lineage and tenure, their value flows and governance, their outcomes and evidence levels, the failures and captures, and the cases awaiting enrichment. Each case page gives the full coding. The codes are explained on the case register page.
Related
- Community Catchment Case Register
- Mountain Water Commons: Community-Held Catchments Beyond Asset-Based Development
Provenance
Created on 9 November 2026 by moving the “Himalaya” subsection of the brief’s “Cases by mountain system” section to this page without change to its wording. Links to case pages were added to the case names, and the opening sentence and the embedded base himalaya.base were added. The base lists every case page whose mountain_region is “Himalaya”. Enriched on 9 November 2026: the paragraph on cases first coded [TBV] was rewritten from the enrichment pass, with each case linked to its page and graded as its page now is. Revised the same day after the second enrichment run: the Paro case was rewritten as the Namey Nichu agreement, and Yakpugang was added as its own case. Updated the same day with the grade changes from the second enrichment run.