Any arrangement that holds back the selection pressure of the dominant system from a young initiative, such as a subsidy, a pilot permission, a sympathetic buyer or a remote place.
Shielding is the first of the three properties of protective space named by Smith and Raven (2012). It keeps the prices, rules, measures and expectations of the regime from bearing fully on something new before it’s ready. Smith and Raven separate two kinds. Passive shielding uses spaces that already exist: an area the grid doesn’t reach, general research funding, a group of committed users. Active shielding is built on purpose by advocates: a feed-in tariff, an exemption, a protected share of public buying.
The forms can be financial, regulatory, market, spatial, temporal, social, cognitive or informational. The shielding documented in the research was almost all public. A low profile appears in early niches as a condition of being small, and no study found treats it as a designed tool.
Contrast with adjacent terms
- Ontological shielding, in Charles Eisenstein’s essay of February 2026, is a proposal to protect phenomena he holds are changed by sceptical exposure. It makes a claim about reality that transitions research doesn’t make or test; the research claim is social and economic.
- Nurturing builds an initiative up inside the shield; shielding only holds pressure back.
- Secrecy hides an initiative from view. Shielding in the research is usually open and recorded.
Related terms
Related pages
Sources
- Smith and Raven (2012). What Is Protective Space? Reconsidering Niches in Transitions to Sustainability. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2011.12.012
- Verhees and others (2013). The Development of Solar PV in The Netherlands: A Case of Survival in Unfriendly Contexts. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2012.11.011
- Eisenstein (2026). Ontological Shielding in New-paradigm Research. https://charleseisenstein.substack.com/p/ontological-shielding-in-new-paradigm
Provenance
Written on 17 November 2026 from hand-back item 5 of the research run behind Protective Space for Young Initiatives. The definition follows Smith and Raven (2012), as the term is used in transitions research.