Transitions research explains well how protection for young initiatives is made and argued for; its evidence that protection leads to lasting survival or wider change comes mostly from single studies of initiatives that survived, and the largest comparative studies find that resources, context and the terms of exit matter as much as the shelter itself.
Overview
New practices and organisations often fail early because they meet the full weight of the existing system before they’re ready: its prices, rules, measures and expectations. Transitions research studies long changes in how societies meet needs such as energy, food and transport. It calls the protected conditions in which something new can develop a niche, or a protective space, and since 1998 it has built a detailed account of how such spaces are made, what happens inside them and how they end.
The central model comes from Adrian Smith and Rob Raven (2012). Shielding holds back the harshest pressures. Nurturing helps the initiative learn, build networks and form shared expectations. Empowerment prepares it to survive outside, either by becoming competitive on existing terms or by changing those terms [IC]. Grassroots innovation research applies these ideas to community groups, co-operatives and movements, and finds that they fit only in part [IC].
Most studies follow one initiative, usually one that lasted, and several were written by the people who ran the work. Two bodies of work compare many cases. A survey of 276 Transition initiatives in 23 countries, active and inactive, found that less successful groups tended to underestimate context and material resources [IC]. A ten-year matched comparison of 371 firms from five German business incubators found no site where incubated firms survived longer, and three where they survived less well [IC].
For a bioregional forum or BioHub, the result is modest and usable. Protect openly, and write the terms down. Tend the network as carefully as the budget. Monitor in ways that help the group learn. Agree in advance when and how exposure begins. The research gives no reason to think protection must be hidden to work.
Right of reply. This brief describes the researchers, centres, initiatives and programmes in it only through their published records and statements. None has been invited to comment. Responses will be recorded here with their date. In this brief,
[MS]marks the account of the party a claim is about, Charles Eisenstein’s essay, and the wiki’s and the W2DF’s own documents.
The distinctions
- Niche, regime and landscape. In the multi-level perspective, a regime is the settled set of rules, technologies, practices and expectations in a sector; a niche is a space where something different can be tried; the landscape is the wider context (population, ideas, the economy at large) that neither controls (Geels 2002) [IC]. This brief uses “landscape” only in that technical sense. Lawhon and Murphy (2012) argue that the field treats the regime as too singular and too detached from place and power [IC].
- Passive and active shielding. Smith and Raven separate spaces that existed before anyone set out to protect an innovation (off-grid areas, general research funding, green consumers) from spaces advocates create on purpose (a subsidy, a pilot permission, a solar co-operative) [IC].
- Fit-and-conform and stretch-and-transform. The first makes an innovation competitive in an unchanged selection environment. The second changes that environment in the innovation’s favour (Smith and Raven 2012) [IC].
- Technological and grassroots niches. The founding work studies technologies and firms. Grassroots innovation research (Seyfang and Smith 2007 and after) studies community initiatives run on voluntary work and grants [IC]. Each finding below names its body of work.
- Protection, incubation and experimentation. Protection is any arrangement that lowers selection pressure on a young initiative. Business incubation houses and advises young firms for a period. A transition experiment is a bounded, practice-based trial meant to feed wider change. A living lab is a user-centred testing arrangement in a real setting. A transformative space is a convened setting where people try new social-ecological arrangements (Pereira and others 2018). A pilot programme is a time-limited trial of a policy or service. Their evidence is kept separate below.
- Outcomes and how they’re known. An initiative can survive without spreading, and spread without changing the regime; the case table records which outcome each study measured, and whether it was measured with a stated design, reconstructed from documents, or stated by the initiative or its funder.
- The essay’s claim and the research’s claim. Eisenstein’s essay makes an ontological claim: some phenomena are not yet settled, and sceptical exposure changes them [MS]. Transitions research makes a social and economic claim: young initiatives are fragile under selection pressure. The Ward 2 Development Forum (W2DF) has adopted the second for its young initiatives [MS]. This brief tests neither the essay’s claim nor the network’s Major Evolutionary Transitions frame, which is Michael Haupt’s position [MS].
The field: from strategic niche management to protective space
Strategic niche management (1998). Kemp, Schot and Hoogma (1998) proposed that governments and firms could create technological niches on purpose, where users, producers and regulators learn together, as a route to regime shifts toward sustainability [IC]. Later reviews read these niches as temporary, with protection meant to fall away as the technology matures [IC on the later reading; the 1998 text wasn’t reread].
The multi-level perspective (2002 to 2007). Geels (2002) built the multi-level perspective on the shift from sailing ships to steamships: niche innovations break through when landscape pressure loosens a regime [IC]. Geels and Schot (2007) set out several pathways by which this can happen [TBV on detail].
Ten years of findings (2008). Schot and Geels (2008) named three processes inside a niche (shaping expectations, building networks, learning) and concluded that they must be read together with processes outside it [IC]. These are the nurturing codes N1 to N3 in the case table.
Protective space (2012). Smith and Raven (2012) named shielding, nurturing and empowerment, called empowerment the least developed, and argued that protection is political: advocates must tell persuasive stories to win and keep it [IC]. They named its risks. Protected industries can be captured by those who gain from the rents; governments find it hard to withdraw protection from infant industries that aren’t improving; and there’s a risk of protective space “becoming an institution that shields poor innovation” (Smith and Raven, 2011 working-paper version) [IC]. The glossary entry on infant-industry protection records the older economic form of the argument.
Testing the model on cases (2013 to 2016). Verhees, Raven, Veraart, Smith and Kern (2013) traced Dutch solar photovoltaics (PV) from the 1970s to 2012 through five protected spaces, including research programmes, off-grid uses and local solar co-operatives, asking how it survived very harsh policy periods [IC]. Raven, Kern, Verhees and Smith (2016) compared six low-carbon cases (solar PV, offshore wind and carbon capture in the United Kingdom and the Netherlands), observing that “few studies pause to consider how and by whom” protective space is made (Raven and others 2016). Their propositions on this socio-political work held, with finer distinctions needed [IC]. Secondary summaries say advocates used passive spaces before building active ones, and mostly chose fit-and-conform [TBV].
Transition management and Three Horizons. Loorbach (2010) set out transition management, a cycle of transition arenas, agendas, experiments and reflexive evaluation drawn from the Dutch national energy transition programme [IC]. Sharpe and colleagues (2016) describe Three Horizons, a facilitation practice that holds three patterns together in the present: the dominant pattern in decline (the first horizon), the emerging pattern (the third) and the contested space of transition between them (the second). They state that the paper draws on their own facilitation [IC]. Sharpe (2013) calls emerging practices pockets of the future in the present [IC]. It’s the one framework in this field that invites a reading against the network’s frame, since it holds the declining and the emerging together; that reading is the wiki’s inference.
Forms of protection. Protection takes eight forms in the coding frame: financial (P1), regulatory (P2), market (P3: a sympathetic buyer), spatial (P4: a place beyond the regime’s reach), temporal (P5: a fixed period before exposure), social (P6: a supportive network), cognitive (P7: a shared story) and informational (P8: a low profile). Financial and regulatory protection dominate the technology cases; social and cognitive protection dominate the grassroots cases. No study here treats a low profile as a designed tool; it appears as a passive condition of early niches [inference from the cases]. For civil-society initiatives, the grassroots studies point to social and cognitive protection, and to intermediaries, as the forms they can most often provide for themselves [IC].
Grassroots and civil-society niches
Seyfang and Smith (2007) argued that community-led grassroots innovations differ from market niches. They arise from social need and ideology, rely on voluntary work and grants, and seek benefits that markets don’t price. The authors set out a research and policy agenda for them [IC].
Seyfang and Haxeltine (2012) applied strategic niche management to the UK Transition Towns movement. They found that the movement had built a working niche of many local projects, with “significant weaknesses in the niche processes” (Seyfang and Haxeltine 2012), including the difficulty of passing learning from one project to another. They concluded that the framework needed adapting for civil-society niches [IC].
Hargreaves, Hielscher, Seyfang and Smith (2013) studied UK community energy, starting from the observation that such groups struggle “in simply surviving” (Hargreaves and others 2013). They examined how intermediary organisations collect and pass on lessons. Intermediaries helped consolidate the niche. The knowledge most groups needed was local and hard to transfer through toolkits [IC].
Feola and Nunes (2014) surveyed 276 Transition initiatives in 23 countries, active and inactive, which makes it a rare study that includes ones that stopped. Most rated themselves successful, defining success by social connection, empowerment and environmental impact. Less successful initiatives may underestimate contextual factors and material resources. The authors also identified an incubation period in which an initiative consolidates, and linked spread to a mix of local and global learning [IC]. Success was self-reported, so the outcome is a claim gathered by survey [IC].
Smith, Fressoli, Abrol, Arond and Ely (2017) examined six grassroots innovation movements: Socially Useful Production (United Kingdom), Appropriate Technology (South America), the People’s Science Movements and the Honey Bee Network (India), the Social Technology Network (Brazil), and hackerspaces and makerspaces [IC]. Their histories show movements opening space for alternatives, and being absorbed or sidelined by more powerful actors [TBV on the outcome of each case].
No study found for this brief follows a community energy group, food co-operative or local currency after a defined protection period ended. That gap is itself a finding.
Experiments, living labs and transformative spaces
Sengers, Wieczorek and Raven (2019) systematically reviewed the literature on experiments and separated five kinds: niche, bounded socio-technical, transition, sustainability and grassroots experiments [IC]. The review maps concepts and doesn’t pool outcome data.
Pereira, Karpouzoglou, Frantzeskaki and Olsson (2018) set out the idea of transformative spaces [IC]. Pereira and fourteen co-authors (2020) drew five lessons from nine such spaces, mainly in the Global South and including Southern African work, on how they are designed, convened and opened [IC]. The authors convened or facilitated the cases, so the paper is an account of their own work. The transformation laboratory (T-lab) work of Charli-Joseph and others belongs to the same family [TBV on detail].
The run didn’t reach the urban experimentation literature (Bulkeley, Castán Broto, Evans and others) or living-lab evaluations, and found no African living-lab evaluation.
The evidence on outcomes, by design level
The brief grades each outcome claim on a five-level ladder: E1 a comparative study of many initiatives with systematic coding, or a survival or matched-comparison analysis; E2 a longitudinal study with a stated baseline, followed over years; E3 a retrospective case study by independent researchers; E4 a framework, review or model with illustrative cases; E5 an account by a practitioner, funder or the initiative itself.
E1. Two bodies of work.
- Feola and Nunes (2014): a survey of 276 Transition initiatives in 23 countries, including inactive ones, with statistical and cluster analysis [IC].
- Business incubation. Schwartz (2013) matched 371 graduates of five German incubators with 371 non-incubated firms over ten years; no site showed higher survival for incubated firms, and three showed significantly lower survival [IC]. Murillo-Rojas, Brinckmann and van Essen (2026) pooled 39 studies covering 55,219 firms and found clearer gains for innovation and growth than for survival, where effects were weak or inconsistent [IC]. Seitz, Buratti, Lehmann and Eberle (2026) pooled 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and found a positive overall effect on performance, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region [IC]. These are business firms, so they bear on community initiatives only by analogy.
E2. None found that set a baseline and followed a protected community initiative forward. Verhees and others (2013) cover four decades as a historical reconstruction from documents and interviews [IC].
E3. Dutch solar PV (Verhees and others 2013); the six-case synthesis by the same team (Raven and others 2016); UK Transition Towns (Seyfang and Haxeltine 2012); UK community energy intermediaries (Hargreaves and others 2013); six grassroots movements (Smith and others 2017); South Africa’s renewable energy community trusts (Wlokas 2015, a report).
E4. Kemp, Schot and Hoogma (1998); Geels (2002); Schot and Geels (2008); Smith and Raven (2012); Sengers and others (2019); Wieczorek (2018); Lawhon and Murphy (2012).
E5. Accounts by people who ran the work: Lynedoch, by its co-founders (Swilling and Annecke 2012); Three Horizons, from the authors’ facilitation (Sharpe and others 2016); transformative spaces the authors convened (Pereira and others 2020); Dutch transition management, which Loorbach’s institute advised (Loorbach 2010).
Outcome claims about protection rest on E3 to E5. The only E1 designs come from the Transition movement and from business incubation [IC on the pattern; inference on its meaning].
The exit
Smith and Raven (2012) say empowerment is the least developed property, and warn of capture and of protection that outlives its purpose [IC]. Raven and others (2016) treat empowerment as outward socio-political work, which depended on aligning the innovation’s story with the agendas of powerful actors [IC]. Dutch PV survived by moving between protected spaces as each was won and lost (Verhees and others 2013) [IC].
The incubator studies give the clearest numbers on what happens when protection ends:
- Schwartz (2009), 352 graduates: leaving the incubator brings an immediate fall in survival that lasts up to three years [IC].
- Schwartz (2011), 324 graduates: early growth after graduation, then no continued growth for most firms [IC].
- Schwartz (2012), 149 graduates: longer incubation and an older incubator both lower survival after graduation; he reads this as support for strict limits on incubation time [IC].
- Schwartz (2013), the matched comparison: no survival advantage after graduation, and lower survival at three of five sites [IC].
The wiki’s restoration synthesis records that the job model of South Africa’s Working for Water programme produced dependency [MS]. No study here compares protected spaces with and without a written exit rule.
The politics and the critiques
Who decides. Smith, Stirling and Berkhout (2005) argued that the direction of a transition depends on the resources and adaptive capacity of regime actors, and that steering it is political [IC]. Smith and Stirling (2010) argued that transitions and resilience research both tend to close down governance around expert framings, and called for opening it up [IC]. Raven and others (2016) found that advocates won protection by tying their technology to powerful actors’ agendas [IC].
Political ecology. Lawhon and Murphy (2012) named four limitations of transitions research and drew on political ecology to address them, with a case on genetically modified crops. In their reading the field neglects how problems are defined, who wins and loses, and the role of place [IC].
Power in the multi-level perspective. Geels (2014) replied by adding politics and power to the framework, describing how incumbents in the UK electricity sector resist low-carbon change [IC]. This answers the charge that power is missing, and leaves open the critics’ wish for a different starting point [inference].
Grassroots movements. Seyfang and Smith (2007) and Smith and others (2017) argue that for movements contesting mainstream framings of innovation, empowerment on the regime’s terms can mean losing their purpose [IC]. Smith and Raven (2012) make a related point about fit-and-conform [IC].
Both sides agree that protection is political. They differ on whether the multi-level perspective can hold that politics or needs replacing [inference].
The Global South and Africa
Wieczorek (2018) reviewed transitions studies of developing countries. Her review suggests that regimes there are often less uniform than in Europe, and that niches may need a degree of regime stability to develop [IC]. The editors of the same special issue (Hansen and others 2018) argue that the field’s frameworks need adapting to high inequality and informality [IC], and Ramos-Mejía and others (2018) describe socio-technical change among people living in poverty [IC].
South Africa
Lynedoch. Swilling and Annecke (2012) read transitions from the Global South with inequality at the centre. Their Chapter 10, “Pioneering Liveable Urbanism: Reflections on an Invisible Way”, covers Lynedoch EcoVillage and the Sustainability Institute near Stellenbosch, which they co-founded in 1999 [IC on the record; E5 on the content]. Their 2006 article describes Lynedoch as South Africa’s first socially mixed, ecologically designed intentional community [MS].
Renewable energy community trusts. South Africa’s Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme (REIPPPP) requires projects to spend on socio-economic and enterprise development and to share some ownership with local communities, usually through community trusts [IC]. Read as protection, the trusts are financial shielding (P1) created by the state and run by firms. Wlokas (2015), in a report for WWF-SA covering the 79 projects approved by May 2015, found that companies mostly planned their community duties in isolation, often through private service providers, and treated community members mainly as beneficiaries. She judged that the arrangements appear to reinforce existing power structures (Wlokas 2015) [IC as a report finding; not peer-reviewed]. The programme office reports 88,317 job years and R3.4 billion in socio-economic development spending by 2025 [MS, as cited in a 2025 New Agenda article].
Inclusive innovation at Stellenbosch. Grobbelaar, Tijssen and Dijksterhuis (2017) studied 15 university-driven inclusive innovation activities in the Western Cape and proposed a framework of innovation regimes for them [IC]; Botha, Grobbelaar and Bam (2016) proposed a framework for evaluating inclusive innovation systems [IC]. Professor Sara Grobbelaar’s group publishes on inclusive innovation and innovation platforms. The search found no published study, by the group or anyone else, of a grassroots niche or living lab in a former mission station [IC on the absence within this search].
Where the formal regime doesn’t reach
No study found addresses protection on communal or mission-station land, in informal economies, or in South African food and seed networks read as niches. The wiki’s synthesis of sixteen restoration cases in sub-Saharan Africa found that durable cases grew from existing local practice and secure local rights, with long apprenticeships before formal institutions [MS]. That describes passive, social and temporal protection that communities provided for themselves, and it’s the closest evidence available here. The run didn’t reach evidence from elsewhere in Africa on living labs, hubs and incubators.
Measuring the young
Reflexive monitoring in action. Van Mierlo and colleagues (2010), at Wageningen University and VU University Amsterdam, designed a method in which a monitor works inside a system innovation project, helping participants reflect on the system they want to change and adjust their actions as they go. It’s built for learning during the work and claims no outcome measure of its own [IC].
Developmental evaluation. Patton (2011) proposed evaluation for innovations in complex, changing settings, where the evaluator helps the work adapt and the goals may change. It differs from formative evaluation, which improves a settled model, and summative evaluation, which judges a finished one [IC].
The politics of results. Eyben, Guijt, Roche and Shutt (2015) collected practitioners’ accounts of how demands for results in international aid shape programmes, and how staff comply, adapt or resist [IC]. Their cases describe work drifting toward what can be counted [TBV on specific cases].
Motivation. Deci, Koestner and Ryan (1999) reviewed 128 experiments and found that tangible rewards tied to a task reduced people’s own wish to do it, while positive feedback tended to raise it [IC].
The wiki’s Political Economy Analysis method studies who wants what and why. The protective-space literature adds nurturing processes (expectations, networks, learning) that a monitor can track without scoring the initiative, and reflexive monitoring as a method built for that [inference]. No comparative study shows that either method harms young initiatives less than standard impact metrics; the claim rests on design reasoning and practitioner accounts (E4 to E5).
The counterpart: the research beside Eisenstein’s layers of shielding
Eisenstein’s essay of 8 February 2026 proposes ontological shielding for research into phenomena that consensus reality treats as impossible. It describes five layers, from no shielding to complete shielding, and likens the most shielded experiment to “a baby in an incubator” (Eisenstein 2026) [MS]. The mapping below is the analyst’s inference.
| Layer (Eisenstein) [MS] | Nearest research concept | Fit | What the essay adds | What the research adds |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0: no shielding; hostile observers, strict protocols | Full exposure to the regime’s selection environment | Close in structure | Exposure changes the phenomenon; a positive result signals a shift in the wider reality | Exposure tests fit; premature exposure ends an initiative by selection, with no change to the thing itself |
| 1: rigorous protocols with a deliberate flaw left for sceptics | None; nearest is fit-and-conform presentation | Weak | Strategic imperfection as a shield | Empowerment through open narratives (Raven and others 2016); no work endorses concealment |
| 2: deliberately informal, for a sympathetic public | Passive space among sympathetic users; grassroots niches | Moderate | Lower rigour as a condition for the phenomenon | Sympathetic users as passive space (Smith and Raven 2012) |
| 3: a bubble visible only to participants | Strong shielding; a low profile (P8); a closed transition arena | Moderate | The phenomenon matures only inside the bubble | Closed spaces aid learning and need planned links outward |
| 4: shielded even from the experimenter | None | None | Results travel by story and an unseen field | No term; unobserved outcomes are unknown |
The parallel societies research map called the fit “Close”. On this reading it’s close only at layer 0, moderate at layers 2 and 3, weak at layer 1 and absent at layer 4 [inference]. The essay also considers deliberately flawed or fraudulent experiments as shielding, and says sincere researchers need not use them [MS]. The W2DF has dropped hidden steering, and no recommendation here draws on those elements.
The works and the cases
Each work the brief relies on has a page in the sources register. The table below is drawn from those pages; its tabs sort by design and niche type, and show the comparative studies and the Global South evidence on their own.
| Work | Author | Year | Design | Niche type | Setting | Finding | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Regime Shifts to Sustainability Through Processes of Niche Formation: The Approach of Strategic Niche Management | René Kemp, Johan Schot and Remco Hoogma | 1998 | E4 | technological | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out strategic niche management: deliberately created, temporary niches in which users, producers and regulators learn together as a route to regime shifts. | [IC] |
| A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation | Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan | 1999 | E1 | mixed | Mainly United States; Global North | Reviews 128 experiments and finds tangible, task-linked rewards reduce intrinsic motivation, while positive feedback tends to raise it. | [IC] |
| Technological Transitions as Evolutionary Reconfiguration Processes: A Multi-Level Perspective and a Case-Study | Frank W. Geels | 2002 | E4 | technological | United Kingdom; Global North | Builds the multi-level perspective of niche, regime and landscape on the shift from sail to steam ships. | [IC] |
| The Governance of Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith, Andy Stirling and Frans Berkhout | 2005 | E4 | technological | Europe; Global North | Argues that transitions depend on regime actors' resources and adaptive capacity, and that steering them is a political act. | [IC] |
| Building Sustainable Neighbourhoods in South Africa: Learning from the Lynedoch Case | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2006 | E5 | grassroots | South Africa; peri-urban; Global South | The co-founders' account of Lynedoch EcoVillage, which they describe as South Africa's first socially mixed, ecologically designed intentional community. | [MS] |
| Typology of Sociotechnical Transition Pathways | Frank W. Geels and Johan Schot | 2007 | E4 | technological | Europe; Global North | Sets out several pathways by which niche innovations, regimes and landscape pressure interact in a transition. | [TBV] |
| Grassroots Innovations for Sustainable Development: Towards a New Research and Policy Agenda | Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2007 | E4 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Argues that community-led grassroots innovations differ from market niches in their drivers, resources and aims, and sets a research agenda for them. | [IC] |
| Strategic Niche Management and Sustainable Innovation Journeys: Theory, Findings, Research Agenda, and Policy | Johan Schot and Frank W. Geels | 2008 | E4 | technological | Europe; Global North | Reviews ten years of strategic niche management studies and concludes that niche-internal processes must be read together with processes outside the niche. | [IC] |
| Beyond Incubation: An Analysis of Firm Survival and Exit Dynamics in the Post-Graduation Period | Michael Schwartz | 2009 | E1 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 352 graduates of five German incubators and finds that leaving the incubator brings a drop in survival lasting up to three years. | [IC] |
| Transition Management for Sustainable Development: A Prescriptive, Complexity-Based Governance Framework | Derk Loorbach | 2010 | E5 | institutional | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out transition management: arenas, agendas, experiments and reflexive evaluation, drawn from the Dutch national energy transition programme. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Social-Ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith and Andy Stirling | 2010 | E4 | mixed | General | Argues that resilience and transitions research both tend to close down governance around expert framings, and calls for opening it up. | [IC] |
| Reflexive Monitoring in Action: A Guide for Monitoring System Innovation Projects | Barbara van Mierlo, Barbara Regeer, Mariette van Amstel, Marleen Arkesteijn, Volkert Beekman, Joske Bunders, Tjard de Cock Buning, Boelie Elzen, Anne-Charlotte Hoes and Cees Leeuwis | 2010 | E5 | mixed | Netherlands; Global North | A method in which a monitor works inside a system innovation project, helping participants reflect on the system they want to change while they act. | [IC] |
| Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use | Michael Quinn Patton | 2011 | E4 | mixed | General | Proposes evaluation that supports innovations in complex, changing settings, where the evaluator helps the work adapt and goals may change. | [IC] |
| Incubating an Illusion? Long-Term Incubator Firm Performance After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2011 | E1 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 324 graduates of five German incubators and finds early growth after graduation, with no continued growth for most firms. | [IC] |
| Socio-Technical Regimes and Sustainability Transitions: Insights from Political Ecology | Mary Lawhon and James T. Murphy | 2012 | E4 | mixed | General | Names four limitations of socio-technical transitions research and draws on political ecology to address them, with a case on genetically modified crops. | [IC] |
| Incubation Time, Incubator Age, and Firm Survival After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2012 | E1 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Finds, for 149 graduates of five German incubators, that longer incubation and older incubators both lower survival after graduation. | [IC] |
| Growing Grassroots Innovations: Exploring the Role of Community-Based Initiatives in Governing Sustainable Energy Transitions | Gill Seyfang and Alex Haxeltine | 2012 | E3 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Applies strategic niche management to the UK Transition Towns movement and finds a working niche with significant weaknesses in its niche processes. | [IC] |
| What Is Protective Space? Reconsidering Niches in Transitions to Sustainability | Adrian Smith and Rob Raven | 2012 | E4 | technological | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Defines protection as shielding, nurturing and empowerment, separates passive from active shielding, names two routes to empowerment, and warns of capture. | [IC] |
| Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2012 | E5 | grassroots | South Africa; Global South | Reads sustainability transitions from the Global South; Chapter 10, by the co-founders of Lynedoch EcoVillage and the Sustainability Institute, reflects on that work. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovations in Community Energy: The Role of Intermediaries in Niche Development | Tom Hargreaves, Sabine Hielscher, Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2013 | E3 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Finds that intermediary organisations help consolidate UK community energy, while the knowledge most groups need stays local and transfers poorly. | [IC] |
| A Control Group Study of Incubators' Impact to Promote Firm Survival | Michael Schwartz | 2013 | E1 | institutional | Germany; urban; Global North | Matches 371 incubator graduates with 371 similar firms over ten years and finds no incubator that raised survival; three lowered it. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope | Bill Sharpe | 2013 | E5 | mixed | United Kingdom; Global North | Presents Three Horizons, a practice that holds the declining present, the emerging future and the contested space between them together in the present. | [IC] |
| The Development of Solar PV in The Netherlands: A Case of Survival in Unfriendly Contexts | Bram Verhees, Rob Raven, Frank Veraart, Adrian Smith and Florian Kern | 2013 | E3 | technological | Netherlands; Global North | Traces Dutch solar PV from the 1970s to 2012 and finds that it survived hostile policy periods by building and moving between several protected spaces. | [IC] |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | E1 | grassroots | 23 countries; mainly Global North | Surveys 276 active and inactive Transition initiatives in 23 countries and finds less successful ones may underestimate context and material resources. | [IC] |
| Regime Resistance Against Low-Carbon Transitions: Introducing Politics and Power into the Multi-Level Perspective | Frank W. Geels | 2014 | E4 | technological | United Kingdom; Global North | Adds incumbent power and resistance to the multi-level perspective, using the UK electricity sector as the example. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? | Rosalind Eyben (ed.), Irene Guijt (ed.), Chris Roche (ed.) and Cathy Shutt (ed.) | 2015 | E5 | institutional | International; Global South | Practitioners' accounts of how demands for results and evidence in aid shape programmes, and how staff comply, adapt or resist. | [IC] |
| Estimating the Reproducibility of Psychological Science | Open Science Collaboration | 2015 | E1 | mixed | International; Global North | Replicates 100 psychology studies and finds 36 per cent of replications statistically significant, with effects about half the original size. | [IC] |
| A Review of the Local Community Development Requirements in South Africa's Renewable Energy Procurement Programme | Holle Linnea Wlokas | 2015 | E3 | institutional | South Africa; rural; Global South | Reviews the community development rules in South Africa's renewable energy procurement programme and finds communities treated mostly as beneficiaries. | [IC] |
| Towards a Framework to Guide the Evaluation of Inclusive Innovation Systems | L. Botha, Sara Grobbelaar and Wouter Bam | 2016 | E4 | institutional | South Africa; Global South | Proposes a framework for evaluating inclusive innovation systems in South Africa. | [IC] |
| Niche Construction and Empowerment Through Socio-Political Work: A Meta-Analysis of Six Low-Carbon Technology Cases | Rob Raven, Florian Kern, Bram Verhees and Adrian Smith | 2016 | E3 | technological | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Compares six low-carbon technology cases and finds that advocates won protection by aligning their story with powerful actors' agendas. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: A Pathways Practice for Transformation | Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester, Andrew Lyon and Ioan Fazey | 2016 | E5 | mixed | United Kingdom; Global North | Describes Three Horizons as a facilitation practice for transformation, from the authors' own experience of using it. | [IC] |
| University-Driven Inclusive Innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa: Towards a Research Framework of Innovation Regimes | Sara Grobbelaar, Robert Tijssen and Marjolijn Dijksterhuis | 2017 | E3 | institutional | South Africa (Western Cape); Global South | Studies 15 university-driven inclusive innovation activities in the Western Cape and proposes a framework of innovation regimes for them. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovation Movements | Adrian Smith, Mariano Fressoli, Dinesh Abrol, Elisa Arond and Adrian Ely | 2017 | E3 | grassroots | United Kingdom, South America, India, Brazil; mixed | Examines six grassroots innovation movements in Europe, South America and India, and how each made space for alternatives and met more powerful actors. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Stocktaking, New Contributions and a Research Agenda | Ulrich Elmer Hansen and others | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Editors' introduction arguing that transitions frameworks need adapting to high inequality and informality in developing countries. | [IC] |
| Designing Transformative Spaces for Sustainability in Social-Ecological Systems | Laura Pereira, Timothy Karpouzoglou, Niki Frantzeskaki and Per Olsson | 2018 | E4 | mixed | General | Proposes transformative spaces: convened collaborative settings in which people experiment with new social-ecological arrangements. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in the Developing World: Challenges of Socio-Technical Transformations Unfolding in Contexts of Poverty | Mónica Ramos-Mejía, Maria-Laura Franco-Garcia and Juan M. Jauregui-Becker | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Describes how socio-technical transformations unfold in contexts of poverty, and what that asks of transitions theory. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Major Insights and Their Implications for Research and Policy | Anna J. Wieczorek | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Reviews transitions studies of developing countries and finds regimes there less uniform, with some regime stability possibly helping niches form. | [IC] |
| Experimenting for Sustainability Transitions: A Systematic Literature Review | Frans Sengers, Anna J. Wieczorek and Rob Raven | 2019 | E4 | mixed | Global | Reviews the transitions literature on experiments and distinguishes five kinds, each with its own theory and focus. | [IC] |
| Transformative Spaces in the Making: Key Lessons from Nine Cases in the Global South | Laura Pereira and fourteen co-authors | 2020 | E5 | mixed | Southern Africa, Latin America and Asia; Global South | Synthesises nine convened transformative spaces, mainly in the Global South and including Southern African work, into five design lessons. | [IC] |
| Ontological Shielding in New-paradigm Research | Charles Eisenstein | 2026 | E5 | mixed | United States; Global North | Eisenstein's essay proposing layers of shielding for research into phenomena he holds are changed by sceptical exposure. | [MS] |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | E1 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 39 studies of 55,219 firms and finds incubation helps innovation and growth more clearly than survival. | [IC] |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | E1 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and finds a positive overall effect of incubation, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region. | [IC] |
| Work | Author | Year | Niche type | Setting | Finding | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Design E417 | ||||||
| Regime Shifts to Sustainability Through Processes of Niche Formation: The Approach of Strategic Niche Management | René Kemp, Johan Schot and Remco Hoogma | 1998 | technological | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out strategic niche management: deliberately created, temporary niches in which users, producers and regulators learn together as a route to regime shifts. | [IC] |
| Technological Transitions as Evolutionary Reconfiguration Processes: A Multi-Level Perspective and a Case-Study | Frank W. Geels | 2002 | technological | United Kingdom; Global North | Builds the multi-level perspective of niche, regime and landscape on the shift from sail to steam ships. | [IC] |
| The Governance of Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith, Andy Stirling and Frans Berkhout | 2005 | technological | Europe; Global North | Argues that transitions depend on regime actors' resources and adaptive capacity, and that steering them is a political act. | [IC] |
| Typology of Sociotechnical Transition Pathways | Frank W. Geels and Johan Schot | 2007 | technological | Europe; Global North | Sets out several pathways by which niche innovations, regimes and landscape pressure interact in a transition. | [TBV] |
| Grassroots Innovations for Sustainable Development: Towards a New Research and Policy Agenda | Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2007 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Argues that community-led grassroots innovations differ from market niches in their drivers, resources and aims, and sets a research agenda for them. | [IC] |
| Strategic Niche Management and Sustainable Innovation Journeys: Theory, Findings, Research Agenda, and Policy | Johan Schot and Frank W. Geels | 2008 | technological | Europe; Global North | Reviews ten years of strategic niche management studies and concludes that niche-internal processes must be read together with processes outside the niche. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Social-Ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith and Andy Stirling | 2010 | mixed | General | Argues that resilience and transitions research both tend to close down governance around expert framings, and calls for opening it up. | [IC] |
| Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use | Michael Quinn Patton | 2011 | mixed | General | Proposes evaluation that supports innovations in complex, changing settings, where the evaluator helps the work adapt and goals may change. | [IC] |
| Socio-Technical Regimes and Sustainability Transitions: Insights from Political Ecology | Mary Lawhon and James T. Murphy | 2012 | mixed | General | Names four limitations of socio-technical transitions research and draws on political ecology to address them, with a case on genetically modified crops. | [IC] |
| What Is Protective Space? Reconsidering Niches in Transitions to Sustainability | Adrian Smith and Rob Raven | 2012 | technological | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Defines protection as shielding, nurturing and empowerment, separates passive from active shielding, names two routes to empowerment, and warns of capture. | [IC] |
| Regime Resistance Against Low-Carbon Transitions: Introducing Politics and Power into the Multi-Level Perspective | Frank W. Geels | 2014 | technological | United Kingdom; Global North | Adds incumbent power and resistance to the multi-level perspective, using the UK electricity sector as the example. | [IC] |
| Towards a Framework to Guide the Evaluation of Inclusive Innovation Systems | L. Botha, Sara Grobbelaar and Wouter Bam | 2016 | institutional | South Africa; Global South | Proposes a framework for evaluating inclusive innovation systems in South Africa. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Stocktaking, New Contributions and a Research Agenda | Ulrich Elmer Hansen and others | 2018 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Editors' introduction arguing that transitions frameworks need adapting to high inequality and informality in developing countries. | [IC] |
| Designing Transformative Spaces for Sustainability in Social-Ecological Systems | Laura Pereira, Timothy Karpouzoglou, Niki Frantzeskaki and Per Olsson | 2018 | mixed | General | Proposes transformative spaces: convened collaborative settings in which people experiment with new social-ecological arrangements. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in the Developing World: Challenges of Socio-Technical Transformations Unfolding in Contexts of Poverty | Mónica Ramos-Mejía, Maria-Laura Franco-Garcia and Juan M. Jauregui-Becker | 2018 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Describes how socio-technical transformations unfold in contexts of poverty, and what that asks of transitions theory. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Major Insights and Their Implications for Research and Policy | Anna J. Wieczorek | 2018 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Reviews transitions studies of developing countries and finds regimes there less uniform, with some regime stability possibly helping niches form. | [IC] |
| Experimenting for Sustainability Transitions: A Systematic Literature Review | Frans Sengers, Anna J. Wieczorek and Rob Raven | 2019 | mixed | Global | Reviews the transitions literature on experiments and distinguishes five kinds, each with its own theory and focus. | [IC] |
| Design E19 | ||||||
| A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation | Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan | 1999 | mixed | Mainly United States; Global North | Reviews 128 experiments and finds tangible, task-linked rewards reduce intrinsic motivation, while positive feedback tends to raise it. | [IC] |
| Beyond Incubation: An Analysis of Firm Survival and Exit Dynamics in the Post-Graduation Period | Michael Schwartz | 2009 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 352 graduates of five German incubators and finds that leaving the incubator brings a drop in survival lasting up to three years. | [IC] |
| Incubating an Illusion? Long-Term Incubator Firm Performance After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2011 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 324 graduates of five German incubators and finds early growth after graduation, with no continued growth for most firms. | [IC] |
| Incubation Time, Incubator Age, and Firm Survival After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2012 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Finds, for 149 graduates of five German incubators, that longer incubation and older incubators both lower survival after graduation. | [IC] |
| A Control Group Study of Incubators' Impact to Promote Firm Survival | Michael Schwartz | 2013 | institutional | Germany; urban; Global North | Matches 371 incubator graduates with 371 similar firms over ten years and finds no incubator that raised survival; three lowered it. | [IC] |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | grassroots | 23 countries; mainly Global North | Surveys 276 active and inactive Transition initiatives in 23 countries and finds less successful ones may underestimate context and material resources. | [IC] |
| Estimating the Reproducibility of Psychological Science | Open Science Collaboration | 2015 | mixed | International; Global North | Replicates 100 psychology studies and finds 36 per cent of replications statistically significant, with effects about half the original size. | [IC] |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 39 studies of 55,219 firms and finds incubation helps innovation and growth more clearly than survival. | [IC] |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and finds a positive overall effect of incubation, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region. | [IC] |
| Design E59 | ||||||
| Building Sustainable Neighbourhoods in South Africa: Learning from the Lynedoch Case | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2006 | grassroots | South Africa; peri-urban; Global South | The co-founders' account of Lynedoch EcoVillage, which they describe as South Africa's first socially mixed, ecologically designed intentional community. | [MS] |
| Transition Management for Sustainable Development: A Prescriptive, Complexity-Based Governance Framework | Derk Loorbach | 2010 | institutional | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out transition management: arenas, agendas, experiments and reflexive evaluation, drawn from the Dutch national energy transition programme. | [IC] |
| Reflexive Monitoring in Action: A Guide for Monitoring System Innovation Projects | Barbara van Mierlo, Barbara Regeer, Mariette van Amstel, Marleen Arkesteijn, Volkert Beekman, Joske Bunders, Tjard de Cock Buning, Boelie Elzen, Anne-Charlotte Hoes and Cees Leeuwis | 2010 | mixed | Netherlands; Global North | A method in which a monitor works inside a system innovation project, helping participants reflect on the system they want to change while they act. | [IC] |
| Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2012 | grassroots | South Africa; Global South | Reads sustainability transitions from the Global South; Chapter 10, by the co-founders of Lynedoch EcoVillage and the Sustainability Institute, reflects on that work. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope | Bill Sharpe | 2013 | mixed | United Kingdom; Global North | Presents Three Horizons, a practice that holds the declining present, the emerging future and the contested space between them together in the present. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? | Rosalind Eyben (ed.), Irene Guijt (ed.), Chris Roche (ed.) and Cathy Shutt (ed.) | 2015 | institutional | International; Global South | Practitioners' accounts of how demands for results and evidence in aid shape programmes, and how staff comply, adapt or resist. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: A Pathways Practice for Transformation | Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester, Andrew Lyon and Ioan Fazey | 2016 | mixed | United Kingdom; Global North | Describes Three Horizons as a facilitation practice for transformation, from the authors' own experience of using it. | [IC] |
| Transformative Spaces in the Making: Key Lessons from Nine Cases in the Global South | Laura Pereira and fourteen co-authors | 2020 | mixed | Southern Africa, Latin America and Asia; Global South | Synthesises nine convened transformative spaces, mainly in the Global South and including Southern African work, into five design lessons. | [IC] |
| Ontological Shielding in New-paradigm Research | Charles Eisenstein | 2026 | mixed | United States; Global North | Eisenstein's essay proposing layers of shielding for research into phenomena he holds are changed by sceptical exposure. | [MS] |
| Design E37 | ||||||
| Growing Grassroots Innovations: Exploring the Role of Community-Based Initiatives in Governing Sustainable Energy Transitions | Gill Seyfang and Alex Haxeltine | 2012 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Applies strategic niche management to the UK Transition Towns movement and finds a working niche with significant weaknesses in its niche processes. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovations in Community Energy: The Role of Intermediaries in Niche Development | Tom Hargreaves, Sabine Hielscher, Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2013 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Finds that intermediary organisations help consolidate UK community energy, while the knowledge most groups need stays local and transfers poorly. | [IC] |
| The Development of Solar PV in The Netherlands: A Case of Survival in Unfriendly Contexts | Bram Verhees, Rob Raven, Frank Veraart, Adrian Smith and Florian Kern | 2013 | technological | Netherlands; Global North | Traces Dutch solar PV from the 1970s to 2012 and finds that it survived hostile policy periods by building and moving between several protected spaces. | [IC] |
| A Review of the Local Community Development Requirements in South Africa's Renewable Energy Procurement Programme | Holle Linnea Wlokas | 2015 | institutional | South Africa; rural; Global South | Reviews the community development rules in South Africa's renewable energy procurement programme and finds communities treated mostly as beneficiaries. | [IC] |
| Niche Construction and Empowerment Through Socio-Political Work: A Meta-Analysis of Six Low-Carbon Technology Cases | Rob Raven, Florian Kern, Bram Verhees and Adrian Smith | 2016 | technological | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Compares six low-carbon technology cases and finds that advocates won protection by aligning their story with powerful actors' agendas. | [IC] |
| University-Driven Inclusive Innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa: Towards a Research Framework of Innovation Regimes | Sara Grobbelaar, Robert Tijssen and Marjolijn Dijksterhuis | 2017 | institutional | South Africa (Western Cape); Global South | Studies 15 university-driven inclusive innovation activities in the Western Cape and proposes a framework of innovation regimes for them. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovation Movements | Adrian Smith, Mariano Fressoli, Dinesh Abrol, Elisa Arond and Adrian Ely | 2017 | grassroots | United Kingdom, South America, India, Brazil; mixed | Examines six grassroots innovation movements in Europe, South America and India, and how each made space for alternatives and met more powerful actors. | [IC] |
| Work | Author | Year | Design | Setting | Finding | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Niche type technological9 | ||||||
| Regime Shifts to Sustainability Through Processes of Niche Formation: The Approach of Strategic Niche Management | René Kemp, Johan Schot and Remco Hoogma | 1998 | E4 | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out strategic niche management: deliberately created, temporary niches in which users, producers and regulators learn together as a route to regime shifts. | [IC] |
| Technological Transitions as Evolutionary Reconfiguration Processes: A Multi-Level Perspective and a Case-Study | Frank W. Geels | 2002 | E4 | United Kingdom; Global North | Builds the multi-level perspective of niche, regime and landscape on the shift from sail to steam ships. | [IC] |
| The Governance of Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith, Andy Stirling and Frans Berkhout | 2005 | E4 | Europe; Global North | Argues that transitions depend on regime actors' resources and adaptive capacity, and that steering them is a political act. | [IC] |
| Typology of Sociotechnical Transition Pathways | Frank W. Geels and Johan Schot | 2007 | E4 | Europe; Global North | Sets out several pathways by which niche innovations, regimes and landscape pressure interact in a transition. | [TBV] |
| Strategic Niche Management and Sustainable Innovation Journeys: Theory, Findings, Research Agenda, and Policy | Johan Schot and Frank W. Geels | 2008 | E4 | Europe; Global North | Reviews ten years of strategic niche management studies and concludes that niche-internal processes must be read together with processes outside the niche. | [IC] |
| What Is Protective Space? Reconsidering Niches in Transitions to Sustainability | Adrian Smith and Rob Raven | 2012 | E4 | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Defines protection as shielding, nurturing and empowerment, separates passive from active shielding, names two routes to empowerment, and warns of capture. | [IC] |
| The Development of Solar PV in The Netherlands: A Case of Survival in Unfriendly Contexts | Bram Verhees, Rob Raven, Frank Veraart, Adrian Smith and Florian Kern | 2013 | E3 | Netherlands; Global North | Traces Dutch solar PV from the 1970s to 2012 and finds that it survived hostile policy periods by building and moving between several protected spaces. | [IC] |
| Regime Resistance Against Low-Carbon Transitions: Introducing Politics and Power into the Multi-Level Perspective | Frank W. Geels | 2014 | E4 | United Kingdom; Global North | Adds incumbent power and resistance to the multi-level perspective, using the UK electricity sector as the example. | [IC] |
| Niche Construction and Empowerment Through Socio-Political Work: A Meta-Analysis of Six Low-Carbon Technology Cases | Rob Raven, Florian Kern, Bram Verhees and Adrian Smith | 2016 | E3 | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Compares six low-carbon technology cases and finds that advocates won protection by aligning their story with powerful actors' agendas. | [IC] |
| Niche type mixed15 | ||||||
| A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation | Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan | 1999 | E1 | Mainly United States; Global North | Reviews 128 experiments and finds tangible, task-linked rewards reduce intrinsic motivation, while positive feedback tends to raise it. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Social-Ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith and Andy Stirling | 2010 | E4 | General | Argues that resilience and transitions research both tend to close down governance around expert framings, and calls for opening it up. | [IC] |
| Reflexive Monitoring in Action: A Guide for Monitoring System Innovation Projects | Barbara van Mierlo, Barbara Regeer, Mariette van Amstel, Marleen Arkesteijn, Volkert Beekman, Joske Bunders, Tjard de Cock Buning, Boelie Elzen, Anne-Charlotte Hoes and Cees Leeuwis | 2010 | E5 | Netherlands; Global North | A method in which a monitor works inside a system innovation project, helping participants reflect on the system they want to change while they act. | [IC] |
| Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use | Michael Quinn Patton | 2011 | E4 | General | Proposes evaluation that supports innovations in complex, changing settings, where the evaluator helps the work adapt and goals may change. | [IC] |
| Socio-Technical Regimes and Sustainability Transitions: Insights from Political Ecology | Mary Lawhon and James T. Murphy | 2012 | E4 | General | Names four limitations of socio-technical transitions research and draws on political ecology to address them, with a case on genetically modified crops. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope | Bill Sharpe | 2013 | E5 | United Kingdom; Global North | Presents Three Horizons, a practice that holds the declining present, the emerging future and the contested space between them together in the present. | [IC] |
| Estimating the Reproducibility of Psychological Science | Open Science Collaboration | 2015 | E1 | International; Global North | Replicates 100 psychology studies and finds 36 per cent of replications statistically significant, with effects about half the original size. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: A Pathways Practice for Transformation | Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester, Andrew Lyon and Ioan Fazey | 2016 | E5 | United Kingdom; Global North | Describes Three Horizons as a facilitation practice for transformation, from the authors' own experience of using it. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Stocktaking, New Contributions and a Research Agenda | Ulrich Elmer Hansen and others | 2018 | E4 | Developing countries; Global South | Editors' introduction arguing that transitions frameworks need adapting to high inequality and informality in developing countries. | [IC] |
| Designing Transformative Spaces for Sustainability in Social-Ecological Systems | Laura Pereira, Timothy Karpouzoglou, Niki Frantzeskaki and Per Olsson | 2018 | E4 | General | Proposes transformative spaces: convened collaborative settings in which people experiment with new social-ecological arrangements. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in the Developing World: Challenges of Socio-Technical Transformations Unfolding in Contexts of Poverty | Mónica Ramos-Mejía, Maria-Laura Franco-Garcia and Juan M. Jauregui-Becker | 2018 | E4 | Developing countries; Global South | Describes how socio-technical transformations unfold in contexts of poverty, and what that asks of transitions theory. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Major Insights and Their Implications for Research and Policy | Anna J. Wieczorek | 2018 | E4 | Developing countries; Global South | Reviews transitions studies of developing countries and finds regimes there less uniform, with some regime stability possibly helping niches form. | [IC] |
| Experimenting for Sustainability Transitions: A Systematic Literature Review | Frans Sengers, Anna J. Wieczorek and Rob Raven | 2019 | E4 | Global | Reviews the transitions literature on experiments and distinguishes five kinds, each with its own theory and focus. | [IC] |
| Transformative Spaces in the Making: Key Lessons from Nine Cases in the Global South | Laura Pereira and fourteen co-authors | 2020 | E5 | Southern Africa, Latin America and Asia; Global South | Synthesises nine convened transformative spaces, mainly in the Global South and including Southern African work, into five design lessons. | [IC] |
| Ontological Shielding in New-paradigm Research | Charles Eisenstein | 2026 | E5 | United States; Global North | Eisenstein's essay proposing layers of shielding for research into phenomena he holds are changed by sceptical exposure. | [MS] |
| Niche type grassroots7 | ||||||
| Building Sustainable Neighbourhoods in South Africa: Learning from the Lynedoch Case | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2006 | E5 | South Africa; peri-urban; Global South | The co-founders' account of Lynedoch EcoVillage, which they describe as South Africa's first socially mixed, ecologically designed intentional community. | [MS] |
| Grassroots Innovations for Sustainable Development: Towards a New Research and Policy Agenda | Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2007 | E4 | United Kingdom; Global North | Argues that community-led grassroots innovations differ from market niches in their drivers, resources and aims, and sets a research agenda for them. | [IC] |
| Growing Grassroots Innovations: Exploring the Role of Community-Based Initiatives in Governing Sustainable Energy Transitions | Gill Seyfang and Alex Haxeltine | 2012 | E3 | United Kingdom; Global North | Applies strategic niche management to the UK Transition Towns movement and finds a working niche with significant weaknesses in its niche processes. | [IC] |
| Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2012 | E5 | South Africa; Global South | Reads sustainability transitions from the Global South; Chapter 10, by the co-founders of Lynedoch EcoVillage and the Sustainability Institute, reflects on that work. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovations in Community Energy: The Role of Intermediaries in Niche Development | Tom Hargreaves, Sabine Hielscher, Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2013 | E3 | United Kingdom; Global North | Finds that intermediary organisations help consolidate UK community energy, while the knowledge most groups need stays local and transfers poorly. | [IC] |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | E1 | 23 countries; mainly Global North | Surveys 276 active and inactive Transition initiatives in 23 countries and finds less successful ones may underestimate context and material resources. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovation Movements | Adrian Smith, Mariano Fressoli, Dinesh Abrol, Elisa Arond and Adrian Ely | 2017 | E3 | United Kingdom, South America, India, Brazil; mixed | Examines six grassroots innovation movements in Europe, South America and India, and how each made space for alternatives and met more powerful actors. | [IC] |
| Niche type institutional11 | ||||||
| Beyond Incubation: An Analysis of Firm Survival and Exit Dynamics in the Post-Graduation Period | Michael Schwartz | 2009 | E1 | Germany; Global North | Follows 352 graduates of five German incubators and finds that leaving the incubator brings a drop in survival lasting up to three years. | [IC] |
| Transition Management for Sustainable Development: A Prescriptive, Complexity-Based Governance Framework | Derk Loorbach | 2010 | E5 | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out transition management: arenas, agendas, experiments and reflexive evaluation, drawn from the Dutch national energy transition programme. | [IC] |
| Incubating an Illusion? Long-Term Incubator Firm Performance After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2011 | E1 | Germany; Global North | Follows 324 graduates of five German incubators and finds early growth after graduation, with no continued growth for most firms. | [IC] |
| Incubation Time, Incubator Age, and Firm Survival After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2012 | E1 | Germany; Global North | Finds, for 149 graduates of five German incubators, that longer incubation and older incubators both lower survival after graduation. | [IC] |
| A Control Group Study of Incubators' Impact to Promote Firm Survival | Michael Schwartz | 2013 | E1 | Germany; urban; Global North | Matches 371 incubator graduates with 371 similar firms over ten years and finds no incubator that raised survival; three lowered it. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? | Rosalind Eyben (ed.), Irene Guijt (ed.), Chris Roche (ed.) and Cathy Shutt (ed.) | 2015 | E5 | International; Global South | Practitioners' accounts of how demands for results and evidence in aid shape programmes, and how staff comply, adapt or resist. | [IC] |
| A Review of the Local Community Development Requirements in South Africa's Renewable Energy Procurement Programme | Holle Linnea Wlokas | 2015 | E3 | South Africa; rural; Global South | Reviews the community development rules in South Africa's renewable energy procurement programme and finds communities treated mostly as beneficiaries. | [IC] |
| Towards a Framework to Guide the Evaluation of Inclusive Innovation Systems | L. Botha, Sara Grobbelaar and Wouter Bam | 2016 | E4 | South Africa; Global South | Proposes a framework for evaluating inclusive innovation systems in South Africa. | [IC] |
| University-Driven Inclusive Innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa: Towards a Research Framework of Innovation Regimes | Sara Grobbelaar, Robert Tijssen and Marjolijn Dijksterhuis | 2017 | E3 | South Africa (Western Cape); Global South | Studies 15 university-driven inclusive innovation activities in the Western Cape and proposes a framework of innovation regimes for them. | [IC] |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | E1 | International; mixed | Pools 39 studies of 55,219 firms and finds incubation helps innovation and growth more clearly than survival. | [IC] |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | E1 | International; mixed | Pools 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and finds a positive overall effect of incubation, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region. | [IC] |
| Work | Author | Year | Niche type | Setting | Finding | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation | Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan | 1999 | mixed | Mainly United States; Global North | Reviews 128 experiments and finds tangible, task-linked rewards reduce intrinsic motivation, while positive feedback tends to raise it. | [IC] |
| Beyond Incubation: An Analysis of Firm Survival and Exit Dynamics in the Post-Graduation Period | Michael Schwartz | 2009 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 352 graduates of five German incubators and finds that leaving the incubator brings a drop in survival lasting up to three years. | [IC] |
| Incubating an Illusion? Long-Term Incubator Firm Performance After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2011 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 324 graduates of five German incubators and finds early growth after graduation, with no continued growth for most firms. | [IC] |
| Incubation Time, Incubator Age, and Firm Survival After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2012 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Finds, for 149 graduates of five German incubators, that longer incubation and older incubators both lower survival after graduation. | [IC] |
| A Control Group Study of Incubators' Impact to Promote Firm Survival | Michael Schwartz | 2013 | institutional | Germany; urban; Global North | Matches 371 incubator graduates with 371 similar firms over ten years and finds no incubator that raised survival; three lowered it. | [IC] |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | grassroots | 23 countries; mainly Global North | Surveys 276 active and inactive Transition initiatives in 23 countries and finds less successful ones may underestimate context and material resources. | [IC] |
| Estimating the Reproducibility of Psychological Science | Open Science Collaboration | 2015 | mixed | International; Global North | Replicates 100 psychology studies and finds 36 per cent of replications statistically significant, with effects about half the original size. | [IC] |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 39 studies of 55,219 firms and finds incubation helps innovation and growth more clearly than survival. | [IC] |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and finds a positive overall effect of incubation, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region. | [IC] |
| Work | Author | Year | Design | Niche type | Setting | Finding | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Building Sustainable Neighbourhoods in South Africa: Learning from the Lynedoch Case | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2006 | E5 | grassroots | South Africa; peri-urban; Global South | The co-founders' account of Lynedoch EcoVillage, which they describe as South Africa's first socially mixed, ecologically designed intentional community. | [MS] |
| The Politics of Social-Ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith and Andy Stirling | 2010 | E4 | mixed | General | Argues that resilience and transitions research both tend to close down governance around expert framings, and calls for opening it up. | [IC] |
| Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use | Michael Quinn Patton | 2011 | E4 | mixed | General | Proposes evaluation that supports innovations in complex, changing settings, where the evaluator helps the work adapt and goals may change. | [IC] |
| Socio-Technical Regimes and Sustainability Transitions: Insights from Political Ecology | Mary Lawhon and James T. Murphy | 2012 | E4 | mixed | General | Names four limitations of socio-technical transitions research and draws on political ecology to address them, with a case on genetically modified crops. | [IC] |
| Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2012 | E5 | grassroots | South Africa; Global South | Reads sustainability transitions from the Global South; Chapter 10, by the co-founders of Lynedoch EcoVillage and the Sustainability Institute, reflects on that work. | [IC] |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | E1 | grassroots | 23 countries; mainly Global North | Surveys 276 active and inactive Transition initiatives in 23 countries and finds less successful ones may underestimate context and material resources. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? | Rosalind Eyben (ed.), Irene Guijt (ed.), Chris Roche (ed.) and Cathy Shutt (ed.) | 2015 | E5 | institutional | International; Global South | Practitioners' accounts of how demands for results and evidence in aid shape programmes, and how staff comply, adapt or resist. | [IC] |
| A Review of the Local Community Development Requirements in South Africa's Renewable Energy Procurement Programme | Holle Linnea Wlokas | 2015 | E3 | institutional | South Africa; rural; Global South | Reviews the community development rules in South Africa's renewable energy procurement programme and finds communities treated mostly as beneficiaries. | [IC] |
| Towards a Framework to Guide the Evaluation of Inclusive Innovation Systems | L. Botha, Sara Grobbelaar and Wouter Bam | 2016 | E4 | institutional | South Africa; Global South | Proposes a framework for evaluating inclusive innovation systems in South Africa. | [IC] |
| University-Driven Inclusive Innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa: Towards a Research Framework of Innovation Regimes | Sara Grobbelaar, Robert Tijssen and Marjolijn Dijksterhuis | 2017 | E3 | institutional | South Africa (Western Cape); Global South | Studies 15 university-driven inclusive innovation activities in the Western Cape and proposes a framework of innovation regimes for them. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovation Movements | Adrian Smith, Mariano Fressoli, Dinesh Abrol, Elisa Arond and Adrian Ely | 2017 | E3 | grassroots | United Kingdom, South America, India, Brazil; mixed | Examines six grassroots innovation movements in Europe, South America and India, and how each made space for alternatives and met more powerful actors. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Stocktaking, New Contributions and a Research Agenda | Ulrich Elmer Hansen and others | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Editors' introduction arguing that transitions frameworks need adapting to high inequality and informality in developing countries. | [IC] |
| Designing Transformative Spaces for Sustainability in Social-Ecological Systems | Laura Pereira, Timothy Karpouzoglou, Niki Frantzeskaki and Per Olsson | 2018 | E4 | mixed | General | Proposes transformative spaces: convened collaborative settings in which people experiment with new social-ecological arrangements. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in the Developing World: Challenges of Socio-Technical Transformations Unfolding in Contexts of Poverty | Mónica Ramos-Mejía, Maria-Laura Franco-Garcia and Juan M. Jauregui-Becker | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Describes how socio-technical transformations unfold in contexts of poverty, and what that asks of transitions theory. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Major Insights and Their Implications for Research and Policy | Anna J. Wieczorek | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Reviews transitions studies of developing countries and finds regimes there less uniform, with some regime stability possibly helping niches form. | [IC] |
| Experimenting for Sustainability Transitions: A Systematic Literature Review | Frans Sengers, Anna J. Wieczorek and Rob Raven | 2019 | E4 | mixed | Global | Reviews the transitions literature on experiments and distinguishes five kinds, each with its own theory and focus. | [IC] |
| Transformative Spaces in the Making: Key Lessons from Nine Cases in the Global South | Laura Pereira and fourteen co-authors | 2020 | E5 | mixed | Southern Africa, Latin America and Asia; Global South | Synthesises nine convened transformative spaces, mainly in the Global South and including Southern African work, into five design lessons. | [IC] |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | E1 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 39 studies of 55,219 firms and finds incubation helps innovation and growth more clearly than survival. | [IC] |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | E1 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and finds a positive overall effect of incubation, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region. | [IC] |
| Work | Author | Year | Type | Publisher or journal | DOI | Subject |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Control Group Study of Incubators' Impact to Promote Firm Survival | Michael Schwartz | 2013 | journal-article | Journal of Technology Transfer 38(3), 302-331 | 10.1007/s10961-012-9254-y | economics |
| A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation | Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan | 1999 | journal-article | Psychological Bulletin 125(6), 627-668 | 10.1037/0033-2909.125.6.627 | consciousness, coordination |
| A Review of the Local Community Development Requirements in South Africa's Renewable Energy Procurement Programme | Holle Linnea Wlokas | 2015 | report | WWF-SA Technical Report, Cape Town | — | economics, coordination |
| Beyond Incubation: An Analysis of Firm Survival and Exit Dynamics in the Post-Graduation Period | Michael Schwartz | 2009 | journal-article | Journal of Technology Transfer 34(4), 403-421 | 10.1007/s10961-008-9095-x | economics |
| Building Sustainable Neighbourhoods in South Africa: Learning from the Lynedoch Case | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2006 | journal-article | Environment and Urbanization 18(2), 315-332 | 10.1177/0956247806069606 | civilization, restoration |
| Designing Transformative Spaces for Sustainability in Social-Ecological Systems | Laura Pereira, Timothy Karpouzoglou, Niki Frantzeskaki and Per Olsson | 2018 | journal-article | Ecology and Society 23(4): 32 | 10.5751/ES-10607-230432 | civilization, coordination |
| Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use | Michael Quinn Patton | 2011 | book | Guilford Press, New York | — | coordination |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | journal-article | Review of Managerial Science 20, 4693-4745 | — | economics |
| Estimating the Reproducibility of Psychological Science | Open Science Collaboration | 2015 | journal-article | Science 349(6251), aac4716 | 10.1126/science.aac4716 | coordination |
| Experimenting for Sustainability Transitions: A Systematic Literature Review | Frans Sengers, Anna J. Wieczorek and Rob Raven | 2019 | journal-article | Technological Forecasting and Social Change 145, 153-164 | 10.1016/j.techfore.2016.08.031 | civilization |
| Grassroots Innovation Movements | Adrian Smith, Mariano Fressoli, Dinesh Abrol, Elisa Arond and Adrian Ely | 2017 | book | Routledge (Pathways to Sustainability series) | 10.4324/9781315697888 | civilization, commons, political-ecology |
| Grassroots Innovations for Sustainable Development: Towards a New Research and Policy Agenda | Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2007 | journal-article | Environmental Politics 16(4), 584-603 | 10.1080/09644010701419121 | civilization, commons |
| Grassroots Innovations in Community Energy: The Role of Intermediaries in Niche Development | Tom Hargreaves, Sabine Hielscher, Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2013 | journal-article | Global Environmental Change 23(5), 868-880 | 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.02.008 | civilization, coordination |
| Growing Grassroots Innovations: Exploring the Role of Community-Based Initiatives in Governing Sustainable Energy Transitions | Gill Seyfang and Alex Haxeltine | 2012 | journal-article | Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 30(3), 381-400 | 10.1068/c10222 | civilization, coordination |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | journal-article | Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal (published online 12 June 2026) | 10.1002/sej.70032 | economics |
| Incubating an Illusion? Long-Term Incubator Firm Performance After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2011 | journal-article | Growth and Change 42(4), 491-516 | 10.1111/j.1468-2257.2011.00565.x | economics |
| Incubation Time, Incubator Age, and Firm Survival After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2012 | journal-article | International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation Management 15(1/2), 108-130 | — | economics |
| Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2012 | book | UCT Press and United Nations University Press | — | civilization, economics |
| Niche Construction and Empowerment Through Socio-Political Work: A Meta-Analysis of Six Low-Carbon Technology Cases | Rob Raven, Florian Kern, Bram Verhees and Adrian Smith | 2016 | journal-article | Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 18, 164-180 | 10.1016/j.eist.2015.02.002 | civilization, coordination |
| Ontological Shielding in New-paradigm Research | Charles Eisenstein | 2026 | essay | Substack, 8 February 2026 | — | consciousness |
| Reflexive Monitoring in Action: A Guide for Monitoring System Innovation Projects | Barbara van Mierlo, Barbara Regeer, Mariette van Amstel, Marleen Arkesteijn, Volkert Beekman, Joske Bunders, Tjard de Cock Buning, Boelie Elzen, Anne-Charlotte Hoes and Cees Leeuwis | 2010 | report | Wageningen University and Research and VU University Amsterdam | — | coordination |
| Regime Resistance Against Low-Carbon Transitions: Introducing Politics and Power into the Multi-Level Perspective | Frank W. Geels | 2014 | journal-article | Theory, Culture and Society 31(5), 21-40 | 10.1177/0263276414531627 | civilization, coordination |
| Regime Shifts to Sustainability Through Processes of Niche Formation: The Approach of Strategic Niche Management | René Kemp, Johan Schot and Remco Hoogma | 1998 | journal-article | Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 10(2), 175-198 | 10.1080/09537329808524310 | civilization, coordination |
| Socio-Technical Regimes and Sustainability Transitions: Insights from Political Ecology | Mary Lawhon and James T. Murphy | 2012 | journal-article | Progress in Human Geography 36(3), 354-378 | 10.1177/0309132511427960 | political-ecology, coordination |
| Strategic Niche Management and Sustainable Innovation Journeys: Theory, Findings, Research Agenda, and Policy | Johan Schot and Frank W. Geels | 2008 | journal-article | Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 20(5), 537-554 | 10.1080/09537320802292651 | civilization |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | journal-article | Global Environmental Change 24, 232-250 | 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.11.011 | civilization, coordination |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Major Insights and Their Implications for Research and Policy | Anna J. Wieczorek | 2018 | journal-article | Environmental Science and Policy 84, 204-216 | 10.1016/j.envsci.2017.08.008 | civilization, economics |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Stocktaking, New Contributions and a Research Agenda | Ulrich Elmer Hansen and others | 2018 | journal-article | Environmental Science and Policy 84, 198-203 | 10.1016/j.envsci.2017.11.009 | civilization, economics |
| Sustainability Transitions in the Developing World: Challenges of Socio-Technical Transformations Unfolding in Contexts of Poverty | Mónica Ramos-Mejía, Maria-Laura Franco-Garcia and Juan M. Jauregui-Becker | 2018 | journal-article | Environmental Science and Policy 84, 217-223 | 10.1016/j.envsci.2017.03.010 | civilization, economics |
| Technological Transitions as Evolutionary Reconfiguration Processes: A Multi-Level Perspective and a Case-Study | Frank W. Geels | 2002 | journal-article | Research Policy 31(8-9), 1257-1274 | 10.1016/S0048-7333(02)00062-8 | civilization |
| The Development of Solar PV in The Netherlands: A Case of Survival in Unfriendly Contexts | Bram Verhees, Rob Raven, Frank Veraart, Adrian Smith and Florian Kern | 2013 | journal-article | Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 19, 275-289 | 10.1016/j.rser.2012.11.011 | civilization |
| The Governance of Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith, Andy Stirling and Frans Berkhout | 2005 | journal-article | Research Policy 34(10), 1491-1510 | 10.1016/j.respol.2005.07.005 | coordination |
| The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? | Rosalind Eyben (ed.), Irene Guijt (ed.), Chris Roche (ed.) and Cathy Shutt (ed.) | 2015 | book | Practical Action Publishing, Rugby | — | coordination, economics |
| The Politics of Social-Ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith and Andy Stirling | 2010 | journal-article | Ecology and Society 15(1): 11 | 10.5751/ES-03218-150111 | coordination, political-ecology |
| Three Horizons: A Pathways Practice for Transformation | Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester, Andrew Lyon and Ioan Fazey | 2016 | journal-article | Ecology and Society 21(2): 47 | 10.5751/ES-08388-210247 | civilization, coordination |
| Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope | Bill Sharpe | 2013 | book | Triarchy Press (second edition 2020) | — | civilization, consciousness |
| Towards a Framework to Guide the Evaluation of Inclusive Innovation Systems | L. Botha, Sara Grobbelaar and Wouter Bam | 2016 | journal-article | South African Journal of Industrial Engineering 27(3), 64-78 | — | economics, coordination |
| Transformative Spaces in the Making: Key Lessons from Nine Cases in the Global South | Laura Pereira and fourteen co-authors | 2020 | journal-article | Sustainability Science 15, 161-178 | 10.1007/s11625-019-00749-x | civilization, coordination |
| Transition Management for Sustainable Development: A Prescriptive, Complexity-Based Governance Framework | Derk Loorbach | 2010 | journal-article | Governance 23(1), 161-183 | 10.1111/j.1468-0491.2009.01471.x | coordination |
| Typology of Sociotechnical Transition Pathways | Frank W. Geels and Johan Schot | 2007 | journal-article | Research Policy 36(3), 399-417 | 10.1016/j.respol.2007.01.003 | civilization |
| University-Driven Inclusive Innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa: Towards a Research Framework of Innovation Regimes | Sara Grobbelaar, Robert Tijssen and Marjolijn Dijksterhuis | 2017 | journal-article | African Journal of Science, Technology, Innovation and Development 9(1), 7-19 | — | economics, coordination |
| What Is Protective Space? Reconsidering Niches in Transitions to Sustainability | Adrian Smith and Rob Raven | 2012 | journal-article | Research Policy 41(6), 1025-1036 | 10.1016/j.respol.2011.12.012 | civilization, coordination |
The case table codes each case the brief draws on in the fields of the coding frame: protection forms P1 to P8 and nurturing processes N1 to N3, as defined above. The TIME codes use Ronfeldt’s framework as adapted by Michael Haupt in the TIME Framework (T Tribal, I Institutional, M Market, E Emergent, dominant form first); every TIME code is the analyst’s inference.
| Case | Source | Protection | Nurturing | Empowerment | Exit | Who protects | TIME | Outcome measured | Design | Authors involved |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dutch solar PV, 1970s to 2012 | Verhees and others 2013 | P1 P2 P3 P4 P6 | N1 N2 N3 | fit-and-conform | gradual-withdrawal | state; firms; civil society (solar co-operatives) | I, M, T | survival (reconstructed) | E3 | no |
| Six low-carbon cases (PV, offshore wind, carbon capture) | Raven and others 2016 | P1 P2 P3 | N1 N2 | mixed | unknown | state; firms | I, M | empowerment (reconstructed) | E3 | same team as source cases |
| UK Transition Towns | Seyfang and Haxeltine 2012 | P6 P7 | N1 N2 N3 | none-recorded | continuing | civil society (Transition Network) | E, T | spread (reconstructed) | E3 | no |
| Transition initiatives in 23 countries | Feola and Nunes 2014 | P1 P6 P7 | N2 N3 | none-recorded | dissolution (some) | community; civil society | E, T | survival and claimed success (survey) | E1 | no |
| UK community energy intermediaries | Hargreaves and others 2013 | P1 P6 | N2 N3 | none-recorded | continuing | civil society; funders | T, I | niche consolidation (claimed; interviews) | E3 | no |
| Lynedoch EcoVillage and Sustainability Institute | Swilling and Annecke 2012 | P1 P4 P6 P7 | N1 N2 N3 | stretch-and-transform | continuing | university (Stellenbosch); founders; community | T, I | survival (claimed) | E5 | yes |
| REIPPPP community trusts | Wlokas 2015 | P1 P2 | N2 | fit-and-conform | continuing | state (IPP Office); firms | I, M | benefit flows (documents; interviews) | E3 | no |
| Nine transformative spaces, including Southern Africa | Pereira and others 2020 | P5 P6 P7 | N1 N2 N3 | mixed | planned-exit | universities; international bodies | E, I | process lessons (claimed) | E5 | yes |
| Five German business incubators | Schwartz 2009 to 2013 | P1 P4 P5 P6 | N2 N3 | fit-and-conform | planned-exit | municipalities; state | I, M | survival and growth after graduation (matched) | E1 | no |
| Dutch energy transition programme | Loorbach 2010 | P2 P5 P7 | N1 N2 N3 | mixed | unknown | state (Ministry of Economic Affairs) | I | process (claimed) | E5 | yes |
| Honey Bee Network and Social Technology Network | Smith and others 2017 | P6 P7 | N2 N3 | stretch-and-transform | capture (partial) | civil society; state | T, E | movement history (reconstructed) | E3 | no |
| Muonde Trust | wiki restoration synthesis | P4 P5 P6 P8 | N3 | none-recorded | continuing | community; a foundation abroad | T, E | durability (claimed) | E5 | no |
The predictions, graded
| Prediction | Evidence for | Evidence against | Grade | What the wiki can say | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 | Initiatives shielded and never empowered stall or dissolve when protection ends | Smith and Raven’s warning [IC]; Schwartz on survival after incubation [IC] | Dutch PV survived by moving between spaces [IC] | Weakly supported | A warned risk, untested for community initiatives |
| P2 | For grassroots initiatives, nurturing matters more to survival than financial shielding | Seyfang and Haxeltine; Hargreaves and others [IC] | Feola and Nunes on material resources and context [IC] | Not supported as stated | Nurturing and material resources both matter; no study ranks them |
| P3 | Protection is usually granted by actors who already hold power, and their terms shape survival | Raven and others on aligning with powerful agendas [IC]; Wlokas on the REIPPPP trusts [IC, report] | Passive and self-made protection by communities [IC; MS for the wiki’s cases] | Supported for active protection of technologies; mixed for grassroots | Active protection usually comes from regime actors; communities also protect themselves |
| P4 | Most evidence comes from single cases (E3 to E5); comparative and longitudinal designs are rare | Raven and others; Feola and Nunes [IC]; two E1 bodies and no E2 found | Incubator studies, for firms [IC] | Supported | Say it plainly |
| P5 | In the Global South, shielding takes different forms and European-built frameworks fit poorly without adaptation | Wieczorek; Hansen and others; Ramos-Mejía and others; Lawhon and Murphy [IC] | Southern studies still find the core terms useful once adapted [IC] | Supported (E4 reviews) | The frameworks are used in the South once adapted |
| P6 | Spaces with an explicit, time-bound exposure rule produce more initiatives that survive exposure | Feola and Nunes [IC]; Schwartz (2012) on incubation time [IC] | None found | Untested as stated; one firm-level study points the same way | A sensible design choice, untested for community initiatives |
| P7 | Reflexive monitoring and developmental evaluation assess a young initiative with less harm than standard metrics | Van Mierlo and others; Patton; Deci and others [IC] | No comparative study | Weakly supported (E4 to E5) | Designed for the purpose; advantage unmeasured |
| P8 | Fit-and-conform initiatives spread faster and change the regime less than stretch-and-transform ones | Implied by the definitions; Smith and Raven [IC] | No study measures speed of spread by route | Untested (conceptual) | A definition; no study has measured it |
| P9 | Open protection, decided and recorded in public, is documented as workable; the research doesn’t show protection must be hidden | The documented protections were public (tariffs, programmes, trusts, arenas, co-operatives) [IC] | No study compares hidden and open protection | Supported in the sense stated | Public protection is documented working |
Evidence the claims must face
- Survivorship. Almost all the cases are survivors. Feola and Nunes (who included inactive initiatives) and Schwartz (matched controls, and firms that closed) are the only exceptions found [IC].
- Authors studying their own work. Lynedoch (Swilling and Annecke), Three Horizons (Sharpe and others), the transformative spaces (Pereira and others) and Dutch transition management (Loorbach) were written up by people who ran, convened or advised them. They’re graded E5.
- Technology to community. The core model comes from technology cases. Grassroots studies confirm that nurturing and intermediaries matter and that the model needs adapting [IC]. Findings on exit and empowerment haven’t been tested on co-operatives or learning campuses.
- The counterfactual. Only Schwartz (2013) and the incubator meta-analyses compare protected and unprotected ventures. No transitions study of a community initiative does.
- The case for exposure. The incubator evidence shows no long-term survival gain from shelter, and a hazard at the moment of exit [IC]. Lean start-up practice holds that early contact with real customers finds failure cheaply [TBV; practitioner literature]. Open science answers the replication problem with more exposure, through registered plans and shared data; the Open Science Collaboration (2015) found 36 per cent of replications statistically significant [IC]. Smith and Raven’s own warning about sheltering weak innovation points the same way [IC].
- The essay’s case. Eisenstein holds that sceptical scrutiny dilutes phenomena that aren’t yet settled, so research can be designed with chosen layers of shielding, and designing an experiment becomes a creative act [MS]. This brief maps that case and neither endorses nor refutes it.
Applying the findings (the wiki’s reading)
The BioConomy wiki’s reading for a bioregional forum or BioHub deciding to protect a young initiative. Each point is inference from the evidence, with its grade.
- What to protect. Favour initiatives that grow from practices people already use and whose local rights are secure (the restoration synthesis [MS]; Feola and Nunes on context [IC]). Write down why the initiative needs protection, and from which pressure.
- Forms to offer. Offer social (P6) and cognitive (P7) protection first: a network, a shared story, and an intermediary that carries lessons in (Hargreaves and others [IC]). Pair them with enough material resources to get through the start (Feola and Nunes [IC]). Money is necessary and isn’t enough on its own.
- Terms in public. Record each protection’s form, provider, purpose and review date in the forum’s public record. The research gives no reason to hide protection (P9, supported) and warns of capture where terms are unclear (Smith and Raven [IC]). The Three-Feature Test asks a related question of patrons under “protection during maximum exposure”.
- Monitoring. Use reflexive monitoring or developmental evaluation early, and track the nurturing processes. Don’t pay per act or rank people (P7, weakly supported; Deci and others [IC]).
- Exposure. Agree and record a review point at which the initiative meets wider conditions, and plan support for that moment (Schwartz 2009, 2012 [IC]; P6 untested for community initiatives). Choose fit-and-conform or stretch-and-transform openly (P8, untested). Entity gestation is already a temporal protection of this kind, with a planned end.
Related
- Major Evolutionary Transitions
- TIME Framework
- Three-Feature Test
- Historical Patronage and the Three-Feature Test
- Ibrahim Abouleish and SEKEM Assessed Against the Three-Feature Test
- Community-Led Landscape Restoration in Sub-Saharan Africa
- Commitment Pooling
- Entity Gestation
- The Bioregional Financing Facility
- Political Economy Analysis
- Infant-industry protection
- Charles Eisenstein
Sources
Every work below has a page in sources/ with its full citation, linked by author and year. Items that aren’t peer-reviewed are labelled.
Transitions: founding and core
- Kemp and others (1998). Regime shifts to sustainability through processes of niche formation. Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 10(2). https://doi.org/10.1080/09537329808524310
- Geels, F.W. (2002). Technological transitions as evolutionary reconfiguration processes. Research Policy 31(8-9). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0048-7333(02)00062-8
- Geels, F.W. and Schot, J. (2007). Typology of sociotechnical transition pathways. Research Policy 36(3). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2007.01.003
- Schot, J. and Geels, F.W. (2008). Strategic niche management and sustainable innovation journeys. Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 20(5). https://doi.org/10.1080/09537320802292651
- Smith, A. and Raven, R. (2012). What is protective space? Reconsidering niches in transitions to sustainability. Research Policy 41(6). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2011.12.012
- Verhees and others (2013). The development of solar PV in The Netherlands. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2012.11.011
- Raven and others (2016). Niche construction and empowerment through socio-political work. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 18. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eist.2015.02.002
- Loorbach, D. (2010). Transition management for sustainable development. Governance 23(1). https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0491.2009.01471.x
- Sharpe, B. (2013). Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope. Triarchy Press. https://triarchypress.net/three-horizons.html
- Sharpe and others (2016). Three horizons: a pathways practice for transformation. Ecology and Society 21(2): 47. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-08388-210247
Transitions: grassroots niches and experiments
- Seyfang, G. and Smith, A. (2007). Grassroots innovations for sustainable development. Environmental Politics 16(4). https://doi.org/10.1080/09644010701419121
- Seyfang, G. and Haxeltine, A. (2012). Growing grassroots innovations. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 30(3). https://doi.org/10.1068/c10222
- Hargreaves and others (2013). Grassroots innovations in community energy. Global Environmental Change 23(5). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.02.008
- Feola, G. and Nunes, R. (2014). Success and failure of grassroots innovations for addressing climate change. Global Environmental Change 24. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.11.011
- Smith and others (2017). Grassroots Innovation Movements. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315697888
- Sengers and others (2019). Experimenting for sustainability transitions. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 145. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2016.08.031
- Pereira and others (2018). Designing transformative spaces for sustainability in social-ecological systems. Ecology and Society 23(4): 32. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-10607-230432
- Pereira, L. and others (2020). Transformative spaces in the making. Sustainability Science 15. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-019-00749-x
Governance and critiques
- Smith and others (2005). The governance of sustainable socio-technical transitions. Research Policy 34(10). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2005.07.005
- Smith, A. and Stirling, A. (2010). The politics of social-ecological resilience and sustainable socio-technical transitions. Ecology and Society 15(1): 11. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-03218-150111
- Lawhon, M. and Murphy, J.T. (2012). Socio-technical regimes and sustainability transitions. Progress in Human Geography 36(3). https://doi.org/10.1177/0309132511427960
- Geels, F.W. (2014). Regime resistance against low-carbon transitions. Theory, Culture and Society 31(5). https://doi.org/10.1177/0263276414531627
Global South and Africa
- Wieczorek, A.J. (2018). Sustainability transitions in developing countries. Environmental Science and Policy 84. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2017.08.008
- Hansen, U.E. and others (2018). Sustainability transitions in developing countries. Environmental Science and Policy 84. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2017.11.009
- Ramos-Mejía and others (2018). Sustainability transitions in the developing world. Environmental Science and Policy 84. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2017.03.010
- Swilling, M. and Annecke, E. (2012). Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World. UCT Press and United Nations University Press. https://www0.sun.ac.za/cst/?p=1791
- Swilling, M. and Annecke, E. (2006). Building sustainable neighbourhoods in South Africa. Environment and Urbanization 18(2). https://doi.org/10.1177/0956247806069606
- Wlokas, H.L. (2015). A review of the local community development requirements in South Africa’s renewable energy procurement programme. WWF-SA. Report (not peer-reviewed). https://www0.sun.ac.za/cst/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/WWF_Wlokas_Review-of-local-community-development-in-REIPPP_2015.pdf
- Grobbelaar and others (2017). University-driven inclusive innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa. African Journal of Science, Technology, Innovation and Development 9(1). https://scholarlypublications.universiteitleiden.nl/handle/1887/49121
- Botha and others (2016). Towards a framework to guide the evaluation of inclusive innovation systems. South African Journal of Industrial Engineering 27(3), 64-78. http://sajie.journals.ac.za/pub/article/view/1632
- IPP Office figures on REIPPPP job years and socio-economic development spending, as cited in an article in New Agenda (2025). https://epubs.ac.za/index.php/newagenda/article/download/3197/2009/8514
Incubation, survival and exit
- Schwartz, M. (2009). Beyond incubation: an analysis of firm survival and exit dynamics in the post-graduation period. Journal of Technology Transfer 34(4). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10961-008-9095-x
- Schwartz, M. (2011). Incubating an illusion? Long-term incubator firm performance after graduation. Growth and Change 42(4). https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2257.2011.00565.x
- Schwartz, M. (2012). Incubation time, incubator age, and firm survival after graduation. International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation Management 15(1/2). https://www.inderscience.com/offer.php?id=44073
- Schwartz, M. (2013). A control group study of incubators’ impact to promote firm survival. Journal of Technology Transfer 38(3). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10961-012-9254-y
- Murillo-Rojas and others (2026). Hatching and fledging? A meta-analysis of the performance effects of business incubators. Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal. https://doi.org/10.1002/sej.70032
- Seitz and others (2026). Do startup incubators enhance new venture performance? Evidence from a meta-analysis. Review of Managerial Science 20. https://opus.bibliothek.uni-augsburg.de/opus4/frontdoor/index/index/docId/130497
Evidence and evaluation
- van Mierlo, B. and others (2010). Reflexive Monitoring in Action: A Guide for Monitoring System Innovation Projects. Wageningen UR and VU University Amsterdam. Report. https://edepot.wur.nl/149471
- Patton, M.Q. (2011). Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use. Guilford Press. https://www.guilford.com/books/Developmental-Evaluation/Michael-Quinn-Patton/9781606238721
- Eyben and others (2015). The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? Practical Action Publishing. https://www.ids.ac.uk/publications/the-politics-of-evidence-and-results-in-international-development-playing-the-game-to-change-the-rules/
- Deci and others (1999). A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation. Psychological Bulletin 125(6). https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.125.6.627
- Open Science Collaboration (2015). Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science. Science 349(6251), aac4716. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aac4716
The counterpart
- Eisenstein, C. (2026). Ontological shielding in new-paradigm research. Substack, 8 February 2026. Essay. https://charleseisenstein.substack.com/p/ontological-shielding-in-new-paradigm
Provenance
Written on 17 November 2026 from a Claude deep research report commissioned by Michael Haupt (instructions version 0.1, the same day), filling the first gap named in the parallel societies research map. The run couldn’t fetch the live corpus pages, so it used extracts from the local repositories. Eisenstein’s essay was read live, Smith and Raven (2012) in its 2011 working-paper version, Raven and others (2016) in its accepted manuscript, and other works through abstracts, repository records and citing works.