| Case | Country | Years | Backing | Backed, anchored or themed | Economy evidence | Resource evidence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resource group grain-and-commodities7 | |||||||
| ACE Warehouse Receipts, Malawi | Malawi | 2011 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ethiopia Commodity Exchange Receipts | Ethiopia | 2003 law; finance initiative from 2009; national system 2026 | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ghana Grains Council Warehouse Receipts | Ghana | 2008 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | 3rd c. BCE (claimed) | K1 (claimed) | backed (claimed) | none | n/a | [TBV] |
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | 2004 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Tanzania Warehouse Receipt System | Tanzania | 1998 pilot; 2005 Act to running | K1 | backed | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Virginia Tobacco Notes | USA, Virginia | 1730 to 1775, reinstated 1776 | K1 | backed | E4 | none | [IC] |
| Resource group land3 | |||||||
| Assignats | France | 1789 to 1796 | K2, then fiat | backed, then fiat | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | 1796 to 1797 | K2 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | 1740 to 1741 | K2 (secured, not redeemable) | backed (claimed) | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Resource group no-resource-backing13 | |||||||
| Banco Palmas and the Palma | Brazil, Fortaleza | 1998 to running | K6 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Bristol Pound | UK, Bristol | 2012 to 2021 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Chiemgauer | Germany, Bavaria | 2003 to running | K6 | none | E3 | n/a | [MS] |
| Community Exchange System | South Africa, Cape Town | 2003 to running | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Fureai Kippu | Japan | 1973 to running | K7 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | 1991 to 2010s | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| K'Mali | South Africa, Kokstad | 2010s | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Sarafu Community Inclusion Currency | Kenya | 2017 to running | K7, K6 partial | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Sardex | Italy, Sardinia | 2009 to running | K7 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | 1932 to 1933 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| WÄRA | Germany | 1926 to 1931 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| WIR Bank | Switzerland | 1934 to running | K7 | none | E2 | n/a | [IC] |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | 1932 to 1933 | K6+K3 | none | E3 | n/a | [IC] |
| Resource group ecological-work3 | |||||||
| Bangla-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | 2013 to running | K7+K3 | themed | E3 | n/a | [IC] |
| Eco-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | 2010 to 2011 | K6+K3 | themed | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Grassroots Economics Commitment Pools | Kenya, Kilifi | 2023 to running (Kiriba pools from 2025) | K7+K3, K6 partial | themed | E5 | none | [MS] |
| Resource group carbon-and-nature-tokens3 | |||||||
| KlimaDAO | global | 2021 to running | K6 (BCT reserve)+K5 | anchored to modeled credits | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Regen Network Ecocredits | global | 2021 to running | K5+K4 | anchored to monitored or modeled change | E4 | E5 | [MS] |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | 2021 to 2022 mechanism | K1+K5 | backed by claims on modeled credits | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Years | Backing | Backed, anchored or themed | Economy evidence | Resource evidence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dominant backing K18 | |||||||
| ACE Warehouse Receipts, Malawi | Malawi | 2011 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ethiopia Commodity Exchange Receipts | Ethiopia | 2003 law; finance initiative from 2009; national system 2026 | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ghana Grains Council Warehouse Receipts | Ghana | 2008 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | 3rd c. BCE (claimed) | K1 (claimed) | backed (claimed) | none | n/a | [TBV] |
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | 2004 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Tanzania Warehouse Receipt System | Tanzania | 1998 pilot; 2005 Act to running | K1 | backed | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | 2021 to 2022 mechanism | K1+K5 | backed by claims on modeled credits | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Virginia Tobacco Notes | USA, Virginia | 1730 to 1775, reinstated 1776 | K1 | backed | E4 | none | [IC] |
| Dominant backing K23 | |||||||
| Assignats | France | 1789 to 1796 | K2, then fiat | backed, then fiat | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | 1796 to 1797 | K2 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | 1740 to 1741 | K2 (secured, not redeemable) | backed (claimed) | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Dominant backing K68 | |||||||
| Banco Palmas and the Palma | Brazil, Fortaleza | 1998 to running | K6 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Bristol Pound | UK, Bristol | 2012 to 2021 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Chiemgauer | Germany, Bavaria | 2003 to running | K6 | none | E3 | n/a | [MS] |
| Eco-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | 2010 to 2011 | K6+K3 | themed | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| KlimaDAO | global | 2021 to running | K6 (BCT reserve)+K5 | anchored to modeled credits | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | 1932 to 1933 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| WÄRA | Germany | 1926 to 1931 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | 1932 to 1933 | K6+K3 | none | E3 | n/a | [IC] |
| Dominant backing K79 | |||||||
| Bangla-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | 2013 to running | K7+K3 | themed | E3 | n/a | [IC] |
| Community Exchange System | South Africa, Cape Town | 2003 to running | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Fureai Kippu | Japan | 1973 to running | K7 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Grassroots Economics Commitment Pools | Kenya, Kilifi | 2023 to running (Kiriba pools from 2025) | K7+K3, K6 partial | themed | E5 | none | [MS] |
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | 1991 to 2010s | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| K'Mali | South Africa, Kokstad | 2010s | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Sarafu Community Inclusion Currency | Kenya | 2017 to running | K7, K6 partial | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Sardex | Italy, Sardinia | 2009 to running | K7 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| WIR Bank | Switzerland | 1934 to running | K7 | none | E2 | n/a | [IC] |
| Dominant backing K51 | |||||||
| Regen Network Ecocredits | global | 2021 to running | K5+K4 | anchored to monitored or modeled change | E4 | E5 | [MS] |
| Case | Country | Years | Backing | Backed, anchored or themed | Economy evidence | Resource evidence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Backed, anchored or themed backed7 | |||||||
| ACE Warehouse Receipts, Malawi | Malawi | 2011 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ethiopia Commodity Exchange Receipts | Ethiopia | 2003 law; finance initiative from 2009; national system 2026 | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ghana Grains Council Warehouse Receipts | Ghana | 2008 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | 1796 to 1797 | K2 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | 2004 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Tanzania Warehouse Receipt System | Tanzania | 1998 pilot; 2005 Act to running | K1 | backed | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Virginia Tobacco Notes | USA, Virginia | 1730 to 1775, reinstated 1776 | K1 | backed | E4 | none | [IC] |
| Backed, anchored or themed backed, then fiat1 | |||||||
| Assignats | France | 1789 to 1796 | K2, then fiat | backed, then fiat | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Backed, anchored or themed none13 | |||||||
| Banco Palmas and the Palma | Brazil, Fortaleza | 1998 to running | K6 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Bristol Pound | UK, Bristol | 2012 to 2021 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Chiemgauer | Germany, Bavaria | 2003 to running | K6 | none | E3 | n/a | [MS] |
| Community Exchange System | South Africa, Cape Town | 2003 to running | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Fureai Kippu | Japan | 1973 to running | K7 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | 1991 to 2010s | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| K'Mali | South Africa, Kokstad | 2010s | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Sarafu Community Inclusion Currency | Kenya | 2017 to running | K7, K6 partial | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Sardex | Italy, Sardinia | 2009 to running | K7 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | 1932 to 1933 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| WÄRA | Germany | 1926 to 1931 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| WIR Bank | Switzerland | 1934 to running | K7 | none | E2 | n/a | [IC] |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | 1932 to 1933 | K6+K3 | none | E3 | n/a | [IC] |
| Backed, anchored or themed themed3 | |||||||
| Bangla-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | 2013 to running | K7+K3 | themed | E3 | n/a | [IC] |
| Eco-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | 2010 to 2011 | K6+K3 | themed | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Grassroots Economics Commitment Pools | Kenya, Kilifi | 2023 to running (Kiriba pools from 2025) | K7+K3, K6 partial | themed | E5 | none | [MS] |
| Backed, anchored or themed anchored to modeled credits1 | |||||||
| KlimaDAO | global | 2021 to running | K6 (BCT reserve)+K5 | anchored to modeled credits | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Backed, anchored or themed backed (claimed)2 | |||||||
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | 1740 to 1741 | K2 (secured, not redeemable) | backed (claimed) | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | 3rd c. BCE (claimed) | K1 (claimed) | backed (claimed) | none | n/a | [TBV] |
| Backed, anchored or themed anchored to monitored or modeled change1 | |||||||
| Regen Network Ecocredits | global | 2021 to running | K5+K4 | anchored to monitored or modeled change | E4 | E5 | [MS] |
| Backed, anchored or themed backed by claims on modeled credits1 | |||||||
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | 2021 to 2022 mechanism | K1+K5 | backed by claims on modeled credits | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Years | Backing | Backed, anchored or themed | Economy evidence | Resource evidence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Continent Africa12 | |||||||
| ACE Warehouse Receipts, Malawi | Malawi | 2011 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Bangla-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | 2013 to running | K7+K3 | themed | E3 | n/a | [IC] |
| Community Exchange System | South Africa, Cape Town | 2003 to running | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Eco-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | 2010 to 2011 | K6+K3 | themed | E3 | E5 | [MS] |
| Ethiopia Commodity Exchange Receipts | Ethiopia | 2003 law; finance initiative from 2009; national system 2026 | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Ghana Grains Council Warehouse Receipts | Ghana | 2008 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Grassroots Economics Commitment Pools | Kenya, Kilifi | 2023 to running (Kiriba pools from 2025) | K7+K3, K6 partial | themed | E5 | none | [MS] |
| K'Mali | South Africa, Kokstad | 2010s | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | 3rd c. BCE (claimed) | K1 (claimed) | backed (claimed) | none | n/a | [TBV] |
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | 2004 to running | K1 | backed | E4 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Sarafu Community Inclusion Currency | Kenya | 2017 to running | K7, K6 partial | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Tanzania Warehouse Receipt System | Tanzania | 1998 pilot; 2005 Act to running | K1 | backed | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Continent Europe8 | |||||||
| Assignats | France | 1789 to 1796 | K2, then fiat | backed, then fiat | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Bristol Pound | UK, Bristol | 2012 to 2021 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Chiemgauer | Germany, Bavaria | 2003 to running | K6 | none | E3 | n/a | [MS] |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | 1796 to 1797 | K2 | backed | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Sardex | Italy, Sardinia | 2009 to running | K7 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| WÄRA | Germany | 1926 to 1931 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| WIR Bank | Switzerland | 1934 to running | K7 | none | E2 | n/a | [IC] |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | 1932 to 1933 | K6+K3 | none | E3 | n/a | [IC] |
| Continent South America1 | |||||||
| Banco Palmas and the Palma | Brazil, Fortaleza | 1998 to running | K6 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Continent Asia1 | |||||||
| Fureai Kippu | Japan | 1973 to running | K7 | none | E4 | n/a | [IC] |
| Continent North America4 | |||||||
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | 1991 to 2010s | K7 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | 1740 to 1741 | K2 (secured, not redeemable) | backed (claimed) | E5 | n/a | [IC] |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | 1932 to 1933 | K6 | none | E5 | n/a | [TBV] |
| Virginia Tobacco Notes | USA, Virginia | 1730 to 1775, reinstated 1776 | K1 | backed | E4 | none | [IC] |
| Continent Global3 | |||||||
| KlimaDAO | global | 2021 to running | K6 (BCT reserve)+K5 | anchored to modeled credits | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Regen Network Ecocredits | global | 2021 to running | K5+K4 | anchored to monitored or modeled change | E4 | E5 | [MS] |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | 2021 to 2022 mechanism | K1+K5 | backed by claims on modeled credits | E4 | E4 | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Backing | Issuer | Holding cost | Persistence | Failure or capture | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Issuer exchange2 | |||||||
| ACE Warehouse Receipts, Malawi | Malawi | K1 | exchange | storage fees | running since 2011 | used mainly by large traders; borrowing against receipts loss-making for maize | [IC] |
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | K1 | exchange | fees | running | none recorded | [TBV] |
| Issuer state4 | |||||||
| Assignats | France | K2, then fiat | state | inflation by over-issue | 7 yrs | over-issue beyond land | [IC] |
| Ethiopia Commodity Exchange Receipts | Ethiopia | K1 | state | fees | running; national system from 2026 | state-run warehouses | [IC] |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | K2 | state | inflation | <1 yr | no trust after the assignats; rapid devaluation | [IC] |
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | K1 (claimed) | state | storage charge claimed | unknown | unknown | [TBV] |
| Issuer community bank1 | |||||||
| Banco Palmas and the Palma | Brazil, Fortaleza | K6 | community bank | none | 26 yrs | Central Bank suit, won by Melo; date reported as 2003 or before 2000 | [IC] |
| Issuer NGO, business network1 | |||||||
| Bangla-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | K7+K3 | NGO, business network | none | 13 yrs; banned May 2013, relaunched November 2013 | 2013 arrests | [IC] |
| Issuer CIC, credit union1 | |||||||
| Bristol Pound | UK, Bristol | K6 | CIC, credit union | none | 9 yrs | funding ran out; shift to contactless and away from cash | [IC] |
| Issuer association4 | |||||||
| Chiemgauer | Germany, Bavaria | K6 | association | demurrage 6%/yr (8% to 2015) | 23 yrs | none | [MS] |
| Ghana Grains Council Warehouse Receipts | Ghana | K1 | association | storage fees | running | serves larger traders | [IC] |
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | K7 | association | none | ~20 yrs | decline after the founder left and the shift to cards | [TBV] |
| WÄRA | Germany | K6 | association | demurrage 1%/month | ~5 yrs | forbidden by the Reich finance ministry, 30 October 1931 | [IC] |
| Issuer nonprofit company1 | |||||||
| Community Exchange System | South Africa, Cape Town | K7 | nonprofit company | none | 23 yrs | none recorded | [TBV] |
| Issuer NGO3 | |||||||
| Eco-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | K6+K3 | NGO | 20% fee first month | ~1 yr | donor funds redeemed | [MS] |
| Fureai Kippu | Japan | K7 | NGO | none | over 50 yrs; stalled after 2000 | displaced in part by statutory long-term care insurance from 2000 | [IC] |
| Sarafu Community Inclusion Currency | Kenya | K7, K6 partial | NGO | expiry and reclamation | 9 yrs | issuer penalties on inactive accounts, 19 October 2020 | [IC] |
| Issuer NGO, community1 | |||||||
| Grassroots Economics Commitment Pools | Kenya, Kilifi | K7+K3, K6 partial | NGO, community | none | about 3 yrs on Celo | donor dependence | [MS] |
| Issuer community, NGO advice1 | |||||||
| K'Mali | South Africa, Kokstad | K7 | community, NGO advice | unknown | unknown | unknown | [TBV] |
| Issuer DAO1 | |||||||
| KlimaDAO | global | K6 (BCT reserve)+K5 | DAO | inflation by staking | running, reduced | speculation | [IC] |
| Issuer company of subscribers1 | |||||||
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | K2 (secured, not redeemable) | company of subscribers | unknown | 1 yr | suppressed by colonial authorities; partners pursued for debts | [IC] |
| Issuer protocol2 | |||||||
| Regen Network Ecocredits | global | K5+K4 | protocol | none | running | soil-carbon credit calculations questioned (2021); same entities in several roles on one project | [MS] |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | K1+K5 | protocol | none | ~7 months | Verra ban 25 May 2022 | [IC] |
| Issuer company1 | |||||||
| Sardex | Italy, Sardinia | K7 | company | none; yearly membership fee | 17 yrs | none recorded | [IC] |
| Issuer municipality2 | |||||||
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | K6 | municipality | stamp demurrage, 2 cents a week on dated scrip | ~1 yr | effort exceeded results; faded as other money returned | [TBV] |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | K6+K3 | municipality | 1%/month demurrage | 14 months | opposed by the state bank; issue suspended May 1933; ended by the Administrative Court in 1933 | [IC] |
| Issuer public-private licensing board1 | |||||||
| Tanzania Warehouse Receipt System | Tanzania | K1 | public-private licensing board | fees | running | none recorded | [IC] |
| Issuer colonial state1 | |||||||
| Virginia Tobacco Notes | USA, Virginia | K1 | colonial state | none recorded | ~25 yrs as money | replaced by paper money 1750s | [IC] |
| Issuer cooperative bank1 | |||||||
| WIR Bank | Switzerland | K7 | cooperative bank | none since 1948; interest on large overdrafts | 92 yrs | none | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Backing | Issuer | Holding cost | Persistence | Failure or capture | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chiemgauer | Germany, Bavaria | K6 | association | demurrage 6%/yr (8% to 2015) | 23 yrs | none | [MS] |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | K6 | municipality | stamp demurrage, 2 cents a week on dated scrip | ~1 yr | effort exceeded results; faded as other money returned | [TBV] |
| WÄRA | Germany | K6 | association | demurrage 1%/month | ~5 yrs | forbidden by the Reich finance ministry, 30 October 1931 | [IC] |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | K6+K3 | municipality | 1%/month demurrage | 14 months | opposed by the state bank; issue suspended May 1933; ended by the Administrative Court in 1933 | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Backing | Issuer | Holding cost | Persistence | Failure or capture | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ACE Warehouse Receipts, Malawi | Malawi | K1 | exchange | storage fees | running since 2011 | used mainly by large traders; borrowing against receipts loss-making for maize | [IC] |
| Assignats | France | K2, then fiat | state | inflation by over-issue | 7 yrs | over-issue beyond land | [IC] |
| Ethiopia Commodity Exchange Receipts | Ethiopia | K1 | state | fees | running; national system from 2026 | state-run warehouses | [IC] |
| Ghana Grains Council Warehouse Receipts | Ghana | K1 | association | storage fees | running | serves larger traders | [IC] |
| KlimaDAO | global | K6 (BCT reserve)+K5 | DAO | inflation by staking | running, reduced | speculation | [IC] |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | K2 | state | inflation | <1 yr | no trust after the assignats; rapid devaluation | [IC] |
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | K2 (secured, not redeemable) | company of subscribers | unknown | 1 yr | suppressed by colonial authorities; partners pursued for debts | [IC] |
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | K1 (claimed) | state | storage charge claimed | unknown | unknown | [TBV] |
| Regen Network Ecocredits | global | K5+K4 | protocol | none | running | soil-carbon credit calculations questioned (2021); same entities in several roles on one project | [MS] |
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | K1 | exchange | fees | running | none recorded | [TBV] |
| Tanzania Warehouse Receipt System | Tanzania | K1 | public-private licensing board | fees | running | none recorded | [IC] |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | K1+K5 | protocol | none | ~7 months | Verra ban 25 May 2022 | [IC] |
| Virginia Tobacco Notes | USA, Virginia | K1 | colonial state | none recorded | ~25 yrs as money | replaced by paper money 1750s | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Backing | Issuer | Holding cost | Persistence | Failure or capture | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resource group land3 | |||||||
| Assignats | France | K2, then fiat | state | inflation by over-issue | 7 yrs | over-issue beyond land | [IC] |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | K2 | state | inflation | <1 yr | no trust after the assignats; rapid devaluation | [IC] |
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | K2 (secured, not redeemable) | company of subscribers | unknown | 1 yr | suppressed by colonial authorities; partners pursued for debts | [IC] |
| Resource group no-resource-backing5 | |||||||
| Bristol Pound | UK, Bristol | K6 | CIC, credit union | none | 9 yrs | funding ran out; shift to contactless and away from cash | [IC] |
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | K7 | association | none | ~20 yrs | decline after the founder left and the shift to cards | [TBV] |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | K6 | municipality | stamp demurrage, 2 cents a week on dated scrip | ~1 yr | effort exceeded results; faded as other money returned | [TBV] |
| WÄRA | Germany | K6 | association | demurrage 1%/month | ~5 yrs | forbidden by the Reich finance ministry, 30 October 1931 | [IC] |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | K6+K3 | municipality | 1%/month demurrage | 14 months | opposed by the state bank; issue suspended May 1933; ended by the Administrative Court in 1933 | [IC] |
| Resource group ecological-work1 | |||||||
| Eco-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | K6+K3 | NGO | 20% fee first month | ~1 yr | donor funds redeemed | [MS] |
| Resource group carbon-and-nature-tokens2 | |||||||
| KlimaDAO | global | K6 (BCT reserve)+K5 | DAO | inflation by staking | running, reduced | speculation | [IC] |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | K1+K5 | protocol | none | ~7 months | Verra ban 25 May 2022 | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Resource | Measurement | Economy outcome | Economy evidence | Resource outcome | Resource evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| KlimaDAO | global | carbon | model | price collapse 2022 | E4 | none shown | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | carbon | model | ~22m credits bridged | E4 | 28% zombie credits | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Case | Country | Resource | Measurement | Economy outcome | Economy evidence | Resource outcome | Resource evidence | Grade | Independent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ACE Warehouse Receipts, Malawi | Malawi | grain | counted, graded | 710 receipts 2011-2018; 48% profitable; large traders dominant | E4 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Assignats | France | land | declared | near-total loss of value by 1796 | E4 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Banco Palmas and the Palma | Brazil, Fortaleza | none | none | network 167 banks | E4 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Bristol Pound | UK, Bristol | none | none | £1m/yr peak | E5 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Community Exchange System | South Africa, Cape Town | none | none | ~R500,000 traded (est.) | E5 | n/a | n/a | [TBV] | yes |
| Ethiopia Commodity Exchange Receipts | Ethiopia | coffee, grain | counted, graded | minimal finance volumes (latest reported year) | E4 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Fureai Kippu | Japan | none | none | ~0.6% of banked credits redeemed (one network, 2010) | E4 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Ghana Grains Council Warehouse Receipts | Ghana | maize | counted, graded | 47,000 t (2016); about 1.2% of national maize production (2015) | E4 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | none | none | not checked | E5 | n/a | n/a | [TBV] | yes |
| K'Mali | South Africa, Kokstad | none | none | not checked | E5 | n/a | n/a | [TBV] | yes |
| KlimaDAO | global | carbon | model | price collapse 2022 | E4 | none shown | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | land | declared | ~20% of face value by April 1796; worthless by May 1797 | E4 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | land | declared | not checked | E5 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | grain | unknown | not checked | none | n/a | n/a | [TBV] | yes |
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | grain | counted | 3.0 million t (2019/20) | E4 | n/a | n/a | [TBV] | yes |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | none | none | not measured | E5 | n/a | n/a | [TBV] | yes |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | carbon | model | ~22m credits bridged | E4 | 28% zombie credits | E4 | [IC] | yes |
| Virginia Tobacco Notes | USA, Virginia | tobacco | counted, graded | lawful tender for tobacco debts | E4 | quality enforced by burning | none | [IC] | yes |
| WÄRA | Germany | none | none | not measured | E5 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| WIR Bank | Switzerland | none | none | CHF 1,614m turnover, 60,703 enterprise clients, velocity ~2.6 (2005); countercyclical | E2 | n/a | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | none (public works) | none | 12,000 schillings issued; parish tax receipts rose 1931-32 | E3 | 32 chestnut trees replaced; not measured | n/a | [IC] | yes |
| Case | Country | Backing | Principles present | Principles absent | Fit | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resource group grain-and-commodities7 | |||||||
| ACE Warehouse Receipts, Malawi | Malawi | K1 | 1B | good | running since 2011 | [IC] | |
| Ethiopia Commodity Exchange Receipts | Ethiopia | K1 | 1B | 4A | good | running; national system from 2026 | [IC] |
| Ghana Grains Council Warehouse Receipts | Ghana | K1 | 1B | good | running | [IC] | |
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | K1 (claimed) | U | unknown | [TBV] | ||
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | K1 | 1B | good | running | [TBV] | |
| Tanzania Warehouse Receipt System | Tanzania | K1 | 1B, 2B, 8 | good | running | [IC] | |
| Virginia Tobacco Notes | USA, Virginia | K1 | 1B, 2B, 6 | 1A, 4A, 4B | partial | ~25 yrs as money | [IC] |
| Resource group land3 | |||||||
| Assignats | France | K2, then fiat | 1B, 3 | 1A, 4A, 4B | mismatch | 7 yrs | [IC] |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | K2 | 1B, 3 | 1A | mismatch | <1 yr | [IC] |
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | K2 (secured, not redeemable) | 1B | 7 | U | 1 yr | [IC] |
| Resource group no-resource-backing13 | |||||||
| Banco Palmas and the Palma | Brazil, Fortaleza | K6 | 7, 8 | n/a | 26 yrs | [IC] | |
| Bristol Pound | UK, Bristol | K6 | n/a | 9 yrs | [IC] | ||
| Chiemgauer | Germany, Bavaria | K6 | n/a | 23 yrs | [MS] | ||
| Community Exchange System | South Africa, Cape Town | K7 | 1A, 8 | n/a | 23 yrs | [TBV] | |
| Fureai Kippu | Japan | K7 | 1A, 8 | n/a | over 50 yrs; stalled after 2000 | [IC] | |
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | K7 | 1A | n/a | ~20 yrs | [TBV] | |
| K'Mali | South Africa, Kokstad | K7 | n/a | unknown | [TBV] | ||
| Sarafu Community Inclusion Currency | Kenya | K7, K6 partial | 4A | n/a | 9 yrs | [IC] | |
| Sardex | Italy, Sardinia | K7 | 1A | n/a | 17 yrs | [IC] | |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | K6 | n/a | ~1 yr | [TBV] | ||
| WÄRA | Germany | K6 | 7 | n/a | ~5 yrs | [IC] | |
| WIR Bank | Switzerland | K7 | 1A | n/a | 92 yrs | [IC] | |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | K6+K3 | 1A, 3, 4A | 7 | n/a | 14 months | [IC] |
| Resource group ecological-work3 | |||||||
| Bangla-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | K7+K3 | 1A, 7 | n/a | 13 yrs; banned May 2013, relaunched November 2013 | [IC] | |
| Eco-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | K6+K3 | 1A, 2B, 7 | 4A, 4B | partial | ~1 yr | [MS] |
| Grassroots Economics Commitment Pools | Kenya, Kilifi | K7+K3, K6 partial | 8 | 4B | U | about 3 yrs on Celo | [MS] |
| Resource group carbon-and-nature-tokens3 | |||||||
| KlimaDAO | global | K6 (BCT reserve)+K5 | 1A, 1B, 4B | mismatch | running, reduced | [IC] | |
| Regen Network Ecocredits | global | K5+K4 | 4B | U | running | [MS] | |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | K1+K5 | 1A, 1B, 2A, 3, 4B | mismatch | ~7 months | [IC] | |
| Case | Country | Backing | Principles present | Principles absent | Fit | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Assignats | France | K2, then fiat | 1B, 3 | 1A, 4A, 4B | mismatch | 7 yrs | [IC] |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | K2 | 1B, 3 | 1A | mismatch | <1 yr | [IC] |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | K6+K3 | 1A, 3, 4A | 7 | n/a | 14 months | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Backing | Principles present | Principles absent | Fit | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | K2 (secured, not redeemable) | 1B | 7 | U | 1 yr | [IC] |
| WÄRA | Germany | K6 | 7 | n/a | ~5 yrs | [IC] | |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | K6+K3 | 1A, 3, 4A | 7 | n/a | 14 months | [IC] |
| Case | Country | Backing | Principles present | Principles absent | Fit | Persistence | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fit good5 | |||||||
| ACE Warehouse Receipts, Malawi | Malawi | K1 | 1B | good | running since 2011 | [IC] | |
| Ethiopia Commodity Exchange Receipts | Ethiopia | K1 | 1B | 4A | good | running; national system from 2026 | [IC] |
| Ghana Grains Council Warehouse Receipts | Ghana | K1 | 1B | good | running | [IC] | |
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | K1 | 1B | good | running | [TBV] | |
| Tanzania Warehouse Receipt System | Tanzania | K1 | 1B, 2B, 8 | good | running | [IC] | |
| Fit mismatch4 | |||||||
| Assignats | France | K2, then fiat | 1B, 3 | 1A, 4A, 4B | mismatch | 7 yrs | [IC] |
| KlimaDAO | global | K6 (BCT reserve)+K5 | 1A, 1B, 4B | mismatch | running, reduced | [IC] | |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | K2 | 1B, 3 | 1A | mismatch | <1 yr | [IC] |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | K1+K5 | 1A, 1B, 2A, 3, 4B | mismatch | ~7 months | [IC] | |
| Fit n/a14 | |||||||
| Banco Palmas and the Palma | Brazil, Fortaleza | K6 | 7, 8 | n/a | 26 yrs | [IC] | |
| Bangla-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | K7+K3 | 1A, 7 | n/a | 13 yrs; banned May 2013, relaunched November 2013 | [IC] | |
| Bristol Pound | UK, Bristol | K6 | n/a | 9 yrs | [IC] | ||
| Chiemgauer | Germany, Bavaria | K6 | n/a | 23 yrs | [MS] | ||
| Community Exchange System | South Africa, Cape Town | K7 | 1A, 8 | n/a | 23 yrs | [TBV] | |
| Fureai Kippu | Japan | K7 | 1A, 8 | n/a | over 50 yrs; stalled after 2000 | [IC] | |
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | K7 | 1A | n/a | ~20 yrs | [TBV] | |
| K'Mali | South Africa, Kokstad | K7 | n/a | unknown | [TBV] | ||
| Sarafu Community Inclusion Currency | Kenya | K7, K6 partial | 4A | n/a | 9 yrs | [IC] | |
| Sardex | Italy, Sardinia | K7 | 1A | n/a | 17 yrs | [IC] | |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | K6 | n/a | ~1 yr | [TBV] | ||
| WÄRA | Germany | K6 | 7 | n/a | ~5 yrs | [IC] | |
| WIR Bank | Switzerland | K7 | 1A | n/a | 92 yrs | [IC] | |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | K6+K3 | 1A, 3, 4A | 7 | n/a | 14 months | [IC] |
| Fit partial2 | |||||||
| Eco-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | K6+K3 | 1A, 2B, 7 | 4A, 4B | partial | ~1 yr | [MS] |
| Virginia Tobacco Notes | USA, Virginia | K1 | 1B, 2B, 6 | 1A, 4A, 4B | partial | ~25 yrs as money | [IC] |
| Fit U4 | |||||||
| Grassroots Economics Commitment Pools | Kenya, Kilifi | K7+K3, K6 partial | 8 | 4B | U | about 3 yrs on Celo | [MS] |
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | K2 (secured, not redeemable) | 1B | 7 | U | 1 yr | [IC] |
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | K1 (claimed) | U | unknown | [TBV] | ||
| Regen Network Ecocredits | global | K5+K4 | 4B | U | running | [MS] | |
| Case | Country | Sources | Last checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Resource group no-resource-backing4 | |||
| Community Exchange System | South Africa, Cape Town | Wikipedia | 2026-11-10 |
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | Wikipedia | 2026-11-10 |
| K'Mali | South Africa, Kokstad | Wikipedia | 2026-11-10 |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | Champ 2008; Fisher and Cohrssen 1933 | 2026-11-10 |
| Resource group grain-and-commodities2 | |||
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | Monson 2009 | 2026-11-10 |
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | Thunde and Baulch 2020 | 2026-11-10 |
| Case | Country | Grade | Last checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| ACE Warehouse Receipts, Malawi | Malawi | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Assignats | France | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Banco Palmas and the Palma | Brazil, Fortaleza | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Bangla-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Bristol Pound | UK, Bristol | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Chiemgauer | Germany, Bavaria | [MS] | 2026-11-10 |
| Community Exchange System | South Africa, Cape Town | [TBV] | 2026-11-10 |
| Eco-Pesa | Kenya, Mombasa | [MS] | 2026-11-10 |
| Ethiopia Commodity Exchange Receipts | Ethiopia | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Fureai Kippu | Japan | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Ghana Grains Council Warehouse Receipts | Ghana | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Grassroots Economics Commitment Pools | Kenya, Kilifi | [MS] | 2026-11-10 |
| Ithaca HOURS | USA, New York | [TBV] | 2026-11-10 |
| KlimaDAO | global | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| K'Mali | South Africa, Kokstad | [TBV] | 2026-11-10 |
| Mandats Territoriaux | France | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Massachusetts Land Bank | USA, Massachusetts | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Ptolemaic Grain Banking | Egypt | [TBV] | 2026-11-10 |
| Regen Network Ecocredits | global | [MS] | 2026-11-10 |
| SAFEX Electronic Silo Certificates | South Africa | [TBV] | 2026-11-10 |
| Sarafu Community Inclusion Currency | Kenya | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Sardex | Italy, Sardinia | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Stamp Scrip in the United States | USA | [TBV] | 2026-11-10 |
| Tanzania Warehouse Receipt System | Tanzania | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Toucan Base Carbon Tonne | global | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Virginia Tobacco Notes | USA, Virginia | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| WÄRA | Germany | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| WIR Bank | Switzerland | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |
| Wörgl Labor Certificates | Austria, Wörgl | [IC] | 2026-11-10 |