| Work | Author | Year | Design | Niche type | Setting | Finding | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Regime Shifts to Sustainability Through Processes of Niche Formation: The Approach of Strategic Niche Management | René Kemp, Johan Schot and Remco Hoogma | 1998 | E4 | technological | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out strategic niche management: deliberately created, temporary niches in which users, producers and regulators learn together as a route to regime shifts. | [IC] |
| A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation | Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan | 1999 | E1 | mixed | Mainly United States; Global North | Reviews 128 experiments and finds tangible, task-linked rewards reduce intrinsic motivation, while positive feedback tends to raise it. | [IC] |
| Technological Transitions as Evolutionary Reconfiguration Processes: A Multi-Level Perspective and a Case-Study | Frank W. Geels | 2002 | E4 | technological | United Kingdom; Global North | Builds the multi-level perspective of niche, regime and landscape on the shift from sail to steam ships. | [IC] |
| The Governance of Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith, Andy Stirling and Frans Berkhout | 2005 | E4 | technological | Europe; Global North | Argues that transitions depend on regime actors' resources and adaptive capacity, and that steering them is a political act. | [IC] |
| Building Sustainable Neighbourhoods in South Africa: Learning from the Lynedoch Case | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2006 | E5 | grassroots | South Africa; peri-urban; Global South | The co-founders' account of Lynedoch EcoVillage, which they describe as South Africa's first socially mixed, ecologically designed intentional community. | [MS] |
| Typology of Sociotechnical Transition Pathways | Frank W. Geels and Johan Schot | 2007 | E4 | technological | Europe; Global North | Sets out several pathways by which niche innovations, regimes and landscape pressure interact in a transition. | [TBV] |
| Grassroots Innovations for Sustainable Development: Towards a New Research and Policy Agenda | Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2007 | E4 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Argues that community-led grassroots innovations differ from market niches in their drivers, resources and aims, and sets a research agenda for them. | [IC] |
| Strategic Niche Management and Sustainable Innovation Journeys: Theory, Findings, Research Agenda, and Policy | Johan Schot and Frank W. Geels | 2008 | E4 | technological | Europe; Global North | Reviews ten years of strategic niche management studies and concludes that niche-internal processes must be read together with processes outside the niche. | [IC] |
| Beyond Incubation: An Analysis of Firm Survival and Exit Dynamics in the Post-Graduation Period | Michael Schwartz | 2009 | E1 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 352 graduates of five German incubators and finds that leaving the incubator brings a drop in survival lasting up to three years. | [IC] |
| Transition Management for Sustainable Development: A Prescriptive, Complexity-Based Governance Framework | Derk Loorbach | 2010 | E5 | institutional | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out transition management: arenas, agendas, experiments and reflexive evaluation, drawn from the Dutch national energy transition programme. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Social-Ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith and Andy Stirling | 2010 | E4 | mixed | General | Argues that resilience and transitions research both tend to close down governance around expert framings, and calls for opening it up. | [IC] |
| Reflexive Monitoring in Action: A Guide for Monitoring System Innovation Projects | Barbara van Mierlo, Barbara Regeer, Mariette van Amstel, Marleen Arkesteijn, Volkert Beekman, Joske Bunders, Tjard de Cock Buning, Boelie Elzen, Anne-Charlotte Hoes and Cees Leeuwis | 2010 | E5 | mixed | Netherlands; Global North | A method in which a monitor works inside a system innovation project, helping participants reflect on the system they want to change while they act. | [IC] |
| Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use | Michael Quinn Patton | 2011 | E4 | mixed | General | Proposes evaluation that supports innovations in complex, changing settings, where the evaluator helps the work adapt and goals may change. | [IC] |
| Incubating an Illusion? Long-Term Incubator Firm Performance After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2011 | E1 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 324 graduates of five German incubators and finds early growth after graduation, with no continued growth for most firms. | [IC] |
| Socio-Technical Regimes and Sustainability Transitions: Insights from Political Ecology | Mary Lawhon and James T. Murphy | 2012 | E4 | mixed | General | Names four limitations of socio-technical transitions research and draws on political ecology to address them, with a case on genetically modified crops. | [IC] |
| Incubation Time, Incubator Age, and Firm Survival After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2012 | E1 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Finds, for 149 graduates of five German incubators, that longer incubation and older incubators both lower survival after graduation. | [IC] |
| Growing Grassroots Innovations: Exploring the Role of Community-Based Initiatives in Governing Sustainable Energy Transitions | Gill Seyfang and Alex Haxeltine | 2012 | E3 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Applies strategic niche management to the UK Transition Towns movement and finds a working niche with significant weaknesses in its niche processes. | [IC] |
| What Is Protective Space? Reconsidering Niches in Transitions to Sustainability | Adrian Smith and Rob Raven | 2012 | E4 | technological | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Defines protection as shielding, nurturing and empowerment, separates passive from active shielding, names two routes to empowerment, and warns of capture. | [IC] |
| Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2012 | E5 | grassroots | South Africa; Global South | Reads sustainability transitions from the Global South; Chapter 10, by the co-founders of Lynedoch EcoVillage and the Sustainability Institute, reflects on that work. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovations in Community Energy: The Role of Intermediaries in Niche Development | Tom Hargreaves, Sabine Hielscher, Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2013 | E3 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Finds that intermediary organisations help consolidate UK community energy, while the knowledge most groups need stays local and transfers poorly. | [IC] |
| A Control Group Study of Incubators' Impact to Promote Firm Survival | Michael Schwartz | 2013 | E1 | institutional | Germany; urban; Global North | Matches 371 incubator graduates with 371 similar firms over ten years and finds no incubator that raised survival; three lowered it. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope | Bill Sharpe | 2013 | E5 | mixed | United Kingdom; Global North | Presents Three Horizons, a practice that holds the declining present, the emerging future and the contested space between them together in the present. | [IC] |
| The Development of Solar PV in The Netherlands: A Case of Survival in Unfriendly Contexts | Bram Verhees, Rob Raven, Frank Veraart, Adrian Smith and Florian Kern | 2013 | E3 | technological | Netherlands; Global North | Traces Dutch solar PV from the 1970s to 2012 and finds that it survived hostile policy periods by building and moving between several protected spaces. | [IC] |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | E1 | grassroots | 23 countries; mainly Global North | Surveys 276 active and inactive Transition initiatives in 23 countries and finds less successful ones may underestimate context and material resources. | [IC] |
| Regime Resistance Against Low-Carbon Transitions: Introducing Politics and Power into the Multi-Level Perspective | Frank W. Geels | 2014 | E4 | technological | United Kingdom; Global North | Adds incumbent power and resistance to the multi-level perspective, using the UK electricity sector as the example. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? | Rosalind Eyben (ed.), Irene Guijt (ed.), Chris Roche (ed.) and Cathy Shutt (ed.) | 2015 | E5 | institutional | International; Global South | Practitioners' accounts of how demands for results and evidence in aid shape programmes, and how staff comply, adapt or resist. | [IC] |
| Estimating the Reproducibility of Psychological Science | Open Science Collaboration | 2015 | E1 | mixed | International; Global North | Replicates 100 psychology studies and finds 36 per cent of replications statistically significant, with effects about half the original size. | [IC] |
| A Review of the Local Community Development Requirements in South Africa's Renewable Energy Procurement Programme | Holle Linnea Wlokas | 2015 | E3 | institutional | South Africa; rural; Global South | Reviews the community development rules in South Africa's renewable energy procurement programme and finds communities treated mostly as beneficiaries. | [IC] |
| Towards a Framework to Guide the Evaluation of Inclusive Innovation Systems | L. Botha, Sara Grobbelaar and Wouter Bam | 2016 | E4 | institutional | South Africa; Global South | Proposes a framework for evaluating inclusive innovation systems in South Africa. | [IC] |
| Niche Construction and Empowerment Through Socio-Political Work: A Meta-Analysis of Six Low-Carbon Technology Cases | Rob Raven, Florian Kern, Bram Verhees and Adrian Smith | 2016 | E3 | technological | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Compares six low-carbon technology cases and finds that advocates won protection by aligning their story with powerful actors' agendas. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: A Pathways Practice for Transformation | Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester, Andrew Lyon and Ioan Fazey | 2016 | E5 | mixed | United Kingdom; Global North | Describes Three Horizons as a facilitation practice for transformation, from the authors' own experience of using it. | [IC] |
| University-Driven Inclusive Innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa: Towards a Research Framework of Innovation Regimes | Sara Grobbelaar, Robert Tijssen and Marjolijn Dijksterhuis | 2017 | E3 | institutional | South Africa (Western Cape); Global South | Studies 15 university-driven inclusive innovation activities in the Western Cape and proposes a framework of innovation regimes for them. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovation Movements | Adrian Smith, Mariano Fressoli, Dinesh Abrol, Elisa Arond and Adrian Ely | 2017 | E3 | grassroots | United Kingdom, South America, India, Brazil; mixed | Examines six grassroots innovation movements in Europe, South America and India, and how each made space for alternatives and met more powerful actors. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Stocktaking, New Contributions and a Research Agenda | Ulrich Elmer Hansen and others | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Editors' introduction arguing that transitions frameworks need adapting to high inequality and informality in developing countries. | [IC] |
| Designing Transformative Spaces for Sustainability in Social-Ecological Systems | Laura Pereira, Timothy Karpouzoglou, Niki Frantzeskaki and Per Olsson | 2018 | E4 | mixed | General | Proposes transformative spaces: convened collaborative settings in which people experiment with new social-ecological arrangements. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in the Developing World: Challenges of Socio-Technical Transformations Unfolding in Contexts of Poverty | Mónica Ramos-Mejía, Maria-Laura Franco-Garcia and Juan M. Jauregui-Becker | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Describes how socio-technical transformations unfold in contexts of poverty, and what that asks of transitions theory. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Major Insights and Their Implications for Research and Policy | Anna J. Wieczorek | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Reviews transitions studies of developing countries and finds regimes there less uniform, with some regime stability possibly helping niches form. | [IC] |
| Experimenting for Sustainability Transitions: A Systematic Literature Review | Frans Sengers, Anna J. Wieczorek and Rob Raven | 2019 | E4 | mixed | Global | Reviews the transitions literature on experiments and distinguishes five kinds, each with its own theory and focus. | [IC] |
| Transformative Spaces in the Making: Key Lessons from Nine Cases in the Global South | Laura Pereira and fourteen co-authors | 2020 | E5 | mixed | Southern Africa, Latin America and Asia; Global South | Synthesises nine convened transformative spaces, mainly in the Global South and including Southern African work, into five design lessons. | [IC] |
| Ontological Shielding in New-paradigm Research | Charles Eisenstein | 2026 | E5 | mixed | United States; Global North | Eisenstein's essay proposing layers of shielding for research into phenomena he holds are changed by sceptical exposure. | [MS] |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | E1 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 39 studies of 55,219 firms and finds incubation helps innovation and growth more clearly than survival. | [IC] |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | E1 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and finds a positive overall effect of incubation, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region. | [IC] |
| Work | Author | Year | Niche type | Setting | Finding | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Design E417 | ||||||
| Regime Shifts to Sustainability Through Processes of Niche Formation: The Approach of Strategic Niche Management | René Kemp, Johan Schot and Remco Hoogma | 1998 | technological | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out strategic niche management: deliberately created, temporary niches in which users, producers and regulators learn together as a route to regime shifts. | [IC] |
| Technological Transitions as Evolutionary Reconfiguration Processes: A Multi-Level Perspective and a Case-Study | Frank W. Geels | 2002 | technological | United Kingdom; Global North | Builds the multi-level perspective of niche, regime and landscape on the shift from sail to steam ships. | [IC] |
| The Governance of Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith, Andy Stirling and Frans Berkhout | 2005 | technological | Europe; Global North | Argues that transitions depend on regime actors' resources and adaptive capacity, and that steering them is a political act. | [IC] |
| Typology of Sociotechnical Transition Pathways | Frank W. Geels and Johan Schot | 2007 | technological | Europe; Global North | Sets out several pathways by which niche innovations, regimes and landscape pressure interact in a transition. | [TBV] |
| Grassroots Innovations for Sustainable Development: Towards a New Research and Policy Agenda | Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2007 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Argues that community-led grassroots innovations differ from market niches in their drivers, resources and aims, and sets a research agenda for them. | [IC] |
| Strategic Niche Management and Sustainable Innovation Journeys: Theory, Findings, Research Agenda, and Policy | Johan Schot and Frank W. Geels | 2008 | technological | Europe; Global North | Reviews ten years of strategic niche management studies and concludes that niche-internal processes must be read together with processes outside the niche. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Social-Ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith and Andy Stirling | 2010 | mixed | General | Argues that resilience and transitions research both tend to close down governance around expert framings, and calls for opening it up. | [IC] |
| Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use | Michael Quinn Patton | 2011 | mixed | General | Proposes evaluation that supports innovations in complex, changing settings, where the evaluator helps the work adapt and goals may change. | [IC] |
| Socio-Technical Regimes and Sustainability Transitions: Insights from Political Ecology | Mary Lawhon and James T. Murphy | 2012 | mixed | General | Names four limitations of socio-technical transitions research and draws on political ecology to address them, with a case on genetically modified crops. | [IC] |
| What Is Protective Space? Reconsidering Niches in Transitions to Sustainability | Adrian Smith and Rob Raven | 2012 | technological | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Defines protection as shielding, nurturing and empowerment, separates passive from active shielding, names two routes to empowerment, and warns of capture. | [IC] |
| Regime Resistance Against Low-Carbon Transitions: Introducing Politics and Power into the Multi-Level Perspective | Frank W. Geels | 2014 | technological | United Kingdom; Global North | Adds incumbent power and resistance to the multi-level perspective, using the UK electricity sector as the example. | [IC] |
| Towards a Framework to Guide the Evaluation of Inclusive Innovation Systems | L. Botha, Sara Grobbelaar and Wouter Bam | 2016 | institutional | South Africa; Global South | Proposes a framework for evaluating inclusive innovation systems in South Africa. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Stocktaking, New Contributions and a Research Agenda | Ulrich Elmer Hansen and others | 2018 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Editors' introduction arguing that transitions frameworks need adapting to high inequality and informality in developing countries. | [IC] |
| Designing Transformative Spaces for Sustainability in Social-Ecological Systems | Laura Pereira, Timothy Karpouzoglou, Niki Frantzeskaki and Per Olsson | 2018 | mixed | General | Proposes transformative spaces: convened collaborative settings in which people experiment with new social-ecological arrangements. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in the Developing World: Challenges of Socio-Technical Transformations Unfolding in Contexts of Poverty | Mónica Ramos-Mejía, Maria-Laura Franco-Garcia and Juan M. Jauregui-Becker | 2018 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Describes how socio-technical transformations unfold in contexts of poverty, and what that asks of transitions theory. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Major Insights and Their Implications for Research and Policy | Anna J. Wieczorek | 2018 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Reviews transitions studies of developing countries and finds regimes there less uniform, with some regime stability possibly helping niches form. | [IC] |
| Experimenting for Sustainability Transitions: A Systematic Literature Review | Frans Sengers, Anna J. Wieczorek and Rob Raven | 2019 | mixed | Global | Reviews the transitions literature on experiments and distinguishes five kinds, each with its own theory and focus. | [IC] |
| Design E19 | ||||||
| A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation | Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan | 1999 | mixed | Mainly United States; Global North | Reviews 128 experiments and finds tangible, task-linked rewards reduce intrinsic motivation, while positive feedback tends to raise it. | [IC] |
| Beyond Incubation: An Analysis of Firm Survival and Exit Dynamics in the Post-Graduation Period | Michael Schwartz | 2009 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 352 graduates of five German incubators and finds that leaving the incubator brings a drop in survival lasting up to three years. | [IC] |
| Incubating an Illusion? Long-Term Incubator Firm Performance After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2011 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 324 graduates of five German incubators and finds early growth after graduation, with no continued growth for most firms. | [IC] |
| Incubation Time, Incubator Age, and Firm Survival After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2012 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Finds, for 149 graduates of five German incubators, that longer incubation and older incubators both lower survival after graduation. | [IC] |
| A Control Group Study of Incubators' Impact to Promote Firm Survival | Michael Schwartz | 2013 | institutional | Germany; urban; Global North | Matches 371 incubator graduates with 371 similar firms over ten years and finds no incubator that raised survival; three lowered it. | [IC] |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | grassroots | 23 countries; mainly Global North | Surveys 276 active and inactive Transition initiatives in 23 countries and finds less successful ones may underestimate context and material resources. | [IC] |
| Estimating the Reproducibility of Psychological Science | Open Science Collaboration | 2015 | mixed | International; Global North | Replicates 100 psychology studies and finds 36 per cent of replications statistically significant, with effects about half the original size. | [IC] |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 39 studies of 55,219 firms and finds incubation helps innovation and growth more clearly than survival. | [IC] |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and finds a positive overall effect of incubation, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region. | [IC] |
| Design E59 | ||||||
| Building Sustainable Neighbourhoods in South Africa: Learning from the Lynedoch Case | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2006 | grassroots | South Africa; peri-urban; Global South | The co-founders' account of Lynedoch EcoVillage, which they describe as South Africa's first socially mixed, ecologically designed intentional community. | [MS] |
| Transition Management for Sustainable Development: A Prescriptive, Complexity-Based Governance Framework | Derk Loorbach | 2010 | institutional | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out transition management: arenas, agendas, experiments and reflexive evaluation, drawn from the Dutch national energy transition programme. | [IC] |
| Reflexive Monitoring in Action: A Guide for Monitoring System Innovation Projects | Barbara van Mierlo, Barbara Regeer, Mariette van Amstel, Marleen Arkesteijn, Volkert Beekman, Joske Bunders, Tjard de Cock Buning, Boelie Elzen, Anne-Charlotte Hoes and Cees Leeuwis | 2010 | mixed | Netherlands; Global North | A method in which a monitor works inside a system innovation project, helping participants reflect on the system they want to change while they act. | [IC] |
| Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2012 | grassroots | South Africa; Global South | Reads sustainability transitions from the Global South; Chapter 10, by the co-founders of Lynedoch EcoVillage and the Sustainability Institute, reflects on that work. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope | Bill Sharpe | 2013 | mixed | United Kingdom; Global North | Presents Three Horizons, a practice that holds the declining present, the emerging future and the contested space between them together in the present. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? | Rosalind Eyben (ed.), Irene Guijt (ed.), Chris Roche (ed.) and Cathy Shutt (ed.) | 2015 | institutional | International; Global South | Practitioners' accounts of how demands for results and evidence in aid shape programmes, and how staff comply, adapt or resist. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: A Pathways Practice for Transformation | Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester, Andrew Lyon and Ioan Fazey | 2016 | mixed | United Kingdom; Global North | Describes Three Horizons as a facilitation practice for transformation, from the authors' own experience of using it. | [IC] |
| Transformative Spaces in the Making: Key Lessons from Nine Cases in the Global South | Laura Pereira and fourteen co-authors | 2020 | mixed | Southern Africa, Latin America and Asia; Global South | Synthesises nine convened transformative spaces, mainly in the Global South and including Southern African work, into five design lessons. | [IC] |
| Ontological Shielding in New-paradigm Research | Charles Eisenstein | 2026 | mixed | United States; Global North | Eisenstein's essay proposing layers of shielding for research into phenomena he holds are changed by sceptical exposure. | [MS] |
| Design E37 | ||||||
| Growing Grassroots Innovations: Exploring the Role of Community-Based Initiatives in Governing Sustainable Energy Transitions | Gill Seyfang and Alex Haxeltine | 2012 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Applies strategic niche management to the UK Transition Towns movement and finds a working niche with significant weaknesses in its niche processes. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovations in Community Energy: The Role of Intermediaries in Niche Development | Tom Hargreaves, Sabine Hielscher, Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2013 | grassroots | United Kingdom; Global North | Finds that intermediary organisations help consolidate UK community energy, while the knowledge most groups need stays local and transfers poorly. | [IC] |
| The Development of Solar PV in The Netherlands: A Case of Survival in Unfriendly Contexts | Bram Verhees, Rob Raven, Frank Veraart, Adrian Smith and Florian Kern | 2013 | technological | Netherlands; Global North | Traces Dutch solar PV from the 1970s to 2012 and finds that it survived hostile policy periods by building and moving between several protected spaces. | [IC] |
| A Review of the Local Community Development Requirements in South Africa's Renewable Energy Procurement Programme | Holle Linnea Wlokas | 2015 | institutional | South Africa; rural; Global South | Reviews the community development rules in South Africa's renewable energy procurement programme and finds communities treated mostly as beneficiaries. | [IC] |
| Niche Construction and Empowerment Through Socio-Political Work: A Meta-Analysis of Six Low-Carbon Technology Cases | Rob Raven, Florian Kern, Bram Verhees and Adrian Smith | 2016 | technological | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Compares six low-carbon technology cases and finds that advocates won protection by aligning their story with powerful actors' agendas. | [IC] |
| University-Driven Inclusive Innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa: Towards a Research Framework of Innovation Regimes | Sara Grobbelaar, Robert Tijssen and Marjolijn Dijksterhuis | 2017 | institutional | South Africa (Western Cape); Global South | Studies 15 university-driven inclusive innovation activities in the Western Cape and proposes a framework of innovation regimes for them. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovation Movements | Adrian Smith, Mariano Fressoli, Dinesh Abrol, Elisa Arond and Adrian Ely | 2017 | grassroots | United Kingdom, South America, India, Brazil; mixed | Examines six grassroots innovation movements in Europe, South America and India, and how each made space for alternatives and met more powerful actors. | [IC] |
| Work | Author | Year | Design | Setting | Finding | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Niche type technological9 | ||||||
| Regime Shifts to Sustainability Through Processes of Niche Formation: The Approach of Strategic Niche Management | René Kemp, Johan Schot and Remco Hoogma | 1998 | E4 | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out strategic niche management: deliberately created, temporary niches in which users, producers and regulators learn together as a route to regime shifts. | [IC] |
| Technological Transitions as Evolutionary Reconfiguration Processes: A Multi-Level Perspective and a Case-Study | Frank W. Geels | 2002 | E4 | United Kingdom; Global North | Builds the multi-level perspective of niche, regime and landscape on the shift from sail to steam ships. | [IC] |
| The Governance of Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith, Andy Stirling and Frans Berkhout | 2005 | E4 | Europe; Global North | Argues that transitions depend on regime actors' resources and adaptive capacity, and that steering them is a political act. | [IC] |
| Typology of Sociotechnical Transition Pathways | Frank W. Geels and Johan Schot | 2007 | E4 | Europe; Global North | Sets out several pathways by which niche innovations, regimes and landscape pressure interact in a transition. | [TBV] |
| Strategic Niche Management and Sustainable Innovation Journeys: Theory, Findings, Research Agenda, and Policy | Johan Schot and Frank W. Geels | 2008 | E4 | Europe; Global North | Reviews ten years of strategic niche management studies and concludes that niche-internal processes must be read together with processes outside the niche. | [IC] |
| What Is Protective Space? Reconsidering Niches in Transitions to Sustainability | Adrian Smith and Rob Raven | 2012 | E4 | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Defines protection as shielding, nurturing and empowerment, separates passive from active shielding, names two routes to empowerment, and warns of capture. | [IC] |
| The Development of Solar PV in The Netherlands: A Case of Survival in Unfriendly Contexts | Bram Verhees, Rob Raven, Frank Veraart, Adrian Smith and Florian Kern | 2013 | E3 | Netherlands; Global North | Traces Dutch solar PV from the 1970s to 2012 and finds that it survived hostile policy periods by building and moving between several protected spaces. | [IC] |
| Regime Resistance Against Low-Carbon Transitions: Introducing Politics and Power into the Multi-Level Perspective | Frank W. Geels | 2014 | E4 | United Kingdom; Global North | Adds incumbent power and resistance to the multi-level perspective, using the UK electricity sector as the example. | [IC] |
| Niche Construction and Empowerment Through Socio-Political Work: A Meta-Analysis of Six Low-Carbon Technology Cases | Rob Raven, Florian Kern, Bram Verhees and Adrian Smith | 2016 | E3 | United Kingdom and Netherlands; Global North | Compares six low-carbon technology cases and finds that advocates won protection by aligning their story with powerful actors' agendas. | [IC] |
| Niche type mixed15 | ||||||
| A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation | Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan | 1999 | E1 | Mainly United States; Global North | Reviews 128 experiments and finds tangible, task-linked rewards reduce intrinsic motivation, while positive feedback tends to raise it. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Social-Ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith and Andy Stirling | 2010 | E4 | General | Argues that resilience and transitions research both tend to close down governance around expert framings, and calls for opening it up. | [IC] |
| Reflexive Monitoring in Action: A Guide for Monitoring System Innovation Projects | Barbara van Mierlo, Barbara Regeer, Mariette van Amstel, Marleen Arkesteijn, Volkert Beekman, Joske Bunders, Tjard de Cock Buning, Boelie Elzen, Anne-Charlotte Hoes and Cees Leeuwis | 2010 | E5 | Netherlands; Global North | A method in which a monitor works inside a system innovation project, helping participants reflect on the system they want to change while they act. | [IC] |
| Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use | Michael Quinn Patton | 2011 | E4 | General | Proposes evaluation that supports innovations in complex, changing settings, where the evaluator helps the work adapt and goals may change. | [IC] |
| Socio-Technical Regimes and Sustainability Transitions: Insights from Political Ecology | Mary Lawhon and James T. Murphy | 2012 | E4 | General | Names four limitations of socio-technical transitions research and draws on political ecology to address them, with a case on genetically modified crops. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope | Bill Sharpe | 2013 | E5 | United Kingdom; Global North | Presents Three Horizons, a practice that holds the declining present, the emerging future and the contested space between them together in the present. | [IC] |
| Estimating the Reproducibility of Psychological Science | Open Science Collaboration | 2015 | E1 | International; Global North | Replicates 100 psychology studies and finds 36 per cent of replications statistically significant, with effects about half the original size. | [IC] |
| Three Horizons: A Pathways Practice for Transformation | Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester, Andrew Lyon and Ioan Fazey | 2016 | E5 | United Kingdom; Global North | Describes Three Horizons as a facilitation practice for transformation, from the authors' own experience of using it. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Stocktaking, New Contributions and a Research Agenda | Ulrich Elmer Hansen and others | 2018 | E4 | Developing countries; Global South | Editors' introduction arguing that transitions frameworks need adapting to high inequality and informality in developing countries. | [IC] |
| Designing Transformative Spaces for Sustainability in Social-Ecological Systems | Laura Pereira, Timothy Karpouzoglou, Niki Frantzeskaki and Per Olsson | 2018 | E4 | General | Proposes transformative spaces: convened collaborative settings in which people experiment with new social-ecological arrangements. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in the Developing World: Challenges of Socio-Technical Transformations Unfolding in Contexts of Poverty | Mónica Ramos-Mejía, Maria-Laura Franco-Garcia and Juan M. Jauregui-Becker | 2018 | E4 | Developing countries; Global South | Describes how socio-technical transformations unfold in contexts of poverty, and what that asks of transitions theory. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Major Insights and Their Implications for Research and Policy | Anna J. Wieczorek | 2018 | E4 | Developing countries; Global South | Reviews transitions studies of developing countries and finds regimes there less uniform, with some regime stability possibly helping niches form. | [IC] |
| Experimenting for Sustainability Transitions: A Systematic Literature Review | Frans Sengers, Anna J. Wieczorek and Rob Raven | 2019 | E4 | Global | Reviews the transitions literature on experiments and distinguishes five kinds, each with its own theory and focus. | [IC] |
| Transformative Spaces in the Making: Key Lessons from Nine Cases in the Global South | Laura Pereira and fourteen co-authors | 2020 | E5 | Southern Africa, Latin America and Asia; Global South | Synthesises nine convened transformative spaces, mainly in the Global South and including Southern African work, into five design lessons. | [IC] |
| Ontological Shielding in New-paradigm Research | Charles Eisenstein | 2026 | E5 | United States; Global North | Eisenstein's essay proposing layers of shielding for research into phenomena he holds are changed by sceptical exposure. | [MS] |
| Niche type grassroots7 | ||||||
| Building Sustainable Neighbourhoods in South Africa: Learning from the Lynedoch Case | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2006 | E5 | South Africa; peri-urban; Global South | The co-founders' account of Lynedoch EcoVillage, which they describe as South Africa's first socially mixed, ecologically designed intentional community. | [MS] |
| Grassroots Innovations for Sustainable Development: Towards a New Research and Policy Agenda | Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2007 | E4 | United Kingdom; Global North | Argues that community-led grassroots innovations differ from market niches in their drivers, resources and aims, and sets a research agenda for them. | [IC] |
| Growing Grassroots Innovations: Exploring the Role of Community-Based Initiatives in Governing Sustainable Energy Transitions | Gill Seyfang and Alex Haxeltine | 2012 | E3 | United Kingdom; Global North | Applies strategic niche management to the UK Transition Towns movement and finds a working niche with significant weaknesses in its niche processes. | [IC] |
| Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2012 | E5 | South Africa; Global South | Reads sustainability transitions from the Global South; Chapter 10, by the co-founders of Lynedoch EcoVillage and the Sustainability Institute, reflects on that work. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovations in Community Energy: The Role of Intermediaries in Niche Development | Tom Hargreaves, Sabine Hielscher, Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2013 | E3 | United Kingdom; Global North | Finds that intermediary organisations help consolidate UK community energy, while the knowledge most groups need stays local and transfers poorly. | [IC] |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | E1 | 23 countries; mainly Global North | Surveys 276 active and inactive Transition initiatives in 23 countries and finds less successful ones may underestimate context and material resources. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovation Movements | Adrian Smith, Mariano Fressoli, Dinesh Abrol, Elisa Arond and Adrian Ely | 2017 | E3 | United Kingdom, South America, India, Brazil; mixed | Examines six grassroots innovation movements in Europe, South America and India, and how each made space for alternatives and met more powerful actors. | [IC] |
| Niche type institutional11 | ||||||
| Beyond Incubation: An Analysis of Firm Survival and Exit Dynamics in the Post-Graduation Period | Michael Schwartz | 2009 | E1 | Germany; Global North | Follows 352 graduates of five German incubators and finds that leaving the incubator brings a drop in survival lasting up to three years. | [IC] |
| Transition Management for Sustainable Development: A Prescriptive, Complexity-Based Governance Framework | Derk Loorbach | 2010 | E5 | Netherlands; Global North | Sets out transition management: arenas, agendas, experiments and reflexive evaluation, drawn from the Dutch national energy transition programme. | [IC] |
| Incubating an Illusion? Long-Term Incubator Firm Performance After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2011 | E1 | Germany; Global North | Follows 324 graduates of five German incubators and finds early growth after graduation, with no continued growth for most firms. | [IC] |
| Incubation Time, Incubator Age, and Firm Survival After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2012 | E1 | Germany; Global North | Finds, for 149 graduates of five German incubators, that longer incubation and older incubators both lower survival after graduation. | [IC] |
| A Control Group Study of Incubators' Impact to Promote Firm Survival | Michael Schwartz | 2013 | E1 | Germany; urban; Global North | Matches 371 incubator graduates with 371 similar firms over ten years and finds no incubator that raised survival; three lowered it. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? | Rosalind Eyben (ed.), Irene Guijt (ed.), Chris Roche (ed.) and Cathy Shutt (ed.) | 2015 | E5 | International; Global South | Practitioners' accounts of how demands for results and evidence in aid shape programmes, and how staff comply, adapt or resist. | [IC] |
| A Review of the Local Community Development Requirements in South Africa's Renewable Energy Procurement Programme | Holle Linnea Wlokas | 2015 | E3 | South Africa; rural; Global South | Reviews the community development rules in South Africa's renewable energy procurement programme and finds communities treated mostly as beneficiaries. | [IC] |
| Towards a Framework to Guide the Evaluation of Inclusive Innovation Systems | L. Botha, Sara Grobbelaar and Wouter Bam | 2016 | E4 | South Africa; Global South | Proposes a framework for evaluating inclusive innovation systems in South Africa. | [IC] |
| University-Driven Inclusive Innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa: Towards a Research Framework of Innovation Regimes | Sara Grobbelaar, Robert Tijssen and Marjolijn Dijksterhuis | 2017 | E3 | South Africa (Western Cape); Global South | Studies 15 university-driven inclusive innovation activities in the Western Cape and proposes a framework of innovation regimes for them. | [IC] |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | E1 | International; mixed | Pools 39 studies of 55,219 firms and finds incubation helps innovation and growth more clearly than survival. | [IC] |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | E1 | International; mixed | Pools 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and finds a positive overall effect of incubation, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region. | [IC] |
| Work | Author | Year | Niche type | Setting | Finding | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation | Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan | 1999 | mixed | Mainly United States; Global North | Reviews 128 experiments and finds tangible, task-linked rewards reduce intrinsic motivation, while positive feedback tends to raise it. | [IC] |
| Beyond Incubation: An Analysis of Firm Survival and Exit Dynamics in the Post-Graduation Period | Michael Schwartz | 2009 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 352 graduates of five German incubators and finds that leaving the incubator brings a drop in survival lasting up to three years. | [IC] |
| Incubating an Illusion? Long-Term Incubator Firm Performance After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2011 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Follows 324 graduates of five German incubators and finds early growth after graduation, with no continued growth for most firms. | [IC] |
| Incubation Time, Incubator Age, and Firm Survival After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2012 | institutional | Germany; Global North | Finds, for 149 graduates of five German incubators, that longer incubation and older incubators both lower survival after graduation. | [IC] |
| A Control Group Study of Incubators' Impact to Promote Firm Survival | Michael Schwartz | 2013 | institutional | Germany; urban; Global North | Matches 371 incubator graduates with 371 similar firms over ten years and finds no incubator that raised survival; three lowered it. | [IC] |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | grassroots | 23 countries; mainly Global North | Surveys 276 active and inactive Transition initiatives in 23 countries and finds less successful ones may underestimate context and material resources. | [IC] |
| Estimating the Reproducibility of Psychological Science | Open Science Collaboration | 2015 | mixed | International; Global North | Replicates 100 psychology studies and finds 36 per cent of replications statistically significant, with effects about half the original size. | [IC] |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 39 studies of 55,219 firms and finds incubation helps innovation and growth more clearly than survival. | [IC] |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and finds a positive overall effect of incubation, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region. | [IC] |
| Work | Author | Year | Design | Niche type | Setting | Finding | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Building Sustainable Neighbourhoods in South Africa: Learning from the Lynedoch Case | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2006 | E5 | grassroots | South Africa; peri-urban; Global South | The co-founders' account of Lynedoch EcoVillage, which they describe as South Africa's first socially mixed, ecologically designed intentional community. | [MS] |
| The Politics of Social-Ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith and Andy Stirling | 2010 | E4 | mixed | General | Argues that resilience and transitions research both tend to close down governance around expert framings, and calls for opening it up. | [IC] |
| Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use | Michael Quinn Patton | 2011 | E4 | mixed | General | Proposes evaluation that supports innovations in complex, changing settings, where the evaluator helps the work adapt and goals may change. | [IC] |
| Socio-Technical Regimes and Sustainability Transitions: Insights from Political Ecology | Mary Lawhon and James T. Murphy | 2012 | E4 | mixed | General | Names four limitations of socio-technical transitions research and draws on political ecology to address them, with a case on genetically modified crops. | [IC] |
| Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2012 | E5 | grassroots | South Africa; Global South | Reads sustainability transitions from the Global South; Chapter 10, by the co-founders of Lynedoch EcoVillage and the Sustainability Institute, reflects on that work. | [IC] |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | E1 | grassroots | 23 countries; mainly Global North | Surveys 276 active and inactive Transition initiatives in 23 countries and finds less successful ones may underestimate context and material resources. | [IC] |
| The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? | Rosalind Eyben (ed.), Irene Guijt (ed.), Chris Roche (ed.) and Cathy Shutt (ed.) | 2015 | E5 | institutional | International; Global South | Practitioners' accounts of how demands for results and evidence in aid shape programmes, and how staff comply, adapt or resist. | [IC] |
| A Review of the Local Community Development Requirements in South Africa's Renewable Energy Procurement Programme | Holle Linnea Wlokas | 2015 | E3 | institutional | South Africa; rural; Global South | Reviews the community development rules in South Africa's renewable energy procurement programme and finds communities treated mostly as beneficiaries. | [IC] |
| Towards a Framework to Guide the Evaluation of Inclusive Innovation Systems | L. Botha, Sara Grobbelaar and Wouter Bam | 2016 | E4 | institutional | South Africa; Global South | Proposes a framework for evaluating inclusive innovation systems in South Africa. | [IC] |
| University-Driven Inclusive Innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa: Towards a Research Framework of Innovation Regimes | Sara Grobbelaar, Robert Tijssen and Marjolijn Dijksterhuis | 2017 | E3 | institutional | South Africa (Western Cape); Global South | Studies 15 university-driven inclusive innovation activities in the Western Cape and proposes a framework of innovation regimes for them. | [IC] |
| Grassroots Innovation Movements | Adrian Smith, Mariano Fressoli, Dinesh Abrol, Elisa Arond and Adrian Ely | 2017 | E3 | grassroots | United Kingdom, South America, India, Brazil; mixed | Examines six grassroots innovation movements in Europe, South America and India, and how each made space for alternatives and met more powerful actors. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Stocktaking, New Contributions and a Research Agenda | Ulrich Elmer Hansen and others | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Editors' introduction arguing that transitions frameworks need adapting to high inequality and informality in developing countries. | [IC] |
| Designing Transformative Spaces for Sustainability in Social-Ecological Systems | Laura Pereira, Timothy Karpouzoglou, Niki Frantzeskaki and Per Olsson | 2018 | E4 | mixed | General | Proposes transformative spaces: convened collaborative settings in which people experiment with new social-ecological arrangements. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in the Developing World: Challenges of Socio-Technical Transformations Unfolding in Contexts of Poverty | Mónica Ramos-Mejía, Maria-Laura Franco-Garcia and Juan M. Jauregui-Becker | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Describes how socio-technical transformations unfold in contexts of poverty, and what that asks of transitions theory. | [IC] |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Major Insights and Their Implications for Research and Policy | Anna J. Wieczorek | 2018 | E4 | mixed | Developing countries; Global South | Reviews transitions studies of developing countries and finds regimes there less uniform, with some regime stability possibly helping niches form. | [IC] |
| Experimenting for Sustainability Transitions: A Systematic Literature Review | Frans Sengers, Anna J. Wieczorek and Rob Raven | 2019 | E4 | mixed | Global | Reviews the transitions literature on experiments and distinguishes five kinds, each with its own theory and focus. | [IC] |
| Transformative Spaces in the Making: Key Lessons from Nine Cases in the Global South | Laura Pereira and fourteen co-authors | 2020 | E5 | mixed | Southern Africa, Latin America and Asia; Global South | Synthesises nine convened transformative spaces, mainly in the Global South and including Southern African work, into five design lessons. | [IC] |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | E1 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 39 studies of 55,219 firms and finds incubation helps innovation and growth more clearly than survival. | [IC] |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | E1 | institutional | International; mixed | Pools 22 studies and 65 effect sizes and finds a positive overall effect of incubation, moderated by specialisation, public sponsorship and region. | [IC] |
| Work | Author | Year | Type | Publisher or journal | DOI | Subject |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Control Group Study of Incubators' Impact to Promote Firm Survival | Michael Schwartz | 2013 | journal-article | Journal of Technology Transfer 38(3), 302-331 | 10.1007/s10961-012-9254-y | economics |
| A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation | Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan | 1999 | journal-article | Psychological Bulletin 125(6), 627-668 | 10.1037/0033-2909.125.6.627 | consciousness, coordination |
| A Review of the Local Community Development Requirements in South Africa's Renewable Energy Procurement Programme | Holle Linnea Wlokas | 2015 | report | WWF-SA Technical Report, Cape Town | — | economics, coordination |
| Beyond Incubation: An Analysis of Firm Survival and Exit Dynamics in the Post-Graduation Period | Michael Schwartz | 2009 | journal-article | Journal of Technology Transfer 34(4), 403-421 | 10.1007/s10961-008-9095-x | economics |
| Building Sustainable Neighbourhoods in South Africa: Learning from the Lynedoch Case | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2006 | journal-article | Environment and Urbanization 18(2), 315-332 | 10.1177/0956247806069606 | civilization, restoration |
| Designing Transformative Spaces for Sustainability in Social-Ecological Systems | Laura Pereira, Timothy Karpouzoglou, Niki Frantzeskaki and Per Olsson | 2018 | journal-article | Ecology and Society 23(4): 32 | 10.5751/ES-10607-230432 | civilization, coordination |
| Developmental Evaluation: Applying Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use | Michael Quinn Patton | 2011 | book | Guilford Press, New York | — | coordination |
| Do Startup Incubators Enhance New Venture Performance? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis | Nikolaus Seitz, Martina Buratti, Erik E. Lehmann and Niklas Eberle | 2026 | journal-article | Review of Managerial Science 20, 4693-4745 | — | economics |
| Estimating the Reproducibility of Psychological Science | Open Science Collaboration | 2015 | journal-article | Science 349(6251), aac4716 | 10.1126/science.aac4716 | coordination |
| Experimenting for Sustainability Transitions: A Systematic Literature Review | Frans Sengers, Anna J. Wieczorek and Rob Raven | 2019 | journal-article | Technological Forecasting and Social Change 145, 153-164 | 10.1016/j.techfore.2016.08.031 | civilization |
| Grassroots Innovation Movements | Adrian Smith, Mariano Fressoli, Dinesh Abrol, Elisa Arond and Adrian Ely | 2017 | book | Routledge (Pathways to Sustainability series) | 10.4324/9781315697888 | civilization, commons, political-ecology |
| Grassroots Innovations for Sustainable Development: Towards a New Research and Policy Agenda | Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2007 | journal-article | Environmental Politics 16(4), 584-603 | 10.1080/09644010701419121 | civilization, commons |
| Grassroots Innovations in Community Energy: The Role of Intermediaries in Niche Development | Tom Hargreaves, Sabine Hielscher, Gill Seyfang and Adrian Smith | 2013 | journal-article | Global Environmental Change 23(5), 868-880 | 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.02.008 | civilization, coordination |
| Growing Grassroots Innovations: Exploring the Role of Community-Based Initiatives in Governing Sustainable Energy Transitions | Gill Seyfang and Alex Haxeltine | 2012 | journal-article | Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 30(3), 381-400 | 10.1068/c10222 | civilization, coordination |
| Hatching and Fledging? A Meta-Analysis of the Performance Effects of Business Incubators | Jorge-Vinicio Murillo-Rojas, Jan Brinckmann and Marc van Essen | 2026 | journal-article | Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal (published online 12 June 2026) | 10.1002/sej.70032 | economics |
| Incubating an Illusion? Long-Term Incubator Firm Performance After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2011 | journal-article | Growth and Change 42(4), 491-516 | 10.1111/j.1468-2257.2011.00565.x | economics |
| Incubation Time, Incubator Age, and Firm Survival After Graduation | Michael Schwartz | 2012 | journal-article | International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation Management 15(1/2), 108-130 | — | economics |
| Just Transitions: Explorations of Sustainability in an Unfair World | Mark Swilling and Eve Annecke | 2012 | book | UCT Press and United Nations University Press | — | civilization, economics |
| Niche Construction and Empowerment Through Socio-Political Work: A Meta-Analysis of Six Low-Carbon Technology Cases | Rob Raven, Florian Kern, Bram Verhees and Adrian Smith | 2016 | journal-article | Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 18, 164-180 | 10.1016/j.eist.2015.02.002 | civilization, coordination |
| Ontological Shielding in New-paradigm Research | Charles Eisenstein | 2026 | essay | Substack, 8 February 2026 | — | consciousness |
| Reflexive Monitoring in Action: A Guide for Monitoring System Innovation Projects | Barbara van Mierlo, Barbara Regeer, Mariette van Amstel, Marleen Arkesteijn, Volkert Beekman, Joske Bunders, Tjard de Cock Buning, Boelie Elzen, Anne-Charlotte Hoes and Cees Leeuwis | 2010 | report | Wageningen University and Research and VU University Amsterdam | — | coordination |
| Regime Resistance Against Low-Carbon Transitions: Introducing Politics and Power into the Multi-Level Perspective | Frank W. Geels | 2014 | journal-article | Theory, Culture and Society 31(5), 21-40 | 10.1177/0263276414531627 | civilization, coordination |
| Regime Shifts to Sustainability Through Processes of Niche Formation: The Approach of Strategic Niche Management | René Kemp, Johan Schot and Remco Hoogma | 1998 | journal-article | Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 10(2), 175-198 | 10.1080/09537329808524310 | civilization, coordination |
| Socio-Technical Regimes and Sustainability Transitions: Insights from Political Ecology | Mary Lawhon and James T. Murphy | 2012 | journal-article | Progress in Human Geography 36(3), 354-378 | 10.1177/0309132511427960 | political-ecology, coordination |
| Strategic Niche Management and Sustainable Innovation Journeys: Theory, Findings, Research Agenda, and Policy | Johan Schot and Frank W. Geels | 2008 | journal-article | Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 20(5), 537-554 | 10.1080/09537320802292651 | civilization |
| Success and Failure of Grassroots Innovations for Addressing Climate Change: The Case of the Transition Movement | Giuseppe Feola and Richard Nunes | 2014 | journal-article | Global Environmental Change 24, 232-250 | 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.11.011 | civilization, coordination |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Major Insights and Their Implications for Research and Policy | Anna J. Wieczorek | 2018 | journal-article | Environmental Science and Policy 84, 204-216 | 10.1016/j.envsci.2017.08.008 | civilization, economics |
| Sustainability Transitions in Developing Countries: Stocktaking, New Contributions and a Research Agenda | Ulrich Elmer Hansen and others | 2018 | journal-article | Environmental Science and Policy 84, 198-203 | 10.1016/j.envsci.2017.11.009 | civilization, economics |
| Sustainability Transitions in the Developing World: Challenges of Socio-Technical Transformations Unfolding in Contexts of Poverty | Mónica Ramos-Mejía, Maria-Laura Franco-Garcia and Juan M. Jauregui-Becker | 2018 | journal-article | Environmental Science and Policy 84, 217-223 | 10.1016/j.envsci.2017.03.010 | civilization, economics |
| Technological Transitions as Evolutionary Reconfiguration Processes: A Multi-Level Perspective and a Case-Study | Frank W. Geels | 2002 | journal-article | Research Policy 31(8-9), 1257-1274 | 10.1016/S0048-7333(02)00062-8 | civilization |
| The Development of Solar PV in The Netherlands: A Case of Survival in Unfriendly Contexts | Bram Verhees, Rob Raven, Frank Veraart, Adrian Smith and Florian Kern | 2013 | journal-article | Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 19, 275-289 | 10.1016/j.rser.2012.11.011 | civilization |
| The Governance of Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith, Andy Stirling and Frans Berkhout | 2005 | journal-article | Research Policy 34(10), 1491-1510 | 10.1016/j.respol.2005.07.005 | coordination |
| The Politics of Evidence and Results in International Development: Playing the Game to Change the Rules? | Rosalind Eyben (ed.), Irene Guijt (ed.), Chris Roche (ed.) and Cathy Shutt (ed.) | 2015 | book | Practical Action Publishing, Rugby | — | coordination, economics |
| The Politics of Social-Ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-Technical Transitions | Adrian Smith and Andy Stirling | 2010 | journal-article | Ecology and Society 15(1): 11 | 10.5751/ES-03218-150111 | coordination, political-ecology |
| Three Horizons: A Pathways Practice for Transformation | Bill Sharpe, Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester, Andrew Lyon and Ioan Fazey | 2016 | journal-article | Ecology and Society 21(2): 47 | 10.5751/ES-08388-210247 | civilization, coordination |
| Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope | Bill Sharpe | 2013 | book | Triarchy Press (second edition 2020) | — | civilization, consciousness |
| Towards a Framework to Guide the Evaluation of Inclusive Innovation Systems | L. Botha, Sara Grobbelaar and Wouter Bam | 2016 | journal-article | South African Journal of Industrial Engineering 27(3), 64-78 | — | economics, coordination |
| Transformative Spaces in the Making: Key Lessons from Nine Cases in the Global South | Laura Pereira and fourteen co-authors | 2020 | journal-article | Sustainability Science 15, 161-178 | 10.1007/s11625-019-00749-x | civilization, coordination |
| Transition Management for Sustainable Development: A Prescriptive, Complexity-Based Governance Framework | Derk Loorbach | 2010 | journal-article | Governance 23(1), 161-183 | 10.1111/j.1468-0491.2009.01471.x | coordination |
| Typology of Sociotechnical Transition Pathways | Frank W. Geels and Johan Schot | 2007 | journal-article | Research Policy 36(3), 399-417 | 10.1016/j.respol.2007.01.003 | civilization |
| University-Driven Inclusive Innovations in the Western Cape of South Africa: Towards a Research Framework of Innovation Regimes | Sara Grobbelaar, Robert Tijssen and Marjolijn Dijksterhuis | 2017 | journal-article | African Journal of Science, Technology, Innovation and Development 9(1), 7-19 | — | economics, coordination |
| What Is Protective Space? Reconsidering Niches in Transitions to Sustainability | Adrian Smith and Rob Raven | 2012 | journal-article | Research Policy 41(6), 1025-1036 | 10.1016/j.respol.2011.12.012 | civilization, coordination |